<<Does anyone think that the results of this auction of high end silver Kennedies will cause a lasting increase in the value of lower grade examples of the same coins; or will they not increase in value?>>
I think it will help those a grade or two below top pop. But it might not help the low end. BTW I do think you (SanctionII) will have increased competition for those un-cherried proof sets!
Badger: I wish I bought a '56 Half in 69 DCAM from Rick Tomaska back in the '90s when I was putting together my '56 registry proof set. If I remember correctly he was asking around 1 grand at the time which I felt was just too much!
Just for interests sakes does anyone here think that there is a significant difference VISUALLY betweeen a high end 1962 Franklin in PR68DCAM and one in PR69DCAM? I've been collecting DCAM/UCAM Franklins for ~20 years now and I'd bet I couldn't tell the difference. A PR69DCAM CERTAINLY isn't worth 10 times as much as a PR68DCAM IMO. Russ, what is your feeling about the price differential for these SMS and AH Kennedy's versus one's 1 grade lower? Is it worth the differential, or is it crazy?
I attended this auction this afternoon...one of the purchases I made was one of Parke's proof Kennedys (not one of the big 4)...and I was the underbidder on a few others. The action was fast...and none of the big 4 were purchased by floor bidders...3 of those went to internet bids...and one was thru HA.com Live.
<< <i>Russ, what is your feeling about the price differential for these SMS and AH Kennedy's versus one's 1 grade lower? Is it worth the differential, or is it crazy? >>
It depends on the coin, and it also depends on how you define "is it worth the differential". Comparing the 1967 MS68DCAM that just sold to my MS67DCAM example, no, I don't think it's worth the differential. Based on the images, I believe mine is a better coin. That said, if the 68DCAM was significantly better than mine and if I had the money to buy it, I would. I would also buy the 1966, and the 1965, (if it was all there for the grade). The fact that cannot be argued is that these coins are genuinely rare in these grades, and are nearly impossible to replace. Coins that are nearly impossible to replace tend to appreciate in value over the long-term.
<< <i>The action was fast...and none of the big 4 were purchased by floor bidders...3 of those went to internet bids...and one was thru HA.com Live. >>
True, but the three that went to internet bidders were pushed several increments higher by floor bidders. The one that went through HA.com Live, (the 1967), didn't seem to generate much interest from the floor.
OK. So I was not successful on any of the Franklins at Platinum Night. I was underbidder on the 1954. Happy to see the 1959 accel since I have one that I think is as nice. Ran the bidding up prior to Live Auction on the 1960. It was a fantastic coin, but I just couldn't see going to $30k.
Most of the Kennedys look like they did roughly as one could expect. Decent showing on 1964-1967 dates. Yes, the 76-S Clad was a little stronger than I expected, but the 76-S Silver at $3,000 plus the juice was as expected, if not a touch weak for this type of auction (remember that coin used to be a solid $4,000 - $5,000 coin). Both 71-S pieces in the sale look like they failed to achieve even $1,000 with the juice - not all that great. The 81-S Ty2 continues to be a challenging coin to locate and did as I expected if not a touch stronger. Coins like the 99-S Silver (and many of the other "typical" dates in the series) continue to slip a bit. Ditto for 2000-2003 Clad 70's - dropping off their highs now.
All in all - I think the auction went well for Parke on the few coins that actually appeared thus far in the major sale - but, unless I am mistaken - didn't a big piece of the #1 Kennedy set not even appear at auction yet as coins got moved to the post-FUN internet sale? If so, personally, I would have liked to see Parke's entire set auctioned at the very same time. IMHO, the "frenzy" is often times not the same days later.
Congrats to Parke on a great collection and "carrying the torch" where Edson left off.
Wondercoin
Please visit my website at www.wondercoins.com and my ebay auctions under my user name www.wondercoin.com.
“A nation can survive its fools, and even the ambitious. But it cannot survive treason from within. An enemy at the gates is less formidable, for he is known and carries his banner openly."
<< <i>but, unless I am mistaken - didn't a big piece of the #1 Kennedy set not even appear at auction yet as coins got moved to the post-FUN internet sale? >>
They didn't get "moved", they started there. Only the really tough coins were in the Signature Sale. It really wouldn't make sense to have the easy material in a Signature Sale.
I had to go back to work today after bidding last night. Everyone had to hear how the big ones got away. My coworkers pointed out that I was being schizophrenic. Did I want coin prices to go down so I could add to the registry set - or - up to raise the intrinsic value? Not sure I have an answer. It was great to be able to view Parke's coins however. Congrats to Parke on the sale.
Badger
Collector of Modern Silver Proofs 1950-1964 -- PCGS Registry as Elite Cameo
<< <i>OK. So I was not successful on any of the Franklins at Platinum Night. I was underbidder on the 1954. Happy to see the 1959 accel since I have an one that I think is as nice. Ran the bidding up prior to Live Auction on the 1960. It was a fantastic coin, but I just couldn't see going to $30k.
Comments
I think it will help those a grade or two below top pop. But it might not help the low end. BTW I do think you (SanctionII) will have increased competition for those un-cherried proof sets!
Badger: I wish I bought a '56 Half in 69 DCAM from Rick Tomaska back in the '90s when I was putting together my '56 registry proof set. If I remember correctly he was asking around 1 grand at the time which I felt was just too much!
I am already kicking myself for not bidding higher on the 1956.
Badger
Link to 1950 - 1964 Proof Registry Set
1938 - 1964 Proof Jeffersons w/ Varieties
U.S. Type Set
Then, you look back after a few years and you could kick
yourself, for not paying the too much price back then.
Camelot
The action was fast...and none of the big 4 were purchased by floor bidders...3 of those went to internet bids...and one was thru HA.com Live.
COMPLETE KENNEDY VARIETY SET, CIRCULATION STRIKES AND PROOFS
1964 MINT SET
<< <i>Russ, what is your feeling about the price differential for these SMS and AH Kennedy's versus one's 1 grade lower? Is it worth the differential, or is it crazy? >>
It depends on the coin, and it also depends on how you define "is it worth the differential". Comparing the 1967 MS68DCAM that just sold to my MS67DCAM example, no, I don't think it's worth the differential. Based on the images, I believe mine is a better coin. That said, if the 68DCAM was significantly better than mine and if I had the money to buy it, I would. I would also buy the 1966, and the 1965, (if it was all there for the grade). The fact that cannot be argued is that these coins are genuinely rare in these grades, and are nearly impossible to replace. Coins that are nearly impossible to replace tend to appreciate in value over the long-term.
Russ, NCNE
and to think I could have had a V8 instead.
<< <i>The action was fast...and none of the big 4 were purchased by floor bidders...3 of those went to internet bids...and one was thru HA.com Live. >>
True, but the three that went to internet bidders were pushed several increments higher by floor bidders. The one that went through HA.com Live, (the 1967), didn't seem to generate much interest from the floor.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>one of the purchases I made was one of Parke's proof Kennedys >>
Which one did you get? And, please stay away from the ones coming up in four days.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>Which one did you get? And, please stay away from the ones coming up in four days. >>
We bought the 2003 clad...and my son already has me committed to bidding on some of those going off next week for his set...
COMPLETE KENNEDY VARIETY SET, CIRCULATION STRIKES AND PROOFS
1964 MINT SET
1954 PR68 Dcam $23k
1959 PR67 Dcam $18.4k
1960 PR69 Dcam $27.6k
Now I see that it is going to take $20-30k per coin to upgrade my collection.
I think I may have lost second place in Franklin proofs.
Badger
Link to 1950 - 1964 Proof Registry Set
1938 - 1964 Proof Jeffersons w/ Varieties
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>Previous auctions were half or more. >>
Care to elaborate with details on your research? Not one isolated sale...but rather market trends...
COMPLETE KENNEDY VARIETY SET, CIRCULATION STRIKES AND PROOFS
1964 MINT SET
All in all - I think the auction went well for Parke on the few coins that actually appeared thus far in the major sale - but, unless I am mistaken - didn't a big piece of the #1 Kennedy set not even appear at auction yet as coins got moved to the post-FUN internet sale? If so, personally, I would have liked to see Parke's entire set auctioned at the very same time. IMHO, the "frenzy" is often times not the same days later.
Congrats to Parke on a great collection and "carrying the torch" where Edson left off.
Wondercoin
<< <i>Man, those are some strong numbers!
Russ, NCNE >>
Yeah, they are.
U.S. Type Set
- Marcus Tullius Cicero, 106-43 BC
<< <i>but, unless I am mistaken - didn't a big piece of the #1 Kennedy set not even appear at auction yet as coins got moved to the post-FUN internet sale? >>
They didn't get "moved", they started there. Only the really tough coins were in the Signature Sale. It really wouldn't make sense to have the easy material in a Signature Sale.
Russ, NCNE
Could be. Many thousands spent (wasted?) for commonly seen coins.
”Isn't learning fun?"
The Learning Channel
Badger
Link to 1950 - 1964 Proof Registry Set
1938 - 1964 Proof Jeffersons w/ Varieties
<< <i>I am already kicking myself for not bidding higher on the 1956. >>
I bought the 1956 for my type set.
Who is John Galt?
<< <i>OK. So I was not successful on any of the Franklins at Platinum Night. I was underbidder on the 1954. Happy to see the 1959 accel since I have an one that I think is as nice. Ran the bidding up prior to Live Auction on the 1960. It was a fantastic coin, but I just couldn't see going to $30k.
1954 PR68 Dcam $23k
1959 PR67 Dcam $18.4k
1960 PR69 Dcam $27.6k
Now I see that it is going to take $20-30k per coin to upgrade my collection.
I think I may have lost second place in Franklin proofs.
Badger >>
Congrats on the 1956. It is a super coin. Let me know if you are ever divesting.
Badger
Link to 1950 - 1964 Proof Registry Set
1938 - 1964 Proof Jeffersons w/ Varieties
<< <i>Many thousands spent (wasted?) for commonly seen coins. >>
Commonly seen? Please send me some of these coins you're commonly seeing.
Russ, NCNE
Russ, NCNE