Two CBH's that I need your opinions on

Goldbully

I thought this was a great deal, do you?????

Link1

I also thought that this was a great deal..........

Link2

Your thoughts and comments are very important to me.......I'll explain later, maybe.


Please PM me if you want the details.

Barndog

is the 1836 really an UNC?

Goldbully

<< <i>is the 1836 really an UNC? >>




NGC says so....what say you, Barndog???

Barndog

got to see it in hand, tilt it around in the light, look for luster breaks.

Goldbully

<< <i>got to see it in hand, tilt it around in the light, look for luster breaks. >>



I understand, that would be nice, but the buyer can only buy on the grade and seller's reputation....knowing he can return to seller.

My main question is this......If this NGC graded coin is a truly acceptable MS62 is $1150 a good price to a collector???

Barndog

<< <i>

<< <i>got to see it in hand, tilt it around in the light, look for luster breaks. >>



I understand, that would be nice, but the buyer can only buy on the grade and seller's reputation....knowing he can return to seller.

My main question is this......If this NGC graded coin is a truly acceptable MS62 is $1150 a good price to a collector??? >>



check comparables prices here

bidask

The 1836 looks okay.....but that 1834 is awful dark and the right obverse field and left reverse field look even darker. No pizzaz to it.

Maybe the picture?

cape

i have 2 34's in stock and they all seem to be dark. i like both coins and i can tell you that dick is a good guy and if you didn't like the coin he would certainly let you return it .

mozin

This seller knows his Busties, and I have no reason to think he would be asking more than a fair profit. He does take coins on consignment, so sometimes he is required to jack up the price to make a reasonable profit. I do not know the story on these two Busties.

My feeling is that the common marriage 1825-36 Busties are bringing too much money recently. They are simply too plentiful to deserve such high prices. Also, a NGC 61 or NGC 62 Bustie seems to bring only PCGS 58 money. Usually, I would rather own a PQ PCGS 58 than a low MS NGC coin.

Goldbully

<< <i>This seller knows his Busties, and I have no reason to think he would be asking more than a fair profit. He does take coins on consignment, so sometimes he is required to jack up the price to make a reasonable profit. I do not know the story on these two Busties.

My feeling is that the common marriage 1825-36 Busties are bringing too much money recently. They are simply too plentiful to deserve such high prices. Also, a NGC 61 or NGC 62 Bustie seems to bring only PCGS 58 money. Usually, I would rather own a PQ PCGS 58 than a low MS NGC coin. >>




Thanks for your advice and candor, mozin.

I like this gentleman also, met him in Baltimore.