Finally a serious Satin Finish coin (Roosie) has been made!!!

Stooge

A serious applause goes to Coinfame (<--Name now fits) for making the first ever Unique pop (1/0) 2007-P MS70FB/SF Roosevelt Dime. This coin looks great in that 70 slab.

2007 P ROOSEVELT 10c PCGS MS70FB!!! ~SATIN FINISH~



Coinfame...Here is a six pack for ya!

Later, Paul.

CoinFame

Thanks Paul!

mas3387

Congratulations CoinFame



But of all coins a Dime,

Ok, so you did good anyway the First Ever Full Band MS70 !!!!!

Datentype

Nice job Seth! What's up with the ten grand? I didn't even ask half that for my 2007-d Kennedy in 70

wondercoin

Congrats Seth!

I believe the Price Guide is setting the price of the Jeff $1 MS70 around $3,500 this week. The dime mght be about as desireable as the $1 the way I see it.

Good to see PCGS looking for those 70's!

Wondercoin

mas3387

<< <i>Nice job Seth! What's up with the ten grand? I didn't even ask half that for my 2007-d Kennedy in 70 >>



If the Kennedy stays Pop 1 I'm sure the buyer did real well

CoinFame

<< <i>

<< <i>Nice job Seth! What's up with the ten grand? I didn't even ask half that for my 2007-d Kennedy in 70 >>

If the Kennedy stays Pop 1 I'm sure the buyer did real well >>



Yes, a unique Kennedy could be worth $10,000 if it stays that way. MS70 Kennedys have happened before, whereas a 70FB dime hasn't ever been made.



<< <i>I believe the Price Guide is setting the price of the Jeff $1 MS70 around $3,500 this week. The dime mght be about as desireable as the $1 the way I see it. >>



Do you know of a MS70 Jefferson that is available currently for $3,500? If so, I'm very interested! The current owner of the coin won't sell it...

The price guide is just that, a GUIDE to help buyers understand the value of a coin. It will change depending on a variety of factors. One of those factors happens to be dealer input and the other is actual sales. If you hand me the 70 Jefferson I'll make sure the price guide editor hears about the new confirmed sale price.

I am not putting a hard price on this unique coin. Make an offer. I am happy to look at it in my set, it may even be a tie breaker coin for a Type Set, Mint Set, or the Roosevelt registry.

Merry Christmas!

Datentype

As pop 1/0 coins i would value the 3 2007 pcgs 70 SF coins as follows based upon popularity of the series and the propensity of buyers that collect those series to shell out serious funds for the coins: 2007-D jefferson presidential $6,000, 2007-D kennedy $5,000 and 2007-P Roosey $4,000 (at highest). I hope Seth finds a buyer at $10,000 for the coin as value is a personal thing. I do believe the coin will remain pop 1/0 as well as the others made but one never knows.

Seroiusly though, your most likely buyer for a Roosey is not going to be a Roosey collector but a "best of mint" set collector as roosey collector's are notoriously frugal and barely willing to shell out a few hundred bucks on pop 5 or 6 coins from my experience. Even pop 1 or 2 coins they tend to way underspend as compared to some of the more popular series such as state quarters, lincoln's and Super Sac's. I mean come on there is probably a line around the corner for people willing to pay $2,000 for a 2003-d in 68 and the pop is in the thirites. NGC graded silver proof delawares in 70UC still sell for around $2,000 each and the pop is over 200 in that grade.

wondercoin

Seth - Do you know - was the "actual sales price" of the Jeff $1 MS70 higher than the $3,500 opening level in the guide? I think Mark is about right on the half dollar and dime pricing. And, hopefully, the guide will rise on the $1 MS70 rather than drop - that would sure be the goal I suspect of the editor.

I heard the pop 2 KS MS70 from a couple years ago just sold for around $3,500- $4,000? That is instructional if true as well. Wondercoin

rcmlgm89

Congratulations Seth

mas3387

This post started off a Congratulations to the maker of the first ever Roosevelt Dime in MS70 Full Bands and it did not take long for it to turn into a debate about the asking price which as I see it has a best offer option. Moon money, maybe? But for now there is only One Satin Finish Roosevelt Dime in a PCGS MS70FB holder and CoinFame has it!!!!

We saw a few months ago a 2003 MS70 Lincoln was made and feedback I received about the coin was that it was not worth $7500.00. The coin made its way to TeleTrade and we watched the coin sell for 13 or 14K + the juice on TT!!!! Couldn’t we see the same for a coin like this?



<< <i>I believe the Price Guide is setting the price of the Jeff $1 MS70 around $3,500 this week. >>



With only one coin on the pop report and a private sale of it I Wonder how the around $3500.00 price tag had been set for the guide



<< <i>Seth - Do you know - was the "actual sales price" of the Jeff $1 MS70 higher than the $3,500 opening level in the guide? I >>



I thought I heard it was population rather than "actual sales price" that the Guide was based on, make a coin the price goes down



<< <i>The price guide is just that, a GUIDE to help buyers understand the value of a coin. It will change depending on a variety of factors. One of those factors happens to be dealer input and the other is actual sales. If you hand me the 70 Jefferson I'll make sure the price guide editor hears about the new confirmed sale price. >>



No comment for now

I heard too many times that when you have a coin such as this it's not worth xxxx but when another dealer has it, you know it's golden.

Seth for now Enjoy the Coin !!!!!!

Forgot we have another Congratulations in order,

Way to go Mark on the 2007 D Kennedy SF MS70 !!!!!

Stooge

If you noticed, I never 1X mentioned the price, but since it is the first MS70FB and only the second MS70 Roosie, I would gladly pay 10K for the coin..if I had the loot. I believe PCGS harshly grades Roosevelts from 2005-date. I have send some whoppers in for grading and the best is a 7FB (BS).

Seth...did you happen to make any '07-P 9FB's?

Congrats again!!

Later, Paul.

mas3387

The 2007P SF in MS69FB is a tough coin for us, we made ZERO so far!!!!!



<< <i>Congrats again!! >>



I agree

Datentype

Stooge, I'm sure Seth would work out a payment plan for you for the 10K $833 for the next 12 months assuming no interest.

DIMEMAN

You could take that 70 and put a bunch of 69's with it...cover the grades and NO ONE could pick out the 70 on a regular basis.

You can get a 69FB for around 50 bucks. Let me see 50 bucks 10k....50 bucks 10k...give me the 69

Datentype

Dimeman, I dissagree. Most MS 70's in pcgs holders are far and above the quality of anything else especially with the verification system in place at PCGS.

Griv

I know this is driving you dime guys crazy. Let me see, sell the car no, maybe a 2nd mortgage or sell some of the wife's jewelry, nah, maybe . . .


Congrats Seth!

Silverstate

OK,

I want a MS70 Pres $ too!

There are just never too many around, thus the prices...

The coin was up and gone in 1/2 a heartbeat !!

mas3387

<< <i>I want a MS70 Pres $ too! >>



Working on it,

Stooge

<< <i>Stooge, I'm sure Seth would work out a payment plan for you for the 10K $833 for the next 12 months assuming no interest. >>

CoinFame

<< <i>If you noticed, I never 1X mentioned the price, but since it is the first MS70FB and only the second MS70 Roosie, I would gladly pay 10K for the coin..if I had the loot. I believe PCGS harshly grades Roosevelts from 2005-date. I have send some whoppers in for grading and the best is a 7FB (BS). Seth...did you happen to make any '07-P 9FB's? Congrats again!! Later, Paul. >>



Thanks for the congrats Paul. We found I believe 4 or 5 of the MS69FBs out of the 25 or so on the pop report so far. That's a very low # for how many 1000's of mint sets have been searched. So for there to be a 70FB is absolutely amazing!

XXX

<< <i>Seth - Do you know - was the "actual sales price" of the Jeff $1 MS70 higher than the $3,500 opening level in the guide? I think Mark is about right on the half dollar and dime pricing. And, hopefully, the guide will rise on the $1 MS70 rather than drop - that would sure be the goal I suspect of the editor.

I heard the pop 2 KS MS70 from a couple years ago just sold for around $3,500- $4,000? That is instructional if true as well. Wondercoin >>



Mitch,

Why don't you ask me instead of speculating. (you have my cell phone number). I own the coin. Remember, the one you have never seen? (And its all 70 and Solid for the grade) So ask me, not the boards. Oh, and yes it was HIGHER. (was the "actual sales price" of the Jeff $1 MS70 higher than the $3,500 opening level in the guide?) I really don't care what the price guides say.......try buying one at 4K opening level, then we can talk what the real number and legitamate offers to purchase it have been.

I don't know why people dog the other "makers" and try to cheapen the value of their hard work by posts like this.

Congrats Seth for the 70 Dime, Mark for the 70 D-Kenn and the maker of the only (to date) MS70 Pres $1 (whom wishes to remain annonimous, publicly).

With out "all of you", some of us would only personally be making a handful (50-60%) of the coins we need to continue building "Fine Sets". Trust me I know.

Said my peice, now I can continue to lurk for another 6 months.

XXX

Congrats Seth........You KNOW I have to have that coin (Damn It).

Well be talking buddy. WH

XXX

<< <i>

<< <i>I want a MS70 Pres $ too! >>



Working on it, >>



Micheal, Don't work tooo hard on it until say July 08.................Right after the set competitions. Thanks.

Nobody wants these stupid dollars anyways. All they are good for are coke machines.

mas3387

Walt I like you sometimes,



<< <i>You KNOW I have to have that coin (Damn It). >>



Better hurry I hear there 2 - 3 others wanting it also!!!!

wondercoin

XXX - Will do. Calling now.

Obviously, the guide should not be lower than what you paid. The editor picked that $3500 figure but I certainly could not debate the number with the limited information I had (although I believe I know who actually slabbed it, but of course, whatever he may have netted on the sale was not the same number as what you paid for the coin).

Wondercoin

mas3387

<< <i>don't know why people dog the other "makers" and try to cheapen the value of their hard work by posts like this. >>



You know Walt your right, when the other guy's post coins with or without pricing you don't see the other "makers" dogging their coins to cheapen the value.

Seth, hope you get all the money you deserve it!!!!!!

Congrats again!!!!

eCoinquest

I don't know why people dog the other "makers" and try to cheapen the value of their hard work by posts like this.

Hey XXX,
I am glad you pointed that out. I have been thinking that for a long time.

Congrats Seth! Good luck with the sale.

CoinFame

Thank you Hany, Michael, Mark, & all who have posted congrats. It's a fun thing to see a monster show up after the many moons spent searching. Anyone that has sat down to 1000 mint sets at a time knows what I'm talking about.



<< <i>Congrats Seth........You KNOW I have to have that coin (Damn It). Well be talking buddy. WH >>



Thank You Walt. While we have not accepted an offer yet, I believe it's not going to last long.

CoinFame

I rudely forgot to thank you Ron, Walt, & Mitch for your congratulations. Thank YOU!