Grading a card with a hole punch

Counselor

Just bought a 1948 Leaf Dimaggio with a hole punch in the top left corner. Rest of card is VG/EX. I am sure it is authentic. Do you think PSA will give this a grade of "1" or will they label it "authentic"?

Thanks

packCollector

authentic I believe is all they will do

Allen

I think they will give it a 1 since it is not altered. Not sure, I mean it is like a pin hole but bigger.....

Stone193

That's an interesting question.

They grade a tack hole a PSA 1.

So, the card has been punched - but not altered IMO. It's like a large tack hole.

So why not give it a PSA 1?

mike

rube26105

i saw some 51 bowman fb on one time so nut took a hole puch too,ruined all the good cards like sammy baugh,his name was punched out,it was slabbed though,i think it was authentic

metalmike

lol -he card prolly belonged to some madman-It's my card dammitt. Reminds me when my sis "signed" HER cards.

bigfische

Kit Young i think has an sgc 10 '33 goudey ruth with a paper punch hole through it.

frankhardy

Send it to PRO - sounds like it's a lock PRO 9.

fandango

theres a pretty wide range for a PSA 1...you can have small pieces missing and it will get a PSA 1

authentic usually means its trimmed...

zippy

It's a PSA 1 or Poor, take your Pick