Gradewise, which one do you like better? Why?

bidask

Or this one?

rec78

The top one--stronger strike-less wear-better definition

coinpictures

Top one. Don't like the "splotchiness" of the bottom one as much.

ajaan

First one

Stork

Top one looks nicer to me. Thank you for your generous giveaway (--someone had to say it )


Cathy

Hussulo

I like the look of the top coin better. I wouldn't be surprised if they were both the same grade but the toning on the second coin hides some of the details and makes it appear a bit flat.

Meiji

I like the strong look of the first one. Nice luster too.