E93 price difference between PSA/SGC 5 Eddie Collins

interchanges

Sheez, was watching a few cards in Heritage's auction that ended last night and was surprised to see the price difference between an SGC EX graded Eddie Collins, and a PSA one.

Is this common? I don't pay that much attention. For the price that was paid, this is quite a substantial price difference.
Probably doesn't help they photographed the PSA card askew in the mylar sleeve. But still!

vintagetoppsguy

It's asking me to sign in to view the prices. Can you just tell me?

interchanges

Shoot. Didn't think of that. I even previewed my post to make sure it would work.

Anyway, the SGC went for $1673.00

PSA went for $956.00

oaktown

<< <i>Shoot. Didn't think of that. I even previewed my post to make sure it would work.

Anyway, the SGC went for $1673.00

PSA went for $956.00 >>





I think the tilt in the PSA holder may have had some impact on the price difference.

vintagetoppsguy

That may have had something to do with it, but the SGC card is just a much better looking card for the grade. The centering is about the same on both, but the SGC card has less corner wear than the PSA card. Also, look at the indention on the PSA card - right border, half way up.

yawie99

The SGC card is nicer, but the presentation of the PSA card couldn't have helped.

SoonerCowboy

SGC definitely better. Look at the big "hunk" taken out of the side on the PSA one.