Grade my Newps-- 2 better date Peace Dollars

twodrhrdtp

These are in holders. I just want to get a concensus.

1928 S


1934 S

tightbudget

62
Cleaned

Crazy4Coins

63 on the 28-S

55 on the 34-S....looks more like some harsh hairlines rather than cleaning to me.

Animalkeeper

62 on the 28-S. Nice luster, several dings/scrapes.
50 maybe 53 on 34-S on a good day (45 on a bad one), possible cleaning, maybe not?

Tbar

62


45

PrivateCoinCollector

If I could grade a Peace dollar I would stop collecting them.

twodrhrdtp

I have been cracking out all my Peace dollars and putting them in my Wayte Raymond album. If the 34 S is cleaned I think it should stay holdered. I guess I will tell you it is a PCI green holder EF40. Leave it or crack it? More opinions would be very helpful. Thanks

robkool

I would recommend leaving that 34 s in its holder, it has some scratches on it, possibly cleaned. I would have graded it AU 50. It's difficult to tell without looking at it in hand.