FS grades in. How did I do?

hiijacker

Does this reflect how hard it is to get a 70, or do I just suck in a bad or good way?

2007-W $10 Martha Washington US MS69
2007-W $10 Martha Washington US MS70
2007-W $10 Martha Washington US MS69
2007-W $10 Martha Washington US MS69
2007-W $10 Martha Washington US MS69
2007-W $10 Abigail Adams US MS69
2007-W $10 Abigail Adams US MS69
2007-W $10 Abigail Adams US MS69
2007-W $10 Abigail Adams US MS69
2007-W $10 Abigail Adams US MS69
2007-W $10 Abigail Adams US PR69DC
2007-W $10 Abigail Adams US PR69DC
2007-W $10 Abigail Adams US PR69DC
2007-W $10 Abigail Adams US PR69DC
2007-W $10 Abigail Adams US PR69DC

Rampage

Congrats on the MS70.

FLBuffaloHunter

Send the MS69's to NGC at least 75% will come back 70's. Now you see why PCGS 70's sell for considerably more!

hiijacker

Anyone know what the general ratio or odds of getting a 70 with pcgs is? Given I only made one, I would think I did worse than average.


Than again, I went cheap and submitted under the modern grading, do you think this had an effect?

morgansforever

Send the 69's back. I believe Russ stated,"If the grade don't fit then resubmit"

TomB

The PCGS pop reports show approximately 21% of the MW and AA mint state coins receive MS70 grades. At 10% you are obviously below that average, but truly if you simply had one more MS70 you would be right on target.

hiijacker

Just checked the pops looks like the chances of getting a 70 is 15%

FLBuffaloHunter

Combined MS70 percentage is 20% PR70 14%:







Compared to 57% MS70 & 56% PF70 for NGC:

coinman420

<< <i>Anyone know what the general ratio or odds of getting a 70 with pcgs is? Given I only made one, I would think I did worse than average.


Than again, I went cheap and submitted under the modern grading, do you think this had an effect? >>



3 70`s on a 10 coin submission was my best. usually its 1 or 2 per submission.



the service level won`t make any difference(i think).

hiijacker

Any thoughts if service level makes a difference?

Coxe

I wonder how many people look at the pop report seeing FS for Jeff nickels going way back and are amazed that there is such a fuss still today about those "first strikes".

Rampage

The graders look at all coins equally, regardless of what service they were submitted under. If I were you, I'd be happy with what the grades were.