Every once in a while.....

PrivateCoinCollector

We get lucky. I had no clue this was an overdate when I sent it in. Bought it as a common Unc.

5 1 13990035 7122 1880/9-S $1 overdate US MS63

AUandAG

Wow, nice! What a pleasant surprise and boost in value!

bob

DennisH

That's the VAM 11 coin. Grey Sheet Ask for a regular 1880-S in MS63 is $39, but here are the actual sales prices of the last six PCGS VAM 11s I have records for in that grade:

1880-S 11 63 PCGS Feb-07 E $123
1880-S 11 63 PCGS Feb-07 E $104
1880-S 11 63 PCGS Jan-07 E $103
1880-S 11 63 PCGS Feb-07 E $82
1880-S 11 63 PCGS Aug-07 E $80
1880-S 11 63 PCGS Feb-07 E $77

Congratulations!

Coxe

Did you think it was an MS63 when you sent it in? If so, why slab it? Since it is an overdate, you'll probably be in a profitable situation on paper anyway.