Large collection buyout- Goudey Ruth, Gerhig goudey, Gerhig canadian goudey and much more! Need help

1980scollector

OK- I had a local guy in town that has about 300,000 worth of cards and has collected for about 30 years. I went over to his house and gave him two partial sets(66 and 69) and about 1000 commons no high #'s of 61 and 62(500 each at most). I also gave 2500.00 in cash and these cards are from packs he opens or cards he has bought over the 30 years. He grades nothing but has bought a few PSA cards etc.

I thought he overvalued my cards and here is what I got- all the goudeys are guaranteed untrimmed and authentic by him-

He paid 2700.00 for the Gerhig and Ruth about three years ago!


Babe Ruth 33 Goudey #149 PSA 4 quality

Gehrig 33 Goudey #92 PSA 5 quality(no creases in either card)

Gehrig 33 Goudey Canadain version #55 PSA 2 quality

Joe Dimaggio 40 Playball #1 PSA 5 quality easy possible 6 but close

1952 Berk Ross Joe Dimaggio PSA 6 Quality possible 7 but looks to be a high grade 6 to me

1962 Topps Mickey Mantle Post Hand Cut Authentic PSA slabbed (looks like a PSA 7 or 8) should I crack and get a grade on it?

1948 Stan Musial Rookie Leaf PSA 3 Quality possible 4

1975 Topps complete set EXMT/NRMT baseball


here is the stuff he has pulled I got in the past few years- he buys it by the cases

Ichiro Pujols Guerreo Triple Threads 9/27

Topps 205 Original gold border card from pack of WIlliam Bransfield(No idea value but looks nice) it is like the A and G insert but is an original inside the border

Troy Tulowitzki Cosigners autograph rookie 57/75

Kenny Irons Rookie Class threads patch auto #84/100

Joe Montana Stovall Jones Triple threads NOTRE DAME PATCH 2 of 3 Only 3 made

Old Judge autograph 2005 Ken Griffey Jr. Autograph


Alex Gordon Auto rookie Topps chrome

Johnny Lattiner threads 2006 auto Gridiron kings


Mario Andretti A and G autograph( I pulled on too so I have two now)
Bill hall
Cole Hamels
Jonathan Pappelbon all a and g autos

Jamarcus Russel Rookie Donruss Classics Autograph Rookie 49/100

2005 DOnruss Diamond Kings Steve Carlton autograph dual jersey 3/25

Reggie Jackson auto dual Jersey EX signings of the times 13/93

Mike Schmidt same as card above auto jersey 27/80


Don Mattingly Premiere Penmanship auto upper deck 9/23

Stan Musial Sweet Spot Signatures 20/75 autograph

Ryan Howard Topps Chrome Gold border Generation Now #58 one of one


I will addd more in a few minutes- I plan on sending goudeys in tommorrow overnight to PSA so they will be there on Monday

1980scollector

ok some more from the deal

52 topps Enos Slaughter PSA 6 quality easy

90 Score Emmitt SMith supplemental rookie PSA 9or 10 quality

Carl Yaz 2005 Timeless Treasures jersey auto # 1/5

2004 Topps Chrome Albert Pujols bat card refractor series 2

Lendale White Topps Rookie Premiere autograph

1984 Topps Baseball rack box




I got several low end insert autos jerseys etc. but that is the meat of the deal!
Old Judge autograph AL Rosen 2005 origins


PSA 7 leader card 1965 Mantle, Killebrew Boog Powell(bought it in a collection)

1969 White letter variation McCovey and Gaylord Perry PSA 5 quality on each card

Jerry Rice Legends autograph nickname FLASH 80 42/53

Joe Namath UD Legends autograph 2001 # JN

2004 Donruss Duke Snider autograph 7/10

thezamfam

Hi do you still heave the jerry rice flash 80 auto 42/53? Ill buy or trade for it Let me know thanks mike

jmbkb4

You might want to contract estil if you're looking to sell the 1975 T set. I think he was looking for that one.

RipublicaninMass

HUH?

TNTonPMS

Holy CRUD !!

Scans !!

Scans !!

Scans !!

Please .

I'd really love to see the Gehrigs most of all .

Seems like you made out nicely although I don't know what your partial sets may have been worth .

ripkenintheminors

Just thought it was worth mentioning that the thread was bumped from 5 months ago.

TNTonPMS

I'm wondering why he would want to get rid of those and still collect others

TNTonPMS

Ahhhh, Thank you Mr.Ripkenintheminors .

Damn !

envoy98

You may want to rethink buying anything from this clown shoe.

Do a search on his name and you'll find at least two or three threads where he failed to make good on deals. Took him 3 months to refund my money on a box he "got in this same deal". I had to badger him the entire time to get him to either send the box, or send me a refund. He flakes out and disappears for days, even weeks at a time. I can't tell you how many times I heard "It's on the way" or "I'll send tomorrow with dc and throw in something extra". Or my favorite, "I'll send you the box and the refund just to make it right" when I told him I wasn't going to hold my breath after both were supposedly sent... guess what actually did show up? My refund...no box, 4 months later now. At least I got my $$$ back.

I assume the bumper of this is the one who contacted me through ebay, I'll tell you again, your mileage may vary, but I wouldn't deal with Nate again. We were supposed to be "buds" and he d1cked me around for 3 months on a $50 deal. I wouldn't waste that kind of time again.

zep33

ouch

WinPitcher

Oh yes i remm that douchebag.


Steve

Ahmanfan

I know others can have different encounters, but 1980s collector has always promptly completed our multiple transactions.
John

baseballjeff

I want to see pictures!

NickM

PayPal just found in my favor and recovered $0.69 of a $13.50 transaction with him.
He didn't respond to my emails or the PayPal dispute or claim.
It was a P. Manning/Brady/Brees triple jersey card, BTW.

Nick

jimq112

I don't care what you guys think, I'm willing to send cash or a bank check for some vintage raw cards that might be real. Throw caution to the wind, what's the worst that could happen?

Allen

So did this guy just make up all of these stories to act like he was getting great finds and deals everyday and he got so caught up in the lie he was selling the cards to prove to us he had them. I remember he sold someone the 83 Topps box for $40 to prove he really got such a great deal because he could not sell it that cheap otherwise.

rpcoletrane

I remember contemplating on whether or not to buy a 54 Topps Banks RC from this sack of sh%$. I'm glad I didn't, because if he had stiffed me, I would have driven to his house and beat him with a crowbar. This kind of crap makes me so mad. I challenge the next son of a bit%$ that decides to come here and try any crap like this to come on down to Tennessee for a nice a$$ kicking!

leadoff4

He gave me a cell phone # in case I wanted to contact him. Not sure if I still have the PM he sent or not.

theczar

Boy do I remember him. I may be dumb, I may be ugly, I may be fat (I'm working on it), but I am not dishonest.


I am not the number one fan of the man from Tennessee

He is some realtor with an attorney for a wife that he threatens people with when he someone looks at him cross-eyed.

I guess those "creased" 1966's were good enough for him to trade with no problem.

That gives two conclusions. One the cards were fine. Or two he has no issue giving someone else creased cards. Since I know the answer is the first one, he is someone to avoid.