Should I try getting this regraded?

asphaltman76

I can't find a wrinkle anywhere....anybody think this could get a 5 if resubmitted?

vintagetoppsguy

Here is my Tinker graded a PSA 4. No creases. Well centered. Very clean back. There is an obvious difference in the corners between your 4 and my 4. Yours sure looks like a 5 to me. I would try at least once. If nothing else, it will at least come back with the label to designate that it's a Carolina Brights.

nam812

I think the corners are too rounded for a PSA 5 (mainly the top two), but I've seen worse cards in better holders.

chaz43

no. chaz

msassin

Crack and send it back in. Worst thing that can happen is it is still a '4'. Besides a 'T206 Carolina Brights' on the label is going to look sweet.

chaz43

<< <i>Crack and send it back in. Worst thing that can happen is it is still a '4'. Besides a 'T206 Carolina Brights' on the label is going to look sweet. >>



No chance. That would be a total waste. The corners are too rounded...fuget about it. chaz

Ladder7

If you get the bump to EX, you'll really PO the guy that sold you the VG-EX

Stingray

<< <i>If you get the bump to EX, you'll really PO the guy that sold you the VG-EX >>






Here is one for comparison off Ebay:

cohocorp

looks like it has a shot to me. good luck with it.

Morgoth

Go for it. I would suggest getting it graded on site at a show.