April Special Poppage (finally), Grades only a Griffin could love
41GoudeyGuy
Posts: 565 ✭
1 04658794 1941 GOUDEY 1 HUGH MULCAHY BLUE BACKGROUND 5
2 04658795 1941 GOUDEY 2 HARLOND CLIFT BLUE BACKGROUND 3
2 04658796 1941 GOUDEY 2 HARLOND CLIFT BLUE BACKGROUND 3
3 04658797 1941 GOUDEY 2 HARLOND CLIFT YELLOW BACKGROUND 5
4 04658798 1941 GOUDEY 3 LOUIS CHIOZZA GREEN BACKGROUND 6
5 04658799 1941 GOUDEY 3 LOUIS CHIOZZA YELLOW BACKGROUND N0
6 04658800 1941 GOUDEY 3 LOUIS CHIOZZA BLUE BACKGROUND 5
7 04658801 1941 GOUDEY 4 BUDDY ROSAR GREEN BACKGROUND 5
8 04658802 1941 GOUDEY 4 BUDDY ROSAR BLUE BACKGROUND 3
9 04658803 1941 GOUDEY 4 BUDDY ROSAR YELLOW BACKGROUND 5
10 04658804 1941 GOUDEY 5 GEORGE McQUINN BLUE BACKGROUND 5
11 04658805 1941 GOUDEY 5 GEORGE McQUINN YELLOW BACKGROUND 4
11 04658806 1941 GOUDEY 5 GEORGE McQUINN YELLOW BACKGROUND N0
11 04658807 1941 GOUDEY 5 GEORGE McQUINN YELLOW BACKGROUND 5
12 04658808 1941 GOUDEY 5 GEORGE McQUINN GREEN BACKGROUND 6MC
13 04658809 1941 GOUDEY 6 EMERSON DICKMAN BLUE BACKGROUND 4
13 04658810 1941 GOUDEY 6 EMERSON DICKMAN BLUE BACKGROUND 1
14 04658811 1941 GOUDEY 6 EMERSON DICKMAN RED BACKGROUND 5
15 04658812 1941 GOUDEY 7 WAYNE AMBLER YELLOW BACKGROUND 4
15 04658813 1941 GOUDEY 7 WAYNE AMBLER YELLOW BACKGROUND N0
16 04658814 1941 GOUDEY 8 BOB MUNCRIEF BLUE BACKGROUND N0
17 04658815 1941 GOUDEY 8 BOB MUNCRIEF RED BACKGROUND 2MC
18 04658816 1941 GOUDEY 8 BOB MUNCRIEF YELLOW BACKGROUND 4
18 04658817 1941 GOUDEY 8 BOB MUNCRIEF YELLOW BACKGROUND 6
19 04658818 1941 GOUDEY 9 BILL DIETRICH YELLOW BACKGROUND 4MK
20 04658819 1941 GOUDEY 9 BILL DIETRICH RED BACKGROUND 1
21 04658820 1941 GOUDEY 9 BILL DIETRICH GREEN BACKGROUND N0
21 04658821 1941 GOUDEY 9 BILL DIETRICH GREEN BACKGROUND 4
22 04658822 1941 GOUDEY 10 TAFT WRIGHT YELLOW BACKGROUND 6
23 04658823 1941 GOUDEY 11 DON HEFFNER BLUE BACKGROUND 2
24 04658824 1941 GOUDEY 10 TAFT WRIGHT BLUE BACKGROUND 5
24 04658825 1941 GOUDEY 11 DON HEFFNER BLUE BACKGROUND 5
25 04658826 1941 GOUDEY 11 DON HEFFNER GREEN BACKGROUND 6
26 04658827 1941 GOUDEY 12 FRITZ OSTERMUELLER GREEN BACKGROUND 4MK
26 04658828 1941 GOUDEY 12 FRITZ OSTERMUELLER GREEN BACKGROUND 4MC
27 04658829 1941 GOUDEY 12 FRITZ OSTERMUELLER BLUE BACKGROUND 4
27 04658830 1941 GOUDEY 12 FRITZ OSTERMUELLER BLUE BACKGROUND 7
28 04658831 1941 GOUDEY 12 FRITZ OSTERMUELLER YELLOW BACKGROUND 5MK
29 04658832 1941 GOUDEY 13 FRANK HAYES YELLOW BACKGROUND 6
30 04658833 1941 GOUDEY 13 FRANK HAYES BLUE BACKGROUND 4
31 04658834 1941 GOUDEY 14 JACK KRAMER YELLOW BACKGROUND 7
32 04658835 1941 GOUDEY 14 JACK KRAMER RED BACKGROUND N0
33 04658836 1941 GOUDEY 14 JACK KRAMER BLUE BACKGROUND 5
34 04658837 1941 GOUDEY 15 DARIO LODIGIANI BLUE BACKGROUND 5
35 04658838 1941 GOUDEY 15 DARIO LODIGIANI GREEN BACKGROUND 2MC
35 04658839 1941 GOUDEY 15 DARIO LODIGIANI GREEN BACKGROUND 5
36 04658840 1941 GOUDEY 15 DARIO LODIGIANI RED BACKGROUND 3
36 04658841 1941 GOUDEY 15 DARIO LODIGIANI RED BACKGROUND 5
37 04658842 1941 GOUDEY 16 GEORGE CASE YELLOW BACKGROUND 5MC
38 04658843 1941 GOUDEY 16 GEORGE CASE GREEN BACKGROUND 4
39 04658844 1941 GOUDEY 16 GEORGE CASE BLUE BACKGROUND 3MC
40 04658845 1941 GOUDEY 17 VITO TAMULIS YELLOW BACKGROUND N0
40 04658846 1941 GOUDEY 17 VITO TAMULIS YELLOW BACKGROUND Not Holdered, Questionable Authentication
40 04658847 1941 GOUDEY 17 VITO TAMULIS YELLOW BACKGROUND 2MK
41 04658848 1941 GOUDEY 17 VITO TAMULIS GREEN BACKGROUND 4
42 04658849 1941 GOUDEY 17 VITO TAMULIS BLUE BACKGROUND N0
43 04658850 1941 GOUDEY 17 VITO TAMULIS RED BACKGROUND 5
44 04658851 1941 GOUDEY 18 WHITLOW WYATT RED BACKGROUND N0
45 04658852 1941 GOUDEY 18 WHITLOW WYATT GREEN BACKGROUND N0
46 04658853 1941 GOUDEY 18 WHITLOW WYATT BLUE BACKGROUND N0
47 04658854 1941 GOUDEY 18 WHITLOW WYATT YELLOW BACKGROUND N0
48 04658855 1941 GOUDEY 19 BILL POSEDEL GREEN BACKGROUND 5
49 04658856 1941 GOUDEY 19 BILL POSEDEL YELLOW BACKGROUND 4
49 04658857 1941 GOUDEY 19 BILL POSEDEL YELLOW BACKGROUND 4
50 04658858 1941 GOUDEY 19 BILL POSEDEL RED BACKGROUND 4
51 04658859 1941 GOUDEY 26 ELBURT FLETCHER GREEN BACKGROUND 4MC
51 04658860 1941 GOUDEY 26 ELBURT FLETCHER GREEN BACKGROUND 5
52 04658861 1941 GOUDEY 26 ELBURT FLETCHER BLUE BACKGROUND 5
53 04658862 1941 GOUDEY 26 ELBURT FLETCHER YELLOW BACKGROUND 4MC
54 04658863 1941 GOUDEY 27 BILL CROUCH YELLOW BACKGROUND 1
55 04658864 1941 GOUDEY 27 BILL CROUCH GREEN BACKGROUND 4
56 04658865 1941 GOUDEY 28 AL TODD RED BACKGROUND 6
56 04658866 1941 GOUDEY 28 AL TODD RED BACKGROUND 2
57 04658867 1941 GOUDEY 28 AL TODD BLUE BACKGROUND 4MK
58 04658868 1941 GOUDEY 28 AL TODD GREEN BACKGROUND 4
59 04658869 1941 GOUDEY 29 DEBS GARMS YELLOW BACKGROUND 7MC
60 04658870 1941 GOUDEY 29 DEBS GARMS RED BACKGROUND 5MC
61 04658871 1941 GOUDEY 30 JIM TOBIN RED BACKGROUND 4MC
61 04658872 1941 GOUDEY 30 JIM TOBIN RED BACKGROUND N0
62 04658873 1941 GOUDEY 30 JIM TOBIN GREEN BACKGROUND 3
63 04658874 1941 GOUDEY 31 CHESTER ROSS YELLOW BACKGROUND 1
64 04658875 1941 GOUDEY 31 CHESTER ROSS BLUE BACKGROUND N0
65 04658876 1941 GOUDEY 31 CHESTER ROSS GREEN BACKGROUND 3
66 04658877 1941 GOUDEY 32 GEORGE COFFMAN GREEN BACKGROUND 2
67 04658878 1941 GOUDEY 32 GEORGE COFFMAN YELLOW BACKGROUND N0
68 04658879 1941 PLAY BALL 25 GENE MOORE N/A 6
69 04658880 1941 PLAY BALL 40 JOHNNY BABICH N/A 5
70 04658881 1948 BOWMAN 28 EMIL VERBAN N/A 7
Date Received: 05/16/2007
Date of Grades Posted: 07/26/2007
Date Shipped: No Date Specified
2 04658795 1941 GOUDEY 2 HARLOND CLIFT BLUE BACKGROUND 3
2 04658796 1941 GOUDEY 2 HARLOND CLIFT BLUE BACKGROUND 3
3 04658797 1941 GOUDEY 2 HARLOND CLIFT YELLOW BACKGROUND 5
4 04658798 1941 GOUDEY 3 LOUIS CHIOZZA GREEN BACKGROUND 6
5 04658799 1941 GOUDEY 3 LOUIS CHIOZZA YELLOW BACKGROUND N0
6 04658800 1941 GOUDEY 3 LOUIS CHIOZZA BLUE BACKGROUND 5
7 04658801 1941 GOUDEY 4 BUDDY ROSAR GREEN BACKGROUND 5
8 04658802 1941 GOUDEY 4 BUDDY ROSAR BLUE BACKGROUND 3
9 04658803 1941 GOUDEY 4 BUDDY ROSAR YELLOW BACKGROUND 5
10 04658804 1941 GOUDEY 5 GEORGE McQUINN BLUE BACKGROUND 5
11 04658805 1941 GOUDEY 5 GEORGE McQUINN YELLOW BACKGROUND 4
11 04658806 1941 GOUDEY 5 GEORGE McQUINN YELLOW BACKGROUND N0
11 04658807 1941 GOUDEY 5 GEORGE McQUINN YELLOW BACKGROUND 5
12 04658808 1941 GOUDEY 5 GEORGE McQUINN GREEN BACKGROUND 6MC
13 04658809 1941 GOUDEY 6 EMERSON DICKMAN BLUE BACKGROUND 4
13 04658810 1941 GOUDEY 6 EMERSON DICKMAN BLUE BACKGROUND 1
14 04658811 1941 GOUDEY 6 EMERSON DICKMAN RED BACKGROUND 5
15 04658812 1941 GOUDEY 7 WAYNE AMBLER YELLOW BACKGROUND 4
15 04658813 1941 GOUDEY 7 WAYNE AMBLER YELLOW BACKGROUND N0
16 04658814 1941 GOUDEY 8 BOB MUNCRIEF BLUE BACKGROUND N0
17 04658815 1941 GOUDEY 8 BOB MUNCRIEF RED BACKGROUND 2MC
18 04658816 1941 GOUDEY 8 BOB MUNCRIEF YELLOW BACKGROUND 4
18 04658817 1941 GOUDEY 8 BOB MUNCRIEF YELLOW BACKGROUND 6
19 04658818 1941 GOUDEY 9 BILL DIETRICH YELLOW BACKGROUND 4MK
20 04658819 1941 GOUDEY 9 BILL DIETRICH RED BACKGROUND 1
21 04658820 1941 GOUDEY 9 BILL DIETRICH GREEN BACKGROUND N0
21 04658821 1941 GOUDEY 9 BILL DIETRICH GREEN BACKGROUND 4
22 04658822 1941 GOUDEY 10 TAFT WRIGHT YELLOW BACKGROUND 6
23 04658823 1941 GOUDEY 11 DON HEFFNER BLUE BACKGROUND 2
24 04658824 1941 GOUDEY 10 TAFT WRIGHT BLUE BACKGROUND 5
24 04658825 1941 GOUDEY 11 DON HEFFNER BLUE BACKGROUND 5
25 04658826 1941 GOUDEY 11 DON HEFFNER GREEN BACKGROUND 6
26 04658827 1941 GOUDEY 12 FRITZ OSTERMUELLER GREEN BACKGROUND 4MK
26 04658828 1941 GOUDEY 12 FRITZ OSTERMUELLER GREEN BACKGROUND 4MC
27 04658829 1941 GOUDEY 12 FRITZ OSTERMUELLER BLUE BACKGROUND 4
27 04658830 1941 GOUDEY 12 FRITZ OSTERMUELLER BLUE BACKGROUND 7
28 04658831 1941 GOUDEY 12 FRITZ OSTERMUELLER YELLOW BACKGROUND 5MK
29 04658832 1941 GOUDEY 13 FRANK HAYES YELLOW BACKGROUND 6
30 04658833 1941 GOUDEY 13 FRANK HAYES BLUE BACKGROUND 4
31 04658834 1941 GOUDEY 14 JACK KRAMER YELLOW BACKGROUND 7
32 04658835 1941 GOUDEY 14 JACK KRAMER RED BACKGROUND N0
33 04658836 1941 GOUDEY 14 JACK KRAMER BLUE BACKGROUND 5
34 04658837 1941 GOUDEY 15 DARIO LODIGIANI BLUE BACKGROUND 5
35 04658838 1941 GOUDEY 15 DARIO LODIGIANI GREEN BACKGROUND 2MC
35 04658839 1941 GOUDEY 15 DARIO LODIGIANI GREEN BACKGROUND 5
36 04658840 1941 GOUDEY 15 DARIO LODIGIANI RED BACKGROUND 3
36 04658841 1941 GOUDEY 15 DARIO LODIGIANI RED BACKGROUND 5
37 04658842 1941 GOUDEY 16 GEORGE CASE YELLOW BACKGROUND 5MC
38 04658843 1941 GOUDEY 16 GEORGE CASE GREEN BACKGROUND 4
39 04658844 1941 GOUDEY 16 GEORGE CASE BLUE BACKGROUND 3MC
40 04658845 1941 GOUDEY 17 VITO TAMULIS YELLOW BACKGROUND N0
40 04658846 1941 GOUDEY 17 VITO TAMULIS YELLOW BACKGROUND Not Holdered, Questionable Authentication
40 04658847 1941 GOUDEY 17 VITO TAMULIS YELLOW BACKGROUND 2MK
41 04658848 1941 GOUDEY 17 VITO TAMULIS GREEN BACKGROUND 4
42 04658849 1941 GOUDEY 17 VITO TAMULIS BLUE BACKGROUND N0
43 04658850 1941 GOUDEY 17 VITO TAMULIS RED BACKGROUND 5
44 04658851 1941 GOUDEY 18 WHITLOW WYATT RED BACKGROUND N0
45 04658852 1941 GOUDEY 18 WHITLOW WYATT GREEN BACKGROUND N0
46 04658853 1941 GOUDEY 18 WHITLOW WYATT BLUE BACKGROUND N0
47 04658854 1941 GOUDEY 18 WHITLOW WYATT YELLOW BACKGROUND N0
48 04658855 1941 GOUDEY 19 BILL POSEDEL GREEN BACKGROUND 5
49 04658856 1941 GOUDEY 19 BILL POSEDEL YELLOW BACKGROUND 4
49 04658857 1941 GOUDEY 19 BILL POSEDEL YELLOW BACKGROUND 4
50 04658858 1941 GOUDEY 19 BILL POSEDEL RED BACKGROUND 4
51 04658859 1941 GOUDEY 26 ELBURT FLETCHER GREEN BACKGROUND 4MC
51 04658860 1941 GOUDEY 26 ELBURT FLETCHER GREEN BACKGROUND 5
52 04658861 1941 GOUDEY 26 ELBURT FLETCHER BLUE BACKGROUND 5
53 04658862 1941 GOUDEY 26 ELBURT FLETCHER YELLOW BACKGROUND 4MC
54 04658863 1941 GOUDEY 27 BILL CROUCH YELLOW BACKGROUND 1
55 04658864 1941 GOUDEY 27 BILL CROUCH GREEN BACKGROUND 4
56 04658865 1941 GOUDEY 28 AL TODD RED BACKGROUND 6
56 04658866 1941 GOUDEY 28 AL TODD RED BACKGROUND 2
57 04658867 1941 GOUDEY 28 AL TODD BLUE BACKGROUND 4MK
58 04658868 1941 GOUDEY 28 AL TODD GREEN BACKGROUND 4
59 04658869 1941 GOUDEY 29 DEBS GARMS YELLOW BACKGROUND 7MC
60 04658870 1941 GOUDEY 29 DEBS GARMS RED BACKGROUND 5MC
61 04658871 1941 GOUDEY 30 JIM TOBIN RED BACKGROUND 4MC
61 04658872 1941 GOUDEY 30 JIM TOBIN RED BACKGROUND N0
62 04658873 1941 GOUDEY 30 JIM TOBIN GREEN BACKGROUND 3
63 04658874 1941 GOUDEY 31 CHESTER ROSS YELLOW BACKGROUND 1
64 04658875 1941 GOUDEY 31 CHESTER ROSS BLUE BACKGROUND N0
65 04658876 1941 GOUDEY 31 CHESTER ROSS GREEN BACKGROUND 3
66 04658877 1941 GOUDEY 32 GEORGE COFFMAN GREEN BACKGROUND 2
67 04658878 1941 GOUDEY 32 GEORGE COFFMAN YELLOW BACKGROUND N0
68 04658879 1941 PLAY BALL 25 GENE MOORE N/A 6
69 04658880 1941 PLAY BALL 40 JOHNNY BABICH N/A 5
70 04658881 1948 BOWMAN 28 EMIL VERBAN N/A 7
Date Received: 05/16/2007
Date of Grades Posted: 07/26/2007
Date Shipped: No Date Specified
Learn some history of the game. Join a vintage base ball team in your area and get out there.
Simsbury Taverneers
My PSA Sets
Simsbury Taverneers
My PSA Sets
0
Comments
I really enjoy the 41 Goudey set.
What's up with the Tamulis fake...? A worn down reprint? I find it hard to believe you wouldn't have seen that.
Also, a pretty good run on non-qualified examples, given that 40% of everything I ever seen from this set is grossly miscut.
There were a number of grades that surpised me on this submission. Some of them graded a notch or two higher than I expected and many of them did not get the expected MC designation. Also, the number of ungraded AUTH results is far higher than I expected. I actually didn't expect to get more than a couple because I went through these pretty well and only picked the best of what i had for submission. I am very anxious to look at the Tamulis because I do not believe it was a fake. I believe I have enough experience with these to catch that and have identified fakes in the past. Besides, who would fake a PSA 2-3 Tamulis?
PSA started identifying the color designation ealier this year through the efforts of Griffins and I. Anthony went after Joe Orlando to get the colors on the flips and I went after Cosetta and got the master set in the Set Registry. It just turned out that we did this independantly at the same time.
Do you collect this set? I'm always looking to gather information on this set and would be very interested in finding out what you have, whether they are available or not.
Brian
Simsbury Taverneers
My PSA Sets
m
that was certainly worth waiting for! Congrats!
Always looking for Topps Salesman Samples, pre '51 unopened packs, E90-2, E91a, N690 Kalamazoo Bats, and T204 Square Frame Ramly's