Help with 67 Mantle Checklist Variation...pics attached

jeff8877

Hi everyone,

There are two variations for this checklist...one has card #170 with a period after the the letter D in D McAuillfe and one does not. Can someone tell me if the first scan would be considered the "no period" variation as it is certainly different from scan number two??


url=http://users.piczonline.com/users/pic.php?u=432QuAnL&i=9331][/url]



[url=http://users.piczonline.com/users/pic.php?u=432QuAnL&i=9330][/url]

nam812

My big book lists no variation with that card.

zep33

i see a dot on the both of them but the top one looks like a smudged dot

jeff8877

Nick...here is the pop report for both...the no dot is very tough.

103 CHECKLIST 110-196 170 IS D McAULIFFE 0 1 2 4 9 1 7 0 1 1 0 26
103 CHECKLIST 110-196 170 IS D.McAULIFFE 3 20 33 67 123 5 145 16 21 1 0 444

nam812

I don't doubt it, I just don't see it in my giant beckett annual.

CDsNuts

Erase the dot.

bishop

These are the two variations of this card. Although SCD lists it as a dot, no dot variation, Dick Gilkeson properly describes the variation in his Baseball Variation Book publication as "period distinct" and "period is a line"

WinPitcher

What Al Bishop says is correct. I have both in raw form myself.

Steve

jeff8877

Thanks Steve...can you confirm the first scan is the no period/line variation??

Thanks Much

Jeff

WinPitcher

It appears to be.

Steve