I was shocked also. I suspect the winning bidder did not expect to go that high. I think 2 snipers wanted it bad, so they put in a super high number thinking it would gaurantee them a win at a much lower price. Ufortunately, they ended up driving each other over $5500. I bet the runner up is breathing a sigh of relief.
<< <i>I was shocked also. I suspect the winning bidder did not expect to go that high. I think 2 snipers wanted it bad, so they put in a super high number thinking it would gaurantee them a win at a much lower price. Ufortunately, they ended up driving each other over $5500. I bet the runner up is breathing a sigh of relief. >>
I disagree if you look at the bidder list ... There were many nut cases bidding it up not just the last two
<< <i>I was shocked also. I suspect the winning bidder did not expect to go that high. I think 2 snipers wanted it bad, so they put in a super high number thinking it would gaurantee them a win at a much lower price. Ufortunately, they ended up driving each other over $5500. I bet the runner up is breathing a sigh of relief. >>
I disagree if you look at the bidder list ... There were many nut cases bidding it up not just the last two >>
I stand by my statement. The final 2 bidders drove it up an addittional $2235. Although I can see your argument that several people had over bid the lot before that.
The auction was real. I was the original seller of the denver mint 67 in this auction. I talked to the seller when he bought the P-mint 67. He is an ebay newbie, in fact his feedback was 0 when he bought my coin. He managed to get NARUd and doesn't even know why. Now he decided to take his profits and sold with his son's account with no recent and no coin-related feedback, poor photos, etc. I called him and almost begged him to take it down and let me sell it with good photos and a professional auction for a very modest comission. He wanted to do it himself. I was quite worried that bidders would be scared off of this auction that had a few red flags flying. Some probably were. I think what saved him was the adding of the PCGS serial numbers so buyers could verify that he at least had valid serial numbers. Also, one of my past customers called and I confirmed the identity of the seller so I know he bid. The winner was also a past customer of mine. Congratulations James.
For those skeptical of the sale price, let me point out that the pop for Denver 67s is 3 and Philadelphia is 13 and some wonder if that's going to be it. There have been no 67s since the first week.
<< <i>That price defies logic when you consider the many other good choices that could be had for that amount of money. >>
I'm always amazed by those who think the rest of the world should share all their opinions on what to collect. Would you be amazed to know the seller has no interest in Morgan Dollars?
<< <i>I wonder if they are expecting to PAY that amount for the rest of the series haHAHAHAHAHAH >>
If the rest of the series only has 66's the 3 owners of D 67 washingtons will sit at the top of of the registry forever.
And for those laughing at the buyer I'll remind you that you laughed at the seller when he bought the D coin for $1450. I think he paid about $1200 for the P 67. He just doubled his money. I'm sure he's laughing too. --Jerry
<< <i>Anybody care to guess what a 68 might pull down? (besides someones financial statement) >>
Probably not a lot more. 67 is seen as the top grade for these coins and I think the price has that built in. If a 68 were to show up (unlikely) it would replace the 67's at the top. However, in your question you talk about one 68 so it would be a pop 1 coin and that would increase the value somewhat. --Jerry
Notwilight; You had made a very good point. I actually emailed the seller twice early in the auction. I was trying to figure out if he was legit or if it was a hijacked account. I was very concerned that the seller had no activity for over a year, then suddenly showed up with a whopper pop 3 ms-67. After pondering it a while, I finally decided to pass. Of course, in hindsight it would not have mattered, as I would have been taken out very early in my snipe anyway.
<< <i>I wonder if they are expecting to PAY that amount for the rest of the series haHAHAHAHAHAH >>
If the rest of the series only has 66's the 3 owners of D 67 washingtons will sit at the top of of the registry forever.
And for those laughing at the buyer I'll remind you that you laughed at the seller when he bought the D coin for $1450. I think he paid about $1200 for the P 67. He just doubled his money. I'm sure he's laughing too. --Jerry >>
Those pop numbers won't stay, not with hundred of millions of coins made. I'm not going to argue further with you, but this clearly is insane to pay $5000 for a pair of coins made made only months ago that cost one dollar each to acquire. All I can think of is tulips!
Seeing someone blow money like this makes me feel a lot better about some of MY purchases lol.
Exclusively collecting Capped Bust Halves in VF to AU, especially rarity 3 and up. Joe G. Great BST purchases completed with commoncents123, p8nt, blu62vette and Stuart. Great coin swaps completed with rah1959, eyoung429 and Zug. Top-notch consignment experience with Russ.
I am not sure, but does anyone know if the presidential series will have satin finishes produced? If they do, the ms-67's may be quickly bumped from the top of the registry.
This is were comparing moderns to old coins doesn't make sense to me. These coins were sent directly from federal bank boxes directly to PCGS they didn't have to lay in a drawer for 100 years never being messed with. I could buy 5 ms67 morgan for that price Guess that's why I don't care for super modern at super prices JMO
<< <i>I wonder if they are expecting to PAY that amount for the rest of the series haHAHAHAHAHAH >>
If the rest of the series only has 66's the 3 owners of D 67 washingtons will sit at the top of of the registry forever. And for those laughing at the buyer I'll remind you that you laughed at the seller when he bought the D coin for $1450. I think he paid about $1200 for the P 67. He just doubled his money. I'm sure he's laughing too. --Jerry >>
Those pop numbers won't stay, not with hundred of millions of coins made. I'm not going to argue further with you, but this clearly is insane to pay $5000 for a pair of coins made made only months ago that cost one dollar each to acquire. All I can think of is tulips! >>
I don't want to argue either but I'll point out that they move these coins like farmers move grain and they get a lot of marks. For coins to get thru in 67 or 68 condition requires it to beat almost quantum mechanical odds. I also think these coins are more annealed than the Sacs (softer). When I get a few minutes free at work I plan to have sampes of each hardness tested But you may be right, more may show up.
The buyers make their own decisions and in this case a poor newbie from Cleveland ended up a winner. I'm very happy for the guy.
<< <i>I am not sure, but does anyone know if the presidential series will have satin finishes produced? If they do, the ms-67's may be quickly bumped from the top of the registry. >>
Haven't heard any talk of it and it is clear the buyers are not expecting it. --jerry
Now that you can't tell who the losing bidders are things are possibly better as far as spamming and bogus second offers are concerned. You really can't tell why the bidding is going up so strongly though.
For that kind of money there would be numerous classics (1932-D quarter, 1909-S VDB and 1914-D Lincoln, numerous important Morgans in MS - 1897-O, 1893-O, 1894-P, 1893-CC etc.) that will almost certainly maintain their value during my lifetime and successive lifetimes.
I really do wonder what a buyer of 2007 coin is thinking to pay that kind of money while the Mint is still churning out that very same coin. You can't state that the dies will wear out becuase the dies get replaced.
This sounds more like the sort of thing some gambler or disillusioned stock market junkie would do.
cho10
Collecting since the 1980's Morgan Dollars Circ. Strikes - Basic Set - Varieties - Prooflike Basic Set - Date Set - Carson City - Early S Mint Short Set - Mintmark Type Set Morgan Dollars Proof - Basic Set - Varieties Peace Circ.
<< <i>Those pop numbers won't stay, not with hundred of millions of coins made. >>
Most likely. But, how many will be first day coins? That's a big part of the value on this pair. The first coins in a new series, from the first day of issue.
there has been a particular dealer selling MANY P mint 67's.......at least 5-6 coins, that is a HUGE percentage of the total......he must have been very lucky to get that group of dollars in unsearched rolls......wow?
and for the tens of thousands more submitted......I sent a 1000 coins, had a couple 67's that were knocked down in finalization (was told this by BULK).....
you cant tell me that there shouldn't be more.....
<< <i>I wonder if they are expecting to PAY that amount for the rest of the series haHAHAHAHAHAH >>
If the rest of the series only has 66's the 3 owners of D 67 washingtons will sit at the top of of the registry forever.
And for those laughing at the buyer I'll remind you that you laughed at the seller when he bought the D coin for $1450. I think he paid about $1200 for the P 67. He just doubled his money. I'm sure he's laughing too. --Jerry >>
<< <i>Those pop numbers won't stay, not with hundred of millions of coins made. >>
Most likely. But, how many will be first day coins? That's a big part of the value on this pair. The first coins in a new series, from the first day of issue.
Russ, NCNE >>
I guess some people assess the risk of the future premium on those first days covers differently than others. It is a huge gamble.
<< <i><< Those pop numbers won't stay, not with hundred of millions of coins made. >>
Most likely. But, how many will be first day coins? That's a big part of the value on this pair. The first coins in a new series, from the first day of issue.
Russ, NCNE >>
I guess some people assess the risk of the future premium on those first days covers differently than others. It is a huge gamble. >>
The first day cover is an entirely different animal than what is being discussed here. Don't misunderstand me, though. I don't think this pair of coins is an acceptable long-term risk. I was simply noting that the argument that a bunch more MS67's will be made is specious in this particular case.
whatever floats their boat I guess. It's stuff like this that turns me off from "condition rarity" coins.. in the end it might say MS67 on the slab, but there will be hundreds if not thousands of coins available that approach the same technical grade even if PCGS says they don't. If you are really collecting the coin, and not the holder, these prices are pretty ridiculous.
I don't know folks! Lots of synical skeptics here but even though PCGS has changed the First Day of Issue qualifications, the Pops for the MS67 coins have NOT gone up. There are still only 13 P's and 3 D's. Those numbers have held since 4/4.
0 have been graded MS67 for non-FDOI so, to me, the MS67's have some value and I would be very surprised if these pops suddenly went up! If you think for an instant that there are not dealers out there trying to achieve that MS67 grade, you really need to re-evaluate especially with what these coins are selling for.
Perhaps 5 grand seems a little steep but if those pops stay as they are, then the price for both those coins will be trivial in another year or two.
I decided to change calling the bathroom the John and renamed it the Jim. I feel so much better saying I went to the Jim this morning.
<< <i>whatever floats their boat I guess. It's stuff like this that turns me off from "condition rarity" coins.. in the end it might say MS67 on the slab, but there will be hundreds if not thousands of coins available that approach the same technical grade even if PCGS says they don't. If you are really collecting the coin, and not the holder, these prices are pretty ridiculous. >>
I'll start believing you "condition rarity haters" when I see you posting the same arguments on morgan and gold threads.
Comments
Mad money for what will end up being common grade coins
2 George Washington Dollars in PCGS plastic.
MS 67
Someone is upside down
We collectors are a nutty bunch.
NSDR - Life Member
SSDC - Life Member
ANA - Pay As I Go Member
That price defies logic when you consider the many other good choices that
could be had for that amount of money.
<< <i>I was shocked also. I suspect the winning bidder did not expect to go that high. I think 2 snipers wanted it bad, so they put in a super high number thinking it would gaurantee them a win at a much lower price. Ufortunately, they ended up driving each other over $5500. I bet the runner up is breathing a sigh of relief. >>
I disagree if you look at the bidder list ... There were many nut cases bidding it up not just the last two
<< <i>
<< <i>I was shocked also. I suspect the winning bidder did not expect to go that high. I think 2 snipers wanted it bad, so they put in a super high number thinking it would gaurantee them a win at a much lower price. Ufortunately, they ended up driving each other over $5500. I bet the runner up is breathing a sigh of relief. >>
I disagree if you look at the bidder list ... There were many nut cases bidding it up not just the last two >>
I stand by my statement. The final 2 bidders drove it up an addittional $2235. Although I can see your argument that several people had over bid the lot before that.
<< <i>I wonder if they are expecting to PAY that amount for the rest of the series haHAHAHAHAHAH >>
Yeah, they'd be looking at over $220,000!!
Lincoln set Colorless Set
For those skeptical of the sale price, let me point out that the pop for Denver 67s is 3 and Philadelphia is 13 and some wonder if that's going to be it. There have been no 67s since the first week.
--Jerry
<< <i>That price defies logic when you consider the many other good choices that could be had for that amount of money. >>
I'm always amazed by those who think the rest of the world should share all their opinions on what to collect. Would you be amazed to know the seller has no interest in Morgan Dollars?
<< <i>I wonder if they are expecting to PAY that amount for the rest of the series haHAHAHAHAHAH >>
If the rest of the series only has 66's the 3 owners of D 67 washingtons will sit at the top of of the registry forever.
And for those laughing at the buyer I'll remind you that you laughed at the seller when he bought the D coin for $1450. I think he paid about $1200 for the P 67. He just doubled his money. I'm sure he's laughing too. --Jerry
<< <i>Anybody care to guess what a 68 might pull down? >>
My house?
<< <i>Anybody care to guess what a 68 might pull down? (besides someones financial statement) >>
Probably not a lot more. 67 is seen as the top grade for these coins and I think the price has that built in. If a 68 were to show up (unlikely) it would replace the 67's at the top. However, in your question you talk about one 68 so it would be a pop 1 coin and that would increase the value somewhat. --Jerry
<< <i>
<< <i>I wonder if they are expecting to PAY that amount for the rest of the series haHAHAHAHAHAH >>
If the rest of the series only has 66's the 3 owners of D 67 washingtons will sit at the top of of the registry forever.
And for those laughing at the buyer I'll remind you that you laughed at the seller when he bought the D coin for $1450. I think he paid about $1200 for the P 67. He just doubled his money. I'm sure he's laughing too. --Jerry >>
Those pop numbers won't stay, not with hundred of millions of coins made. I'm not going to argue further with you, but this clearly is insane to pay $5000 for a pair of
coins made made only months ago that cost one dollar each to acquire. All I can think of is tulips!
Free Trial
Joe G.
Great BST purchases completed with commoncents123, p8nt, blu62vette and Stuart. Great coin swaps completed with rah1959, eyoung429 and Zug. Top-notch consignment experience with Russ.
These coins were sent directly from federal bank boxes directly to PCGS
they didn't have to lay in a drawer for 100 years never being messed with.
I could buy 5 ms67 morgan for that price
Guess that's why I don't care for super modern at super prices
JMO
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>I wonder if they are expecting to PAY that amount for the rest of the series haHAHAHAHAHAH >>
If the rest of the series only has 66's the 3 owners of D 67 washingtons will sit at the top of of the registry forever. And for those laughing at the buyer I'll remind you that you laughed at the seller when he bought the D coin for $1450. I think he paid about $1200 for the P 67. He just doubled his money. I'm sure he's laughing too. --Jerry >>
Those pop numbers won't stay, not with hundred of millions of coins made. I'm not going to argue further with you, but this clearly is insane to pay $5000 for a pair of coins made made only months ago that cost one dollar each to acquire. All I can think of is tulips! >>
I don't want to argue either but I'll point out that they move these coins like farmers move grain and they get a lot of marks. For coins to get thru in 67 or 68 condition requires it to beat almost quantum mechanical odds. I also think these coins are more annealed than the Sacs (softer). When I get a few minutes free at work I plan to have sampes of each hardness tested But you may be right, more may show up.
The buyers make their own decisions and in this case a poor newbie from Cleveland ended up a winner. I'm very happy for the guy.
--Jerry
<< <i>I am not sure, but does anyone know if the presidential series will have satin finishes produced? If they do, the ms-67's may be quickly bumped from the top of the registry. >>
Haven't heard any talk of it and it is clear the buyers are not expecting it. --jerry
You really can't tell why the bidding is going up so strongly though.
For that kind of money there would be numerous classics (1932-D quarter, 1909-S VDB and 1914-D Lincoln, numerous important Morgans in MS - 1897-O, 1893-O, 1894-P, 1893-CC etc.) that will almost certainly maintain their value during my lifetime and successive lifetimes.
I really do wonder what a buyer of 2007 coin is thinking to pay that kind of money while the Mint is still churning out that very same coin. You can't state that the dies will wear out becuase the dies get replaced.
This sounds more like the sort of thing some gambler or disillusioned stock market junkie would do.
Collecting since the 1980's
Morgan Dollars Circ. Strikes
- Basic Set - Varieties - Prooflike Basic Set - Date Set
- Carson City - Early S Mint Short Set - Mintmark Type Set
Morgan Dollars Proof
- Basic Set - Varieties
Peace Circ.
<< <i>Those pop numbers won't stay, not with hundred of millions of coins made. >>
Most likely. But, how many will be first day coins? That's a big part of the value on this pair. The first coins in a new series, from the first day of issue.
Russ, NCNE
and for the tens of thousands more submitted......I sent a 1000 coins, had a couple 67's that were knocked down in finalization (was told this by BULK).....
you cant tell me that there shouldn't be more.....
how would they know?
guess what, they were.
I guess they see this frequently happening.
<< <i>
<< <i>I wonder if they are expecting to PAY that amount for the rest of the series haHAHAHAHAHAH >>
If the rest of the series only has 66's the 3 owners of D 67 washingtons will sit at the top of of the registry forever.
And for those laughing at the buyer I'll remind you that you laughed at the seller when he bought the D coin for $1450. I think he paid about $1200 for the P 67. He just doubled his money. I'm sure he's laughing too. --Jerry >>
I've been told I tolerate fools poorly...that may explain things if I have a problem with you. Current ebay items - Nothing at the moment
<< <i>
<< <i>Those pop numbers won't stay, not with hundred of millions of coins made. >>
Most likely. But, how many will be first day coins? That's a big part of the value on this pair. The first coins in a new series, from the first day of issue.
Russ, NCNE >>
I guess some people assess the risk of the future premium on those first days covers differently than others. It is a huge gamble.
NSDR - Life Member
SSDC - Life Member
ANA - Pay As I Go Member
<< <i><< Those pop numbers won't stay, not with hundred of millions of coins made. >>
Most likely. But, how many will be first day coins? That's a big part of the value on this pair. The first coins in a new series, from the first day of issue.
Russ, NCNE >>
I guess some people assess the risk of the future premium on those first days covers differently than others. It is a huge gamble. >>
The first day cover is an entirely different animal than what is being discussed here. Don't misunderstand me, though. I don't think this pair of coins is an acceptable long-term risk. I was simply noting that the argument that a bunch more MS67's will be made is specious in this particular case.
Russ, NCNE
Steve
<< <i>Anybody care to guess what a 68 might pull down? >>
Probably pull down about 150 posts regarding it, once the thread was started.
- Jim
<< <i>I can only say that it is items like this that will in the end destroy the rare coin market >>
change is inevitable, survival is not
you have made a very good point
Unbelievable at best...
Later, Paul.
Later, Paul.
<< <i>
<< <i>I can only say that it is items like this that will in the end destroy the rare coin market >>
change is inevitable, survival is not you have made a very good point >>
I don't want to argue so I won't post a counter but I don't buy it.
0 have been graded MS67 for non-FDOI so, to me, the MS67's have some value and I would be very surprised if these pops suddenly went up! If you think for an instant that there are not dealers out there trying to achieve that MS67 grade, you really need to re-evaluate especially with what these coins are selling for.
Perhaps 5 grand seems a little steep but if those pops stay as they are, then the price for both those coins will be trivial in another year or two.
The name is LEE!
<< <i>whatever floats their boat I guess. It's stuff like this that turns me off from "condition rarity" coins.. in the end it might say MS67 on the slab, but there will be hundreds if not thousands of coins available that approach the same technical grade even if PCGS says they don't. If you are really collecting the coin, and not the holder, these prices are pretty ridiculous. >>
I'll start believing you "condition rarity haters" when I see you posting the same arguments on morgan and gold threads.