Home Trading Cards & Memorabilia Forum

PSA shipping refused, opened packaged..

Does anyone know if there is anything I can do to find my cards in this situation?

I sent about $100 worth of cards with an USPS Priority Mail envelope. Now, generally I send large value of cards with insurance or registered mail, but since this was only 25 cards worth less than $100 I decided nothing would happen.

I check tracking, and it says PSA refused the package. The package is returned to me, but with a minor problem - the top is open, my order slip is inside, but no cards. I taped it up pretty good, but I guess the cards must have slipped out.

Anything I can do to maybe find the cards, or do I lose because of insurance?

Comments

  • storm888storm888 Posts: 11,701 ✭✭✭
    Inexpensive lesson.

    Not all USPS workers are honest. They know
    what PSA is.

    Next time, $2.30 buys $100.00 insurance.

    Sorry.
    Folks Who Bite Get Bitten. Folks Who Don't Bite Get Eaten.
  • Yeah, I should have gone for insurance. The top is opened perfectly, so it does not look ripped accidentally, it looks like it was opened with a letter opener.

    I guess live and learn!
  • ripkenintheminorsripkenintheminors Posts: 2,186 ✭✭✭


    << <i>Inexpensive lesson.

    Not all USPS workers are honest. They know
    what PSA is.

    Next time, $2.30 buys $100.00 insurance.

    Sorry. >>



    Agreed. I have learned to insure everything, regardless of value. Unfortunately there are a lot of crooks out there.
  • The main reason I did not insure was not because I am cheap, but I've sent hundreds of packages (eBay) and a few dozen to PSA without any problem - but next time I will be more careful.

    Is there any point in filing a "lost/rifling" report at the USPS? Maybe the cards fell somewhere, or someone put them in a lost/found.
  • CDsNutsCDsNuts Posts: 10,092
    You should fill out the paperwork, because if the last 20 guys that had stuff stolen from this guy had filled out their paperwork, maybe the guy doesn't have a job and your cards get there in one piece.

    Lee
  • I recently sent a money order to a company that has the word Memorabilia in their title. The envelope was sealed with tape and mailed at the PO on a Friday. On Monday, I received the money order back, in an envelope from the PO, stamped "found loose in mail"... no original envelope or invoice, just the M.O. My envelope didn't even make past the central sorting office before someone noticed the "Memorabilia" address and took a chance opening the envelope in hopes of finding some cards.
    My mailwomen has knocked on my door to inform me of open padded-mailers. In both instances, the slabbed cards I won on ebay were still in the mailer. Maybe honesty prevailed in both cases and maybe the cert #s on the PSA slabs were enough to scare anyone away (they were commons...LOL) Makes me wonder if the slabs had been a Mantle or Aaron or if the cards were raw...would they have been in the mailers?

    My guess is PSA refused the envelope because it was already tampered with.
  • storm888storm888 Posts: 11,701 ✭✭✭
    "Is there any point in filing a "lost/rifling" report at the USPS?"

    ////////////////////////////////////////////////

    Yes.

    They will look at the route the parcel took through
    the system. The next time a theft happens on the
    same path, they will dig deeper. It is hard to catch
    a thief, but they catch them everyday; with the help
    of their customers.

    While Priority Mail is touted as being primarily for
    speed, the USPS does not want it to be perceived
    as unsafe.
    Folks Who Bite Get Bitten. Folks Who Don't Bite Get Eaten.
  • MooseDogMooseDog Posts: 1,946 ✭✭✭


    << <i>"Is there any point in filing a "lost/rifling" report at the USPS?" >>



    Agreed. Definitely file a claim. Postal Inspectors take their jobs very seriously and if it is the same carrier or other employee doing the rifling, he'll be history and could potentially go to jail if caught in the act.
  • WinPitcherWinPitcher Posts: 27,726 ✭✭✭
    Im confused, PSA refused the item? Cuz it was not sent registered mail?

    Steve
    Good for you.
  • jimq112jimq112 Posts: 3,511 ✭✭✭
    Ill-advised shipping for sure. Use a box like PSA requires, spend the extra on insurance at the very least and registered if the contents are worth over $250. Just makes sense.

    The Postal Inspectors aren't the ones who get involved if it's suspected employee theft. It's a branch called the Postal Inspection Service, it sounds similar but they're 2 different agencies. Postal Inspectors are busy with anthrax and mail bombs, and mail fraud and things like that. The Postal Inspection service is only concerned with postal employees being bad. Calling the Postal Inspector won't do a thing.


    Crash - call PSA and see if they documented whether they returned it because it was an envelope or because it was an EMPTY envelope. Do that first before you file any lost/stolen mail reports. It's possible that your cards were taken or lost before they even got to PSA.

    If PSA received an envelope and signed for it and it was empty they would owe you for the cards. They would be lost on their watch, and I'm positive that they are careful about that.

    If PSA returned an empty envelope then your cards disappeared somewhere in processing, way way harder to catch anybody but it's possible they might be listed on the lost mail intranet.

    If they returned a full envelope, go to www.usps.com and file a service complaint. If your carrier has a history of things coming up "missing" this is the only way it gets to the right people. Filing a rifling report or calling the post office in your area doesn't put it on record.

    If they suspect a carrier of theft (based on more than one complaint) the postmaster brings in the inspection service. They will set traps, birthday cards with a $20 showing, walmart gift cards, etc are the common traps.

    At my office if we notice an empty box or envelope we document it and sticker the hell out of it as received empty. Not all offices do that.

    If you need a # to call, PM your zip code and I'll try to get you a name/number instead of 1-800-usps

    jim
    image
  • GOODLIEUGOODLIEU Posts: 629 ✭✭
    A number of years ago I bought a Graded 1971 Topps Dan Issel PSA 8 card off a Seller on ebay. If memory serves me correct I did not pay much for it (About $25.00) so I did not insure it. A few days later a bubble mailer showed up in my mailbox from the seller with a Delivery Confirmation and when I opened it I found a empty package. I checked the package more carefully and it appeared to have a fine cut on the bottom which had been retaped. I had dealt with the seller before and his feedback was pristeen so I was pretty confident it was sent by him. Anyway I went to my local post office and filled out a form indicating my findings. A few months later after I had long forgotten about the card I received a call from a Postal Inspector in Florida where the seller was based and he had my card along with a number of other items that they confiscated when they arrested a Mail Handler that they were investigating based on the number of complaints of tampering of uninsured mail from that location. Bottom line is that it dont hurt to repot this theft because it may in fact aid them in rooting out a thief in their midst.
  • storm888storm888 Posts: 11,701 ✭✭✭
    My friends and I have all sent items to
    PSA in cardboard-hardened Flat-Rate
    Priority Mail envelopes.

    None have ever been rejected.

    Folks Who Bite Get Bitten. Folks Who Don't Bite Get Eaten.
  • Thank you for the response guys. PSA definitely rejected it because the envelope got there opened already - so it happened on the way there. I have sent a lot of stuff to PSA, and since this was only $100, I thought there would not be a problem.

    Should I go to the post office I sent it from to file the missing report, or do I have to do it online or over the phone?
  • Read the end of jimq112 post. He's best informed on what you'll need to do.
  • I will look into it. The only issue even when having insurance, is that sometimes that value does not matter - for some cards it's so hard finding a mint or gem mint raw copy to send in that even if you get the money back from the insurance, you may not find another one as nice. I guess it's a risk, eh!
  • jimq112jimq112 Posts: 3,511 ✭✭✭
    If it got there empty it's not your carrier and you will be lucky to find your cards. It's going to be almost impossible to catch someone if they took them.

    They're experimenting with new "flat" sorting equipment and sometimes that equipment doesn't like tape. It's possible that somewhere along the way the tape got caught in the machine and pulled off, and the cards fell out. If that happens then you would hope some honest worker would see the cards loose and turn them in to their supervisor. Then you would hope further that they got sent to loose items and they're waiting for you.

    I recently bought a card from Troy (Favrefan) and it arrived in a bubble mailer with the end cleanly cut open. The card was inside. Troy told me he had taped it well, I believe him, but the card was half out of the bubble mailer when I got it. The envelope wasn't ripped open at all, but cut clean, and you can see that the tape was peeled back.

    image

    Anyway if the envelope arrived empty file the claim but it's a longshot that you get your cards back. If I can help let me know!
    image
  • Thanks - the top of the envelope was cleanly cut. It is one of those small USPS priority envelopes with the self-seal, but I did put a little bit of extra tape on there, so it's also possible that it got caught in the sorting machines.

    I'll make a stop at the post office today, and fill out the form there, hopefully something will turn up.
Sign In or Register to comment.