Cartledge Grades are in
halosfan
Posts: 2,643 ✭✭✭✭
Wondo .. here is what was behind curtain number 1!
LINE # CERT # CARD CARD CO. CARD # CARD NAME VARIETY GRADE
1 31780692 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 13 WILLIAM THOMPSON FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 9
2 31780693 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 10 TOM SPRING FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 7
3 31780694 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 44 GUSTAVE HUMERY FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 9OC
4 31780695 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 5 SAMUEL ELIAS FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 7
5 31780696 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 47 SMALL MONTANA FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
6 31780697 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 48 JOHN HENRY LEWIS FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 7
7 31780698 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 49 HARRY MIZLER FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS Not Holdered, Miscut
8 31780699 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 50 JACK DOYLE FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 7
9 31780700 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 45 BEN FOORD FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 4
10 31780701 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 43 JACK KID BERG FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
11 31780702 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 42 JOHNNY WARD FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
12 31780703 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 39 LEN HARVEY FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 9
13 31780704 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 40 JACK PETERSEN FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 9
14 31780705 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 41 BENNY LYNCH FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
15 31780706 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 29 MAX SCHMELING FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
16 31780707 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 28 HENRY ARMSTRONG FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 7
17 31780708 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 11 BILL NEAT FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 7
18 31780709 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 27 GUNNAR BARLUND FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
19 31780710 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 25 GEORGES CARPENTIER FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
20 31780711 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 26 JACK DEMPSEY FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
21 31780712 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 22 JAMES J. CORBETT FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
22 31780713 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 14 JAMES BURKE FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
23 31780714 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 15 TOM SAYERS FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
24 31780715 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 16 JEM MACE FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
25 31780716 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 17 TOM KING FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
26 31780717 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 19 BILL DOHERTY FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
27 31780718 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 20 PETER JACKSON FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
28 31780719 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 21 FRANK SLAVIN FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
29 31780720 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 12 JEM WARD FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
30 31780721 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 9 THOMAS MOLINEAUX FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
31 31780722 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 8 TOM CRIBB FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
32 31780723 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 7 JOHN GULLEY FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
33 31780724 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 6 TOM BELCHER FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 6
34 31780725 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 4 ISAAC PERRINS FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 7
35 31780726 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 3 TOM JOHNSON FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
36 31780727 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 18 JOHN L. SULLIVAN FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
37 31780728 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 38 EDDIE PHILLIPS FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 9OC
38 31780729 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 34 ARNO KOELBLIN FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
39 31780730 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 2 JACK SLACK FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
40 31780731 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 1 JOHN BROUGHTON FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 7
41 31780732 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 35 MAURICE STRICKLAND FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
42 31780733 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 36 PETE SARRON FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
43 31780734 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 37 TOMMY FARR FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
44 31780735 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 31 WALTER NEUSEL FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
45 31780736 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 32 AL ROTH FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 9
46 31780737 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 33 DON McCORKINDALE FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
47 31780738 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 23 CHARLES MITCHELL FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
48 31780739 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 24 BOB FITZSIMMONS FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
Lots of 8s ... very few 9s and a few lesser. I'm somewhat suprised by these results. I felt that there was the possibility of more 9s and even a 10 or 2. A few of the cards had some centering issues which would explain the few 7s and 9Ocs. No explanation until I get the cards back on the 4, 6, and miscut. I still can't believe that most of these cards were 8s by the looks of them. At least I din't get slammed on any of the name fighters. One or two will be upgrades and most will fit nicely into the set. I was really hoping to get real close to completing this set in 8 or better with this sub. Now I'm in that neverland of being almost complete with one set and having more than 1/2 of a second set. What to do???? Sell of the second set piecemeal or complete it and sell it as a whole or keep two.
C'est la vie I guess.
Matthew
Edited to add ... Thanks to Wondo. He is one of the best to deal with! And I would not hesitate to deal with him at any time.
LINE # CERT # CARD CARD CO. CARD # CARD NAME VARIETY GRADE
1 31780692 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 13 WILLIAM THOMPSON FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 9
2 31780693 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 10 TOM SPRING FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 7
3 31780694 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 44 GUSTAVE HUMERY FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 9OC
4 31780695 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 5 SAMUEL ELIAS FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 7
5 31780696 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 47 SMALL MONTANA FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
6 31780697 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 48 JOHN HENRY LEWIS FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 7
7 31780698 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 49 HARRY MIZLER FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS Not Holdered, Miscut
8 31780699 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 50 JACK DOYLE FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 7
9 31780700 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 45 BEN FOORD FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 4
10 31780701 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 43 JACK KID BERG FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
11 31780702 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 42 JOHNNY WARD FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
12 31780703 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 39 LEN HARVEY FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 9
13 31780704 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 40 JACK PETERSEN FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 9
14 31780705 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 41 BENNY LYNCH FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
15 31780706 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 29 MAX SCHMELING FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
16 31780707 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 28 HENRY ARMSTRONG FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 7
17 31780708 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 11 BILL NEAT FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 7
18 31780709 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 27 GUNNAR BARLUND FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
19 31780710 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 25 GEORGES CARPENTIER FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
20 31780711 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 26 JACK DEMPSEY FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
21 31780712 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 22 JAMES J. CORBETT FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
22 31780713 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 14 JAMES BURKE FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
23 31780714 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 15 TOM SAYERS FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
24 31780715 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 16 JEM MACE FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
25 31780716 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 17 TOM KING FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
26 31780717 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 19 BILL DOHERTY FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
27 31780718 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 20 PETER JACKSON FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
28 31780719 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 21 FRANK SLAVIN FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
29 31780720 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 12 JEM WARD FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
30 31780721 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 9 THOMAS MOLINEAUX FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
31 31780722 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 8 TOM CRIBB FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
32 31780723 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 7 JOHN GULLEY FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
33 31780724 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 6 TOM BELCHER FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 6
34 31780725 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 4 ISAAC PERRINS FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 7
35 31780726 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 3 TOM JOHNSON FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
36 31780727 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 18 JOHN L. SULLIVAN FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
37 31780728 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 38 EDDIE PHILLIPS FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 9OC
38 31780729 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 34 ARNO KOELBLIN FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
39 31780730 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 2 JACK SLACK FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
40 31780731 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 1 JOHN BROUGHTON FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 7
41 31780732 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 35 MAURICE STRICKLAND FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
42 31780733 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 36 PETE SARRON FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
43 31780734 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 37 TOMMY FARR FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
44 31780735 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 31 WALTER NEUSEL FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
45 31780736 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 32 AL ROTH FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 9
46 31780737 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 33 DON McCORKINDALE FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
47 31780738 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 23 CHARLES MITCHELL FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
48 31780739 1938 F.C. CARTLEDGE 24 BOB FITZSIMMONS FAMOUS PRIZE FIGHTERS 8
Lots of 8s ... very few 9s and a few lesser. I'm somewhat suprised by these results. I felt that there was the possibility of more 9s and even a 10 or 2. A few of the cards had some centering issues which would explain the few 7s and 9Ocs. No explanation until I get the cards back on the 4, 6, and miscut. I still can't believe that most of these cards were 8s by the looks of them. At least I din't get slammed on any of the name fighters. One or two will be upgrades and most will fit nicely into the set. I was really hoping to get real close to completing this set in 8 or better with this sub. Now I'm in that neverland of being almost complete with one set and having more than 1/2 of a second set. What to do???? Sell of the second set piecemeal or complete it and sell it as a whole or keep two.
C'est la vie I guess.
Matthew
Edited to add ... Thanks to Wondo. He is one of the best to deal with! And I would not hesitate to deal with him at any time.
Looking for a Glen Rice Inkredible and Alex Rodriguez cards
0
Comments
Thank you for the kind words. These are great cards, and I would love to see similarly graded exmples stack up to yours. That, of course, doesn't help in the registry, but you have GREAT cards.
John
I say sell the rest off piece by piece. There seem to be more collectors of this set now than there were just a few months ago so sell them off and use that money to finish the set.
Nice work!
Arthur
Congrats on finishing the set. You did it (mostly) the old-fashioned way of buying cards one at a time. Some guys just buy a set and have them all graded. (What I'm thinking about doing
Arthur
I think I may be a few cards shy of that but I'll know for sure when they all get back to me. It would be a nice goal to let the set rest once I get there.
Arthur