What would you rather have a 1948 Leaf PSA 7 Jackie Robinson or....

gwinny

a 1949 Bowman PSA 8 Jackie Robinson, and why? Not sure how many actually consider the Bowman as a rookie card although it's listed in the PSA set registry as one.

First time poster, have enjoyed the board for a long time.
Thanks,
Dave

GDM67

If you're just talking about something to have for your collection, I would prefer a PSA 8 1954 Topps to any other card of Mr. Robinson. That one captures his greatness better than any other, for me.

perkdog

I like the Leaf better, but my fav is the '55 Topps