Options
Toned 1916 Buffalo nickel (with some peculiarities)
While my photos do not indicate it, the reverse on this one is rotated about 25% or so in the counterclockwise direction. The arc by the buffalo's knee is standing out of the surface and is not a scratch...any idea what it is? It was suggested to me that it might be from a clashed die, but I can't see any of the normal clashed die stuff on the reverse.
Also, is this the no F variety listed in the Cherrypickers guide?



Also, is this the no F variety listed in the Cherrypickers guide?



"Have a nice day!"
0
Comments
Your coin just misses, as there can be some of the initial visibly seen.
TPG's can be very brutal when attributing this coin.
The reverse looks like a strike-through. Could possibly be a piece of metal that got on the die.
If the coin was not rotated, I would say that it was a clash, because when you line up the coin, that location is where the eye would be.
Pete
WTP Complete Variety Set
WTP 2 Feathers
Strange coincidence?
[URL=http://imageshack.us]
[URL=http://imageshack.us]
[URL=http://imageshack.us]
[URL=http://imageshack.us]
The matching die rotation is kind of weird though, I haven't seen this clash before, mostly just 'chin whiskers'.
But I get a feeling it's not all that uncommon, hopefully one of the Buff experts will provide some insight/examples.
On which dates is it most common?
<< <i> Not a no "F" variety... >>
Buffnut - Are you sure about that? I can just make out the top of the F, but I would still think this qualifies, especially considering it's BU.
<< <i>
<< <i> Not a no "F" variety... >>
Buffnut - Are you sure about that? I can just make out the top of the F, but I would still think this qualifies, especially considering it's BU. >>
Well, I guess it depends on what school of buff varieties you come from. The purists would say that it wouldn't qualify unless there is absolutely no evidence of the "F" whatsoever. Others would allow for a partial "F". As BuffaloIronTail mentioned, it may be difficult to get a TPG to slab it as such, since there is still the top line of the initial showing.
Since this date is known with a completely missing "F", then it makes it even harder to pass as a true no "F" IMHO.
WTP Complete Variety Set
WTP 2 Feathers
Spur leg buff
Looks like it is definitely a die clash mark.
WTP Complete Variety Set
WTP 2 Feathers