,,

sTONER · February 23, 2007 9:38AM

here we have a stunning 88-0 hot lips in an NGC au 50,, picture is a scan, but coin is WHITE, with very light rim tones,, this beauty should cross no problem, not a beat up maxed out Tomb,, Coinworld price listed is 2500.00,, PCGS price listed is 3000.00, im putting her up here at 1100.00 ,, ( i will allow a 48 hr return privilage) any questions please feel free to pm me,,steve

Yale68 · February 23, 2007 10:20PM

You are asking too much. The going rate for an AU50 is between $800 and $950. The PCGS price that you quote is for an AU55.

sTONER · February 23, 2007 10:49PM

<< You are asking too much. The going rate for an AU50 is between $800 and $950. The PCGS price that you quote is for an AU55. >>

PCGS price guide says AU ( AU STARTS AT 50-58 ) for you being the authority on these,, you can take 10% off with free shipping,,steve

sTONER · February 24, 2007 8:48AM

roadrunner · February 24, 2007 8:54AM

Interesting. I saw a PCGS AU58 at my local shop mid-last year and it was priced around $2500 as I recall. An AU50 at half that amount doesn't seem outlandish. In any case, I'm no expert on the pricing of these.

But if this AU50 is more like an EF45+, that's a world of difference.

roadrunner

Nocerino18 · February 24, 2007 8:58AM

<< You are asking too much. The going rate for an AU50 is between $800 and $950. The PCGS price that you quote is for an AU55. >>

I agree. Check out these past auction that sold:

1888-O S$1 PCGS AU50 Hot Lips Sold on Ebay

sTONER · February 24, 2007 9:26PM

price has been lowered guys,, if you want a beat up piece of chit, buy the $800-$950 tomb,, or if you want a clean enjoyable coin,one you can keep and enjoy,, this one is it,,any questions,, feel free,,steve

DenverDave · February 24, 2007 11:49PM

<< 

<< You are asking too much. The going rate for an AU50 is between $800 and $950. The PCGS price that you quote is for an AU55. >>

I agree. Check out these past auction that sold:

1888-O S$1 PCGS AU50 Hot Lips Sold on Ebay >>

Nocerino18...

I took your advise and checked eBay, I think your prices on eBay are too high...

Take this 1892-CC MS65 you have listed @ $7500.00...

Click here to view 1892-CC MS65 on eBay...

Another seller had it up last week and it only bid up to $6800...

Click Here to see same 1892-CC listed last week on eBay by another seller...

Plus your using the same photos, what's up with that...?

Maybe you guys should use the PM Function instead of trashing someone FS thread with your "spoon"...

Silvermonstercoins · February 25, 2007 8:07AM

I would never reference Ebay as a place to price coins. There are so many people who over state coins that when someone actually lists as stated people sit on the fences and Ebay becomes a wholesale market if any thing and only if the coin is graded by a service will it ever achieve anything near the true value of most honestly listed coins. Just my two cents worth.

I hardly ever list without a price stated that I will take as a minimum offer which 90 plus percent of the time is the price of the coin if bid on at all.

Rampage · February 25, 2007 11:38AM

<< here we have a stunning 88-0 hot lips in an NGC au 50,, picture is a scan, but coin is WHITE, with very light rim tones,, this beauty should cross no problem, not a beat up maxed out Tomb,, Coinworld price listed is 2500.00,, PCGS price listed is 3000.00, im putting her up here at 1100.00 ( serious offers considered),, ( i will allow a 48 hr return privilage) any questions please feel free to pm me,,steve

>>

Actually, I think the price you are asking is fine. It is a nice looking coin. Good luck on the sale.

sTONER · February 26, 2007 3:33AM

thanx Richard, she, a looker for sure,,

SeaEagleCoins · February 26, 2007 10:24AM

Nice Coin Stoner

sTONER · February 26, 2007 8:58PM

thanx new guy,, thats sTONER,,

sTONER · February 27, 2007 11:45PM

sTONER · February 28, 2007 11:50PM

cumon guys this is a killer coin

Silvermonstercoins · March 1, 2007 2:10AM

Cross it to PCGS and I am sure you will get more people interested.

DennisH · March 1, 2007 3:34AM

" Interesting. I saw a PCGS AU58 at my local shop mid-last year and it was priced around $2500 as I recall. An AU50 at half that amount doesn't seem outlandish. In any case, I'm no expert on the pricing of these."

Roadrunner: You missed a monster bargain. Here are the four PCGS-58 examples I have sales records for:

1888-O 4 58 PCGS Dec-06 TT $8,064
1888-O 4 58 PCGS Apr-06 PP $12,000
1888-O 4 58 PCGS Mar-06 PP $12,000
1888-O 4 58 PCGS Jan-05 H $8,912

(TT is Teletrade, PP is private party [I know the guy who sold both of them], and H is Heritage).

sTONER · March 1, 2007 10:34PM

thanx for the price info Dennis,,

pbfloyd · March 2, 2007 12:21AM

The coin is not AU-50 iT IS EF-45

DennisH · March 2, 2007 1:01AM

The coin is not AU-50 iT IS EF-45

No, it says right there on the holder that it's an AU50.

Your opinion is that it's an XF45.

SeaEagleCoins · March 2, 2007 3:19AM

<< The coin is not AU-50 iT IS EF-45 >>

.and you are an expert whose word is gospel?

...I suppose you stopped by and offered this 'opinon' while you were on break from your job at one of the top grading services as their senior grader???

sTONER · March 2, 2007 5:31AM

<< The coin is not AU-50 iT IS EF-45 >>

,, what are you some sort of a pin head no it all ???? dousche

sTONER · March 2, 2007 10:38PM

Rampage · March 3, 2007 4:21AM

<< The coin is not AU-50 iT IS EF-45 >>

It looks more AU50ish to me than XF45. I've got an XF45 that boarders AU50 and this coin is well beyond my coin.

coindeuce · March 3, 2007 12:26PM

Stick to your $1100 mark on this one Steve. I sold a raw AU-55(my grade) in 2005 on the Bay for $1500. And the prices on these damn sure hasn't gone south.

Nocerino18 · March 3, 2007 1:13PM

Ok, my chance to respond back a little. Mr. Stoner, I actually think your AU50 example is a nice one, and $1100 is a much more reasonable and realistic price. I believe if I remember correctly the original price was $1500 which was much more than the going rate. I wasn't bashing you or your coin I was just agreeing with a prior members comment and showing a comparable.

Now as for the 1892-CC S$1 PCGS MS65. My business partner had listed it under his account and it was bid up to $6800. I as half owner of the coin decided that listing the coin with a reserve was not the correct way to list it, and so I listed it at a fixed price of $7,500. This in fact turned out to be the correct avenue to sell the coin because one of our regular customers saw the coin listed on ebay and came into the shop to check it out in person, and needless to say the coin is no longer available for sale.

- Alex

sTONER · March 5, 2007 9:33PM

thanx CD, im sticking to 1100.00 on this beauty.. hey Alex apology accepted and thankyou for the compliment on her, she is a beauty and nobodys steeling this one..

sTONER · March 6, 2007 10:00PM

sTONER · March 8, 2007 10:20PM

sTONER · March 9, 2007 10:00PM

pbfloyd · March 11, 2007 6:46AM

Guess I should ttt the thread after flaming it!..................It is a nice example

sTONER · March 12, 2007 6:38AM

thankyou, she, is pertty nice,,

sTONER · March 16, 2007 8:20AM

snowman;

:snowmsnowman;

an;

snowman;

:ssnowman;

nowman;

:snosnowman;

wman;

snowman;

sTONER · March 16, 2007 10:07PM

,,

Comments