Your thoughts please.

fiveniner

]


This card was rejected by PSA as a non holdered miscut submitted twice.Knowing this could it still generate any interest to any collector of a 59 topps set?This card is by far one of the toughest in the set.I would not hide this fact if I do try to sell it.
Hanebrink No Trade.Excuse my scan the edges are not choppy as shown on image.
I would like some opinions before deciding.

goose3

hard to give an opinion....

your image makes the card appear to be perforated like a stamp......at least on my monitor.

shouldabeena10

CON40

The right edge is completely out of whack. Plus, it looks like a fairly significant diamond cut. I'm not surprised PSA rejected it.

262Runner

The miscut is obvious on the right side.

Card would fit nicely into a raw set however.

262

fiveniner

Looking at this scan it is definetly apparent that it is miscut.In its actual size I did not notice it till I got it back from PSA the second time.
I purchased it on Ebay about 4 years ago and paid way too much for it.Unfortuantley I was not into Professionaly graded cards at the time.

KyleBicking

You could get it authenticated, no grade. I'm not familiar with the card, but if it will help it sell, its worth the money grading it.

1960toppsguy

Just trim it up a bit and resubmit, that usually will do the trick!

Hubcap

59er:

It is my experience with PSA that miscut has nothing to do with diamond cut. It has to do with either the minimum size requirements of the card, or, if you hold the card against a stack of other raw 59 cards, the cut is not square with these other cards.

I had a 57 card that came back twice...first for evid of trim and then the second time for miscut. I matched it up with other 57s and just couldn't figure out what was the problem. It also definitely wasn't trimmed as it had no smooth sides under magnification. So I sent it in a third time and it got an 8.

Just hard to figure. I guess it just depends on the grader's professional interpretation, time of the year, and/or hour of the day. I would suggest putting it in a box and forgetting about it, and then resubmitting just before the National next August.

AZ

lostdart58

There are alot of collectors out there who still collect RAW...........My 59 set is raw................I think I paid about $30 for my example about 3 years ago.......Yours is better centered, mine is not ..

diamondman

Sometimes if the card is to big to fit the holder/ oversized card instead of undersized (min size reg) it will get a miscut label, it looks to me left to right is larger in width than other 59's check it with a couple other 59's.