So if you could have one lot at Heritage's upcoming sale, what would it be?

sonofagunk

Here is mine:
Lot 1353: Auction 422 1868 1C Aluminum Proof Set.

Imagine, an entire proof set in ALUMINUM. Even the $20 "gold" Double Eagle.

Indian cent Judd-612, Pollock-677, PR65.
Two cent piece Judd-614, Pollock-679, PR66.
Three cent nickel Judd-621, Pollock-690, PR65.
Three cent silver Judd-622, Pollock-691, PR65.
Shield nickel Judd-636, Pollock-708, PR64.
Seated Liberty half dime Judd-639, Pollock-711, PR65.
Seated Liberty dime Judd-649, Pollock-722, PR66.
Seated Liberty quarter Judd-650, Pollock-723, PR64.
Seated Liberty half dollar Judd-651, Pollock-724, PR65.
Seated Liberty silver dollar Judd-652, Pollock-725, PR66.
Indian Head gold dollar Judd-653, Pollock-726, PR65.
Liberty Head quarter eagle Judd-654, Pollock-727, PR64.
Indian Head three dollar Judd-655, Pollock-728, PR64.
Liberty Head half eagle Judd-660, Pollock-733, PR64.
Liberty Head eagle Judd-664, Pollock-739, PR64.
Liberty Head double eagle Judd-665, Pollock-740, PR65.

Julian

I haven't gone over the whole catalogue yet, but I have always been partial to Saint-Gaudens.

Consequently, my initial choice is the 1907 Ultra HR double eagle.

swhuck

Julian, I've seen that coin up close and personal, and it would, without question, be my choice. It may be the most beautiful coin I've ever seen, period.