Feedback requested: Which Bust $ is a higher grade?

dizzyfoxx

...and guess each grade, and please explain why you came to your conclusion?

#1




"or"

#2

Cam40

both are ef45 less wear more like weakly struck.

Wisconsin

I will say coin #1 grades XF45 beacause of the luster and #2 XF40 for lack of luster.

Edited to add that I like both coins

MisterBungle

I don't know, but I looked at them so long, I
feel like I have to say something, so...

If I had a choice of which one to take home
with me, I would choose the first one. I just
like the look of it better.

~

cape

I LIKE THE FIRST COIN BETTER.

coinkat

1 is better than 2 but both may be the same grade... likely both are 45

DennisH

#2 looks to me to have less wear.

options26

#1 is the better coin, #2 is the better picture.

Wisconsin

Can you tell us the grades on these dollars??

michael

40 and 45 respectively

mozin

I don't know the series, but I would guess #1 is PCGS VF35, and #2 is NGC XF45.

I like coin #1 better.

STONE

I definitely like coin #1 more, though I have to give the higher grade to #2. It hurts to do that because of the lack of luster in #2, but there is slightly more detail than #1.

ajaan

Is that a scratch on Liberty's cheek in #1?

lasvegasteddy

i personally see less wear on #2,but like the look of #1 but note...,i see a difference in the reverses in the positioning of the letters of "states" to the clouds and wonder which variety holds more value?

Frankcoins

#1 seems to have mint luster, so I will guess 1 AU50 and 2 EF40