Won this card, any guesses on what it will grade? UPDATE- GRADE POPPED

mkg809

edited to add: I think it was worth $10.50.

mkg809

Here is the back

Bosox1976

I'd say a 7. From what I can see of the bottom left corner and the border chip alomg the top edge of the reverse, an 8 seems out of reach. Great color & gloss!

yawie99

Is that a wrinkle on the lower right of the reverse or just a scratch on the holder? I'm guessing the latter, so I'll say 7.

julen23

that card would make 1 helluva a classic poster!!!

i say 7 or 8 if some nameless lucky board members submitted!

julen

Webhead1968

I will agree with 7 because of the rough edge and centering. Otherwise a real nice card.

onlyanumber

<< <i>Is that a wrinkle on the lower right of the reverse or just a scratch on the holder? I'm guessing the latter, so I'll say 7. >>



I'm guessing it's a wrinkle and would say a 4...

lostdart58

<< <i>I will agree with 7 because of the rough edge and centering. Otherwise a real nice card. >>



A rough cut like that can still get a PSA 9.

fiveniner

6

jmbkb4

Looks like a 6-7 to me

ArnyVee

Looks like a solid little 7...outside chance of a weak 8. This is all based on that not being a wrinkle.

baseballfanatic

6

larryallen73

8oc

stevek

Nice card! High end 6 or a 7. Appears as though the cards were stored upright vertically in a shoebox, so there won't be much surface wear or hardly any wear to the top corners, but over the years the bottom corners received some wear from rubbing against the cardboard shoebox.

bsfastball

8

downtown

Looking at the image of back of card...there appears to be more room between card and holder on bottom left than at the top....misscut or trimmed?

brianwintersfan

6-7

Southerncards

My eye says trimmed, both left and right sides.

NewJerseyMeatHook

11.

Carew29

with those edges i thought it was an OPC card until i saw Topps on the back.

zef204

<< <i>

<< <i>I will agree with 7 because of the rough edge and centering. Otherwise a real nice card. >>



A rough cut like that can still get a PSA 9. >>

I agree, they can also get PSA 10's. I had a 67 Philly that was an SGC92 due to rough cuts and it got a PSA 10 to my surprised.


My opinion, that’s a nice looking card. Anyone who throws out a number or "trimmed" has very little to base their guess on. Especially from a photo and not a scan. That being said, the rough cut WILL NOT hurt the grade. The top corners look sharp and the bottom corners can not really be seen well. If the scratches are on the case, and not a wrinkle on the bottom corner, I think there is a chance the card could score well. The centering may be an issue, or the severity pf it may be just the angle of the pic.

Nice card, IMO from the limited images it looks nicer than a 6, and maybe even than a 7. A lot of variables are unknown(centering, wrinkles) so no one can really make an intelligent guess at this point.

mkg809

1967 TOPPS 423 FENCE BUSTERS W.MAYS/W.McCOVEY 8

It was worth the $10.50 I paid for it!

onlyanumber

Congrats!!! What's the SMR on an 8?

Stone193

<< <i>1967 TOPPS 423 FENCE BUSTERS W.MAYS/W.McCOVEY 8

It was worth the $10.50 I paid for it! >>


Congratulations!

I think that's a great grade - I wasn't sure since I couldn't see the bottom corners - I thought the top ones were strong.

I don't know what the card is worth in 8 but I'm sure you got your 10 bucks worth!

thanx for sharing
mike

Bosox1976

I am delighted thay my guess of a 7 proved too low. Congratulations.

VintageJeff

SMR in 8 is $100

Nice job.

digicat

So, you gonna flip it or keep it?

zef204

Awesome grade! The top corners looked strong and I guess the bottom were strong enough to fetch an 8.

Congratulations!

mkg809

So, you gonna flip it or keep it?

I think I'm gonna keep unless I get a really good offer.

cravetopps

straight 7 or 8 OC if not trimmed. the edges seem very rough but I have seen that before and does not mean it's trimmed or if the lower right is not a crease or a slight tear.