a list of recent crackouts and results

cohocorp

in case anyone finds this of interest, here are results of a number of crackouts. this is a decent sampling of a relatively large list. All of these are 1952 topps baseball.

#1 pafko was Gai 5.5 crossed to = psa 5
#4 lenhardt Sgc 60 = psa 5
#5 jansen Sgc 60 = psa 5
#10 rosen Gai 4.5 = psa 4
#16 hermanski Gai 5.5 = psa 5
#28 priddy Sgc 50 = psa 4
#31 zernial Gai 5 = psa 6
#32 robinson Sgc 50 = psa 5
#37 snider Sgc 60 = psa 5
#55 boone Sgc 80 = psa 6
#56 glaviano Gai 5.5 = psa 5
#58 mahoney Sgc 60 = psa 5
#63 pollette Gai 5 = psa 5
#65 slaughter Gai 5 = psa 4
#73 werle Sgc 60 = psa 4
#80 wehmeier Gai 4 = psa 4
#106 vernon Sgc 50 = psa 5
#107 ryan Sgc 70 = psa 6
#112 majeski Gai 7 = psa 6
#117 lollar Sgc 60 = psa 5
#119 mcdermott Gai 5.5 = psa 5
#136 schmitz Sgc 80 = psa 7
#137 mcmillan Gai 4.5 = psa 5
#155 overmire Gai 5 = psa 4
#164 dubiel Gai 5 = psa 5
#167 howerton Gai 5 = psa 5
#187 miller Gai 5 = psa 5
#201 kellner Gai 4 = psa 5
#212 garver Gai 5 = psa 6
#230 batts Gai 5 = psa 5
#235 dropo Sgc 60 = psa 5
#248 shea Gai 5 = psa 5
#253 berardino Gai 5 = psa 5
#257 avila Gai 4.5 = psa 4
#262 trucks Sgc 70 = psa 5
#265 diering Gai 6 = psa 6
#273 palica Gai 4.5 = psa 4
#284 arft Gai 4 = psa 5
#285 fannin Gai 4 = psa 4
#288 nichols Sgc 70 = psa 6
#292 baker Gai 5.5 = psa 4
#293 sisti Gai 4 = psa 4
#294 cooper Gai 5 = psa 5
#296 rolfe Gai 5 = psa 5
#297 seminick Gai 5.5 = psa 5
#299 murray Gai 4 = psa 4
#301 porterfield Gai 4 = psa 4
#305 richards Gai 6 = psa 6
#316 williams Sgc 50 = psa 5
#320 rutherford Sgc 50 = psa 5
#325 serena Gai 5 = psa 4
#326 shuba Sgc 60 = psa 5
#327 wilson Sgc 50 = psa 5
#328 borkowski Sgc 50 = psa 4
#332 bartirome Gai 5 = psa 5
#335 lepcio Gai 5 = psa 4
#336 koslo Sgc 50 = psa 5
#337 hearn Sgc 60 = psa 2 – a 3 grade drop!
#344 blackwell Sgc 50 = psa 4
#345 white Sgc 60 = psa 5
#346 spencer Sgc 60 = psa 5
#348 kelly Sgc 60 = psa 5
#350 abrams Sgc 70 = psa 6
#351 dark Sgc 60 = psa 4
#352 drews Gai 5 = psa 5
#354 hatfield Gai 5 = psa 5
#358 kucab Sgc 50 = psa 5
#359 fondy Sgc 60 = psa 5
#366 madison Sgc 60 = psa 5
#368 wright Sgc 50 = psa 4
#369 groat Sgc 50 = psa 4
#370 hoeft Sgc 60 = psa 5
#371 hofman Sgc 50 = psa 5
#372 mcdougald Gai 5.5 = psa 5
#374 benton Sgc 60 = psa 5
#378 fusselman Sgc 60 = psa 5
#383 wilber Sgc 50 = psa 4
#384 crosetti Sgc 50 = psa 6
#386 yuhas Sgc 50 = psa 4
#388 chipman Gai 5.5 = psa 5
#389 wade Sgc 60 = psa 5
#390 nelson Sgc 50 = psa 4
#392 wilhelm Gai 4 = psa 4
#395 pitman Sgc 50 = psa 4
#396 williams Sgc 60 = psa 5
#397 main Gai 4 = psa 4
#401 schultz Sgc 60 = psa 5
#402 harrist Sgc 60 = psa 5
#404 brodowski Sgc 50 = psa 4
#405 pellagrini Sgc 70 = psa 6

XanaduNow

Cohocorp, do you work for GAI?

The SGC crossovers didn't really surprise me but I don't think I saw once GAI lose more than a grade (some went up) when crossed to PSA. Maybe I need to start scooping up some cheap GAIs and try to cross them over. Thanks for sharing, that was interesting.

Arthur

Mefer

With the exception of the one card you commented on, fairly consistent across the board. I am always interested in seeing cross-over results and this, as you say, is a fairly large sample. Thanks for sharing.

yawie99

Now you just need to crack them out of their PSA slabs and send them back to Newport Beach. I'd bet we'd see more inconsistency that way than with your inter-company results.

Bosox1976

Always interesting stuff.

1989FleerBillRipkencollector

Interesting. I own some GAI 9.5 FF versions that are overgraded. But recently I have had a BGS 9 come back a GAI 8.5 and one I thought would get a 9.5 came back a 8.5

meuandthelot

Thanks for the results.


I wonder what this would re-grade? by me a 6 max

http://www.scpauctions.com/scpauctions/LotDetail.cfm?Lot_ID=10387

leadoff4

Excellent info. I love this type of information. Thanks Cohocorp!

cohocorp

xanadunow-- no, i do not work for anyone. i got alot of those gai cards from kit young.

this was actually a pain to get this list together, but i figured some of you guys would be interested in the info. i crossed everything to psa for my registry set. i was pretty happy with the pafko and the crosetti. 2 toughies. now as for the hearn dropping 3 grades, it is a possibility that i damaged it cracking it out. it was a long, tough day. i didnt notice damaging it, but it is possible. i used heavy duty pliers and a miniature crowbar. got bloodied up and blistered. i got pretty good at it though. 5 seconds to break out of a gai holder. sgc is tougher. i broke a bvg once and had to use a hammer. not again.

cohocorp

julen23

no doubt, thanx for sharing your x-over results...

i have 1 gai card i sent in on this month's modern special, it had great corners, but there was a small stain or print defect in the background...

julen

aro13

Very consistent results - well done!!

itsinthegrade

from this post its nice to see gai is grading accurately. there was never no ? that they had talented graders there but they always had the stigma as over graders.

Griffins

It shows me that for the most part the grading company's are pretty consistant. I had similar results a few years ago with a few dozen Cracker Jacks.