84 topps payton psa 10...how high

ldferg

where will this one end??? man, how does mojo do it?

it's a pop 1... wow! ssgunn...good luck.


84 topps payton


150+ psa 10s.

grote15

Sweet card, but centering looks weak for a PSA 10, esp. a pop 1 of 1, IMO.

CDsNuts

Yeah, looks 40/60 LR and 45/55 TB.

Lee

5STAT

$3500.....might have hit $5K IF it was nicer....

left border looks like it has a touch...but could be a shadow...either way....nice hit!!!

bri2327

There will be some " buy the holder, not the card " sucker out there who will take a bath on that one.

I wonder how many 9's are laying around that look far better than that.

BigRedMachine

<< <i>There will be some " buy the holder, not the card " sucker out there who will take a bath on that one.

I wonder how many 9's are laying around that look far better than that. >>



Brian, great point. And with so much unopened, too, there are bound to be far better looking cards out there. Another example of a card that will sell for $3000 today as a 1 of 1, and then $400 in a few years when there are multiple examples.

Didn't the guys who paid $5000 for PSA 10's of McGwire and Griffey learn anything??

Of course, if this were my auction, they'd pull it for putting 1 of 1 in the title!!

shawn

bri2327

Shawn,

I see that " have to have the first one " mentality nearly ever week, though on a lesser scale, with my Mattingly master set.

So many 1 of 1's are fought over by the same 2 or 3 guys, with the card going in the $50-100 range. I pass those over and more often than not within 2 months there are suddenly 4 or 5 of the card in PSA 10, the few guys who HAD to have it at the beginning are out of the race, and I pick the card up for its $9.99 opening bid.

You really would think some of these guys would learn.

metalmike20

This is not a 1 of 1 even, this is the second psa-10 of this card. The first psa-10 is already in a set on the registry and I just double checked the pop and it says pop of 2. Still a great card though, I doubt I'll land it!

Mike

ldferg

these 2 must have just popped in the last month if there are now 2.

metalmike20

I can't wait to see the day when a psa-10 1985 topps Payton gets graded, now that we are talking about some $$!! It's going to be a tough card to get a 10 on if ever actually. I'm surprised the 1984 Payton took so long to get a psa-10 considering how much 84 material has been submitted the last couple of years. I know the 84 has many printing flaws and centering issues though.

Mike

NHLfightguy

Now that I know there is actually 2 in a 10. I say it goes for between $800-$1200...........

gregm13

<< <i>There will be some " buy the holder, not the card " sucker out there who will take a bath on that one.

I wonder how many 9's are laying around that look far better than that. >>



I couldn't have said it better myself - not very nice at all....for a PSA 10. I have cards better than that end up in PSA 8 holders every submission.

Regards,

Greg M.

ssgunnip

I am not in on that one LDferg. The only one of ones I buy are usually Cowboys rookies, but I appeciate you thinking of me as a player!

ssgunn