I didnt think it was possible...

bri2327

To garner a PSA 10 AND PSA/DNA certified....doesnt the auto make it NOT a PSA 10 ?

PSA 10 ?

ToppsCo1lector

Don't know, but it's a sweet card.

lawnmowerman

Not really sure but I see what your saying. It sure is a nice card though. I always liked '92 Fleer.

detroitfan2

Not the best scan, but here's another currently on ebay. My birthday is on Thanksgiving this year, as a side note.

lawnmowerman

<< <i>Not the best scan, but here's another currently on ebay. My birthday is on Thanksgiving this year, as a side note.

>>

Tom, why would you want a card of that Magic dude when you could get a card of the greatest B Ball player ever?




matt

detroitfan2

<<Tom, why would you want a card of that Magic dude when you could get a card of the greatest B Ball player ever?>>

Matt, good question. I want the Magic card because he is from Michigan State. Sometimes, we collect cards for sentimental reasons, even if it means collecting a marginal player or two. I'm kind of preaching to the choir here, I know . . .

softparade

Bri,

Looks like Donnie just fouled one off!! Nice card

lawnmowerman

<< <i><<Tom, why would you want a card of that Magic dude when you could get a card of the greatest B Ball player ever?>>

Matt, good question. I want the Magic card because he is from Michigan State. Sometimes, we collect cards for sentimental reasons, even if it means collecting a marginal player or two. I'm kind of preaching to the choir here, I know . . . >>

BigRedMachine

<< <i>Not really sure but I see what your saying. It sure is a nice card though. I always liked '92 Fleer. >>



Matt, I think Brian means that, by definition, a card with writing on it couldn't be a PSA 10. I could be wrong (again)

I have seen a lot of PSA 10 cards and a lot of PSA certified cards, but don't recall seeing both. And if that's not Brians point, it makes a little sense. How is a card that has writing on it a psa 10??(auto or not)

shawn

edited to say: I thought Matt said I'm not sure what you're saying. I don't read so good.

bri2327

Shawn,

That was my point exactly. Doesnt the writing on the card whether its an auto or not make it by definition NOT a PSA 10 card ?

BTW, that isnt my card. I saw it on ebay and it had me baffled.

XanaduNow

<< <i><<Tom, why would you want a card of that Magic dude when you could get a card of the greatest B Ball player ever?>>

Matt, good question. I want the Magic card because he is from Michigan State. Sometimes, we collect cards for sentimental reasons, even if it means collecting a marginal player or two. I'm kind of preaching to the choir here, I know . . . >>





Detroitfan is on fire tonight.

Arthur

XanaduNow

Ahem ... I think we all know who the greatest basketball player of all-time is ...



And no, I'm not talking about Jabbar.

Arthur

Stone193

Bri

I thought that PSA decided to grade the card with the PSA/DNA authentication if someone chooses.

This has nothing to do with the "regular" grading service that you are speaking about - I believe.

mike

lawnmowerman

<< <i>

<< <i>Not really sure but I see what your saying. It sure is a nice card though. I always liked '92 Fleer. >>



Matt, I think Brian means that, by definition, a card with writing on it couldn't be a PSA 10. I could be wrong (again)

I have seen a lot of PSA 10 cards and a lot of PSA certified cards, but don't recall seeing both. And if that's not Brians point, it makes a little sense. How is a card that has writing on it a psa 10??(auto or not)

shawn >>

shawn,

Yes I knew what he was saying about the auto on the card. Sorry for the misunderstanding but I replied "Not really sure but I see what your saying" I was saying not really sure to the question;

<< <i>doesnt the auto make it NOT a PSA 10 ? >>

and "I see what your saying" about the writing on the card.

matt

bri2327

<< <i>Bri

I thought that PSA decided to grade the card with the PSA/DNA authentication if someone chooses.

This has nothing to do with the "regular" grading service that you are speaking about - I believe.

mike >>



So, if I am understanding you correctly, the GEM MINT 10 grade refers to the auto, not the card ?

ToppsCo1lector

<< <i>Ahem ... I think we all know who the greatest basketball player of all-time is ...



And no, I'm not talking about Jabbar.

Arthur >>


I'm a HUGE fan of Pistol.

jradke4

The Majic card is a bad comparason. It was issued with the Auto on it. The Mattingly was signed in person/

lawnmowerman

<< <i>edited to say: I thought Matt said I'm not sure what you're saying. I don't read so good. >>



No problem Shawn! I could see after reading what I wrote that it was an easy thing to look over

Matt

ctsoxfan

How can that card be a PSA 10 with that awful "Yankee" logo on it?

earlycalguy

the card is graded a 10, not the auto. if the autograph was the 10 then i believe it says autograph grade on the flip.

i don't see why it can't be graded a 10. if the autograph writing was a factor in the card grade then i guess i'll signed cards would have a MK qualifier.

detroitfan2

<<The Majic card is a bad comparason. It was issued with the Auto on it. The Mattingly was signed in person/ >>

That's a good point jradke.

It is also my understanding that the PSA 10 on the original card of this post is the grade for the card, not for the autograph. But I just checked the PSA web-site, and I am amazed at the lack of information about the grading of autographed cards.

detroitfan2

<<Detroitfan is on fire tonight.

Arthur>>

Thanks Arthur! At least someone appreciates my humor (or lack thereof).

-Tom