Oh well, I did the Bluemoon coin Best Offer thing

ajaan

Thought I would give it a try with some raw Canadian coins. I made three offers. One was rejected, one was counter offered (I declined it), one was accepted. The one accepted had a BIN price of $1,195.00. I offered $150 and it was accepted. Once the coin arrives I'll tell you whether I did well, or I crapped out royally.

Cladiator

"Gutsiest move I've ever seen Mav"

wildjag

<< <i>Thought I would give it a try with some raw Canadian coins. I made three offers. One was rejected, one was counter offered (I declined it), one was accepted. The one accepted had a BIN price of $1,195.00. I offered $150 and it was accepted. Once the coin arrives I'll tell you whether I did well, or I crapped out royally. >>



Wow that sure is a hellva markup they had posted

Kurt4

I trust Ajaan's judgement. If the coin is worth $150 or a total piece of crap I would be interested in Bluemooncoins justifying their BIN price of $1,195. That just does not seem right.




Edited for spelling.

ajaan

Here is the link to the coin.

It arrived today. Bluemoon called it MS63, I call it AU58. Not too bad. An AU50 coin Trends for C$160 and MS60 C$300 so I really didn't get the deal of a century but I wasn't really screwed either. Either way this is no way a $1000 coin.

BS

I was just looking through their auctions talk about sleazy.

coinpictures

<< <i>I trust Ajaan's judgement. If the coin is worth $150 or a total piece of crap I would be interested in Bluemooncoins justifying their BIN price of $1,195. That just does not seem right.
>>



Playing devil's advocate for a second, no seller has any duty or obligation to justify their pricing, whether it be starting price, BIN, or reserve. People ask moon money for things all the time, including on this very forum. As a buyer you have 3 choices: (1) pay their price, (2) make an offer, or (3) move along.

I've said in an earlier post that I suspect the reason for the ludicrously high BIN prices is so that they can screen prospective buyers and potentially weigh competing offers. While I'll admit that they take the pricing to an extreme, it logically makes sense.

(of course I may be projecting logical thought where none exists , and maybe they price them that way because they insanely think there's a snowball's chance in hell of them actually getting that price... however I doubt it).

ajaan

The coin I won Trends for C$1200 in MS63 which is where they probably got their pricing from.

Kurt4

Ajaan, I'm glad you got your money's worth. As for their pricing, since it trends $1200 in MS63 that does make sense. Whether the coin is a 63 is another matter. Coinpictures does make sense. They just take the risk that some buyers (like myself) will ignore their auctions. If they have a $300 coin priced at $1000 and somebody offers them $700, then they have done quite well.