A bunch of submission results are in ... 10/16 on crossovers

JustMakesCents

For those who care, I have some PCGS submission results in. Comments are welcome!

This was my first crossover attempt. All were NGC same-grade crossovers except the 39-S.
01 1 10489174 2461 1913 1C US MS65RD (was NGC 65RD)
02 1 10489175 2464 1913-D 1C US DNC (NGC MS66RD - Pop 2/0 NGC, 5/0 PCGS - Had to try it!)
03 1 10489176 2482 1915-D 1C US MS65RD (was NGC 65RD)
04 1 10489177 2502 1917-S 1C US DNC (NGC MS64RD - Really thought this one had a good shot)
05 1 10489178 2509 1918-D 1C US MS64RD (was NGC 64RD)
06 1 10489179 2545 1923 1C US MS66RD (was NGC 66RD - this was a no-brainer)
07 1 10489180 2560 1925 1C US MS66RD (was NGC 66RD)
08 1 10489181 2560 1925 1C US DNC (NGC MS67RD - Had to give it a shot!)
09 1 10489182 2563 1925-D 1C US MS64RD (was NGC 64RD)
10 1 10489183 2569 1926 1C US MS66RD (was NGC 66RD)
11 1 10489184 2578 1927 1C US DNC (NGC MS66RD - Not sure on this one)
12 1 10489185 2578 1927 1C US MS66RD (was NGC 66RD - another no-brainer)
13 1 10489186 2587 1928 1C US DNC (NGC MS67RD - 68RD obv + 66.5 rev)
14 1 10489187 2683 1939-S 1C US MS67RD (was ICG 68RD)
15 1 10489188 5791 1932-D 25C US Scratch/Rim Dent (was MS61 - looks 62/63 - missed the problem)
16 1 10489189 5792 1932-S 25C US MS62 (was NGC MS62 - thought it could go 63)

Latest Economy Submission - entered 8/25/06, grades posted today
01 1 10488970 4939 1923 10C US CleanedFB (Oops - thought 65/66FB)
02 1 10488971 4945 1924-D 10C US CleanedFB (Oops - thought 64FB)
03 1 10488972 5027 1940-S 10C US MS64FB (Gotta work on my mercs - I pegged it as 65/66FB)
04 1 10488973 85796 1934-D 25C Heavy Motto US MS62 (thought 63)
05 1 10488974 5798 1935-D 25C US MS64 (thought 63)
06 1 10488975 5790 1932 25C US Cleaned (toned - should have been an easy 65 - hmmm!)
07 1 10488976 5799 1935-S 25C US MS64 (thought 63)
08 1 10488977 5802 1936-S 25C US MS65 (thought 64)
09 1 10488978 5803 1937 25C US MS65 (thought 65)
10 1 10488979 5805 1937-S 25C US MS63 (thought 63)
11 1 10488980 5806 1938 25C US MS65 (thought 64, shot 65)
12 1 10488981 5807 1938-S 25C US MS65 (thought 64, shot 65)
13 1 10488982 5810 1939-S 25C US Damage or Tooling (thought 64/65 - missed something)
14 1 10488983 5812 1940-D 25C US MS64 (thought 63)
15 1 10488984 5858 1955 25C US MS65 (thought 65/66 - nice rainbow toning)
16 1 10488985 5229 1954 10C US PR67 (incredible toning - no brainer 66CAM - DDR)
17 1 10488986 5986 1954 25C US PR67 (thought 66 possible CAM)
18 1 10488987 6695 1954 50C US PR66 (thought 66 possible CAM)
19 1 10488988 6704 1963 50C US PR63 (unusual toning - submitted just to see if it would grade - PR65 expected)
20 1 10488989 96703 1962 50C US PR68DC (thought 66/67 DCAM - cha ching! - $15 proof set)

Collectors Club free submission - Entered 8/24/06, shipped 9/13/06
1 1 08506157 5801 1936-D 25C US MS64 (thought 63, possible 64 - cha ching!)
2 1 08506158 5975 1936 25C US PR63 (I obviously need to work on my proof grading - expected 65)
3 1 08506159 5976 1937 25C US PR63 (expected 64)
4 1 08506160 5977 1938 25C US PR64 (expected 64)
5 1 08506161 5978 1939 25C US PR63 (expected 65, shot 66)
6 1 08506162 5979 1940 25C US PR63 (expected 65)
7 1 08506163 5980 1941 25C US PR63 (expected 65)
8 1 08506164 5981 1942 25C US PR63 (expected 66)

This one made my day at the Denver ANA - show graded
1 1 06397112 4907 1916-D 10C US XF45FB (cha ching!)


Over all, I am mostly pleased, but I have a few areas to work on.

Jeff

BlindedByEgo

Can't let this one pass - all in all, nice going! I just got 32-D and 32-S back both MS62 from PCGS - they're not giving grades away right now. The S I'm OK with but the D was a sure 63 - it's going across the street.

Nice job!

pontiacinf

great job there Jeff

tychojoe

Very interesting. I like how you guys share info and results here. If you have a few areas to work on, then I have WHOLE BOOKS to work on! I plan on starting with Photograde as soon as I can get a copy, and working up from there.

Really though, congrats, especially since a grade improvement can be a big step increase, and the PCGS's seem to be becoming more the coin of the realm.

WaterSport

That is an impressive bunch of Lincolns regardless of whose plastic they are in.

WS

drwstr123

<< <i>That is an impressive bunch of Lincolns regardless of whose plastic they are in.

WS >>


What he said, me too!

bushmaster8

Nice results on the whole!

BTW- I did not realize PCGS would give FB on circulated coins. I thought all the strike designations were for MS only. Is this something new, or has it always been that way?

seanq

<< <i>Nice results on the whole!

BTW- I did not realize PCGS would give FB on circulated coins. I thought all the strike designations were for MS only. Is this something new, or has it always been that way? >>



The designation will not be on the insert. If you write the FB coin number on the submission form, the results will post with the FB on the end of the grade even if it is circulated or bodybagged. I did that recently with a Jefferson nickel submission, one came back AU58 but the grades posted online as "AU58FS".


Sean Reynolds

JustMakesCents

Thanks for the comments, everyone. TTT for the daytime crew.

Jeff

LincolnsRule

Nice job Jeff. Some really nice Lincolns are in there.