Who the heck will win the NL Cy Young 2006

gosteelers

Chris Carpenter? Brad Penny? Brandon Webb? John Smoltz?

Not a very strong class this year...

Writer11

How about Billy Wagner or Jason Schmidt?

You're right ... Tough choice this year.

bri2327

May as well just give it to Clemens. I heard he has room for one more on his shelf and wont retire till he gets it.

A761506

I'd give it to Webb as of now, but it definitely is a pretty weak crowd to choose from.

I'd say Carlos Zambrano makes the next best case - he has been about the only positive thing about the Cubs this season.

Now, the AL award - that's going to be interesting because there are 4 legitimate candidates (Halladay, Verlander, Santana & Papelbon - although he's fading fast with 3 blown saves in his last 5 chances).

Writer11

<< <i>I'd give it to Webb as of now, but it definitely is a pretty weak crowd to choose from.

I'd say Carlos Zambrano makes the next best case - he has been about the only positive thing about the Cubs this season.

Now, the AL award - that's going to be interesting because there are 4 legitimate candidates (Halladay, Verlander, Santana & Papelbon - although he's fading fast with 3 blown saves in his last 5 chances). >>



I thought about Zambrano after. Yeah, I think he should get it as of his stats today.

frankhardy

I think the NL award has yet to be won. Someone will seperate himselft from the pack in the last month.

Cubby

Ryan Dempster

onlyanumber

Don't rule out Josn Johnson of Florida

Barndog

Hoffman if the Padres make it to the playoffs?

stown

Wandy Rodriguez

KOBEcollector

Hoffman if the Padres make it to the playoffs?

I wouldn't give it to Hoffman just for the fact that he blew the All-Star game and now the American League gets home field in the W.S

Dave

yawie99

I would've said Carpenter before this afternoon. It's wide open, that's for sure.