Home› Trading Cards & Memorabilia Forum

Does this seem incongruous to you guys...?

sando69sando69 Posts: 276
in Trading Cards & Memorabilia Forum
ebay auction closed tonite for a 1933 Sport Kings Babe Ruth PSA 8 (pop 22, 2 higher)... selling price- $20,500.

memory lane auction that closed fri morn offered same card, PSA 7 (pop 24, 24 higher)... selling price- $ 7395...

that same auction also offered 1933 Goudey #53 Babe Ruth PSA 7 (pop 19, 17 higher)... selling price- $15,200.

memory lane auction also had 1933 Goudey #144 Babe Ruth PSA 7 (pop 39, 36 higher)... selling price- $9842.

does the Sport King PSA 7 seem comparatively undervalued... and if so, why?



image

Comments

  • ColleSystemColleSystem Posts: 512 ✭✭
    I am not that familiar with all of the details of that Sport Kings card (although I'd love to have one). The $13,000 price difference definately would be magnified if last nights 8 was weak and the Memory lane 7 was strong.

    -Scott
    My sets:
    1977 Topps Star Wars - "Space Swashbucklers"
  • storm888storm888 Posts: 11,701 ✭✭✭
    I suspect one could only speculate their way to a
    true and worthwhile compare and contrast answer.

    The question does not exactly ask us to compare apples and
    oranges, but it almost does.

    As we all know, there are, or can be, a thousand different reasons
    why one card or another sells at a given price. The
    unknown circumstances that surround the motivations
    of buyers like you have cited make a definitive answer
    almost impossible to reach except by chance/luck.

    All that rattled off, my answer is "no;" the SK card may
    be "undervalued," but the dollar difs between the
    comparison cards does not prove that.

    Also, SK card buyers tend to be pretty broad in sports
    enthusiasm; much more so than the average Goudey
    guy. Put another way, except for the name "Ruth"
    appearing on all of the cards, the connection between
    the two-pairs is rather remote in the minds of many
    high-end collectors.

    Many SK buyers appreciate the idea of building the set.
    That can influence buying/pricing decisions a bunch. OTOH, many
    bb purists are not keen on accepting that the SK-set cards are
    really even "very close to being baseball cards."

    SK prices can often get propped up when poor folks with extra
    money get the fever. The SK cards have a much greater connection
    to the working class than do the other Goudeys, and the
    SK cards are just not looked at with ultra-lust like the comparison
    Ruth cards are by rich folks. In other words, rarity absent the
    desire of the rich-crowd to possess leads to lower demand
    and lower prices.

    Thus, the auction outcomes outlined, by themselves, DO NOT
    mean that the SK 7 is "comparatively undervalued." It is more likely
    "comparatively under demanded and lusted for." (Community
    demand often/always over-rides "rarity factors" in almost all
    collectibles.)

    I am not saying the SKs are overpriced, I am just saying that price
    is an element of how many folks who want them can afford them.
    Big money guys, with plenty of exceptions, view the other Ruth
    cards as more of a treasure not withstanding their comparative
    abundance.

    But, I ain't no expert on nothin', and I might be all wrong.

    storm image
    Folks Who Bite Get Bitten. Folks Who Don't Bite Get Eaten.
  • lawnmowermanlawnmowerman Posts: 19,477 ✭✭✭✭


    << <i>Does this seem incongruous to you guys...? >>



    I might be able to answer you if I knew what that word meant.

    Please speak slow and no big words, you have to remember ME cut grass image

    matt

    1994 Pro Line Live

    TheDallasCowboyBackfieldProject

  • sando69sando69 Posts: 276
    matt-
    it means that the house & senate can rarely agree on anything...
    as evidenced by storm's eloquent & insightful analysis! image

    storm-
    thanks for the comments.
    i guess that also explains why the same $20,000 that buys a 1933 ruth psa 8 can only command a psa
    5 or sgc 70 1952 topps mantle! imageimageimage
    it is truly all a factor of demand i suppose!
  • kingraider75kingraider75 Posts: 1,500 ✭✭
    more people have access to Ebay than Memory Lane auctions. I like Memory Lane, Mastro, and all the like, but I think Ebay still reaches more people. Does that mean $13k difference????? Maybe so, maybe not.
    Running an Ebay store sure takes a lot more time than a person would think!
  • MajorDanbyMajorDanby Posts: 1,343
    hmmm, not sure if the difference between ebay and memory lane is the main culprit. I suspect prices in big name auctions like memory lane to rake in more dough.

    the difference is likely caused by the fact that besides his rookie and second year cards, ruth's most known and collected cards are his 33 goudeys. it's really his only mainstream card. and we all know the lore of the goudey set and its place in the hobby. sports king cards are popular, but pale in comparison to the goudey set or other more reknowned sets (compare the prices for a sports king ty cobb to say a T206 or any caramel issue).
    My Auctions

  • Stone193Stone193 Posts: 24,438 ✭✭✭✭✭
    image

    I like the SK Ruth card.

    I'm with Storm - in that the SK set is a mixed sport set - this could wind up making it less desirable than the Goudeys - less demand equals lower price.

    And if so, and one wants a sweet card that may cost less? I'ld hit it!

    mike
    Mike
  • sando69sando69 Posts: 276
    hey mike-
    i'd like to borrow that card... would you mind sending it to me?

    now have fairly decent comparative images of the difference between $7395 and $20,500...
    is someone willing to post them for me.
    thanks for your help! imageimage
  • themetalsignthemetalsign Posts: 555 ✭✭
    Matt,
    Me cut grass too !!!!!! Slowly getting out of it though. 14 years is long enough.....

    Dave
    Vintagecardshop
Sign In or Register to comment.