Proof vs circulation on a 1957 half penny

Tonedbuff

How does one differentiate between the proof and standard strike on these? This one is deeply toned, and has incredible appeal, with a luster and a killer strike that makes me think proof. Any pro's out there?

ajaan

Here is an example of a 1958 VIP issue (Proof).

7Jaguars

Yes, ajaan has sent a nice picture and would say if you look at details such as the queen's hair and the flag's cross detail on the revers that you will see clear differences. So not a proof but enjoy the coins you find attractive.

Tonedbuff

Thanks for the comparison. I bought this just for the color, for about $4. No complaints, just a fun piece.
Cheers,
Richard

spinaker2000

Hey, any excuse for Don to whip out a '58 1/2d proof is a good thread!!