Home Trading Cards & Memorabilia Forum

A buyers market

Since I have gotten back into collectibles. I have done my purchasing through e-bay. I have also gone to card shows. It seems that both of these places are 'sellers market' with the high prices of buying tables at card shows and with the high shipping/seller fees on E-bay, it seems like there has to be a more effective less costly way of buying collectibles.

Many people sell their cards to advertisers in beckett or SMR and most of these companies give these people 20-30% of the value for their cards. It seems like every collector is getting ripped off. Honestly, many young people look in the basement of their grandparents apartment and find these cards which are virtually junk to them. They are willing to sell them for any price they can, and the companies intercept them before the true interested buyers can make these people a fair offer. Has anybody found a way or does anybody have an idea on how to beat these Giants (other than to pitch around Barry?)
-Ryan

Comments

  • Well, there are a few schools of thought here. On one hand you complain about these heavy hitter dealers and say that they buy all the good stuff before Average Joe knows about the opportunity. Well, this is how these guys make a living. If it mean't putting food on the table, I am sure you would figure out a way to get these great deals. Does it suck? Sure does, but thats how it goes sometimes. There is however, something good that does come out of all this. If you are looking for a 52 Mantle or something of that nature, you know its gonna be legit. It may cost an arm and a leg, but if you want the card bad enough, you will pay for it.

    Interseting side note; I wonder if there are many people who can speculate with baseball cards as well as Warren Buffet (all cards, not just modern).
  • On the speculation note, I know that many people try to do it (myself included) and im certain many are successful. People get knocked for looking at cards as an investment, but if you are smart about what and WHEN you purchase cards, profits can be made. The market is very cyclical. Buying liquid star rookie cards in november-january is usually a winning proposition. Fees and shipping do eat a big chunk of gross profits however.
  • There are a lot of collections out there. I am an estate planning attorney in Palm Beach. In my field, we deal with assisting the family in the administration of estates. I have come across several substantial collections that the heirs were looking to sell. However, I am prohibited from purchasing them. I have a few national dealers/auction houses that I use to purchase/sell the collections. Most of the time, the family wants fast money. I would recommend that you introduce yourself to various estate planning attorneys, family law attorneys and asset managers in your city. Let them know that you would like an opportunity to purchase any collections that their clients are looking to sell. You may be suprised at the results.

    David
  • Stone193Stone193 Posts: 24,437 ✭✭✭✭✭


    << <i>People get knocked for looking at cards as an investment >>


    bs

    I think sometimes there a rush to judgement on the investment thing.

    But in the case of what I think you're talking about - short term flipping is different than what many ask.

    They are looking at long term performance akin to a mutual fund. In that case, the outlook may be different.

    The problem with flipping IMO? Ya gotta stay on top of the stuff like a hawk...which is kinda like having another job? Not as much fun and just collecting cause you like what you see.

    There's a lot of reward for guys who know what they're doing and stay on top of it.

    I wish anyone luck who has the fortitude.

    In fact, I enjoy hearing about those kind of transactions.
    mike
    Mike
  • Stone193Stone193 Posts: 24,437 ✭✭✭✭✭


    << <i>I would recommend that you introduce yourself to various estate planning attorneys, family law attorneys and asset managers in your city. Let them know that you would like an opportunity to purchase any collections that their clients are looking to sell. You may be suprised at the results. >>


    Very interesting David.

    Good advice - nice way to pick up other stuff also I would guess...like furniture?

    thanx
    mike
    Mike
  • Mike

    In addition to collectibles, you can add cars, boats, furniture, real estate, etc. I keep lists of individuals that want to be presented with an option to buy certain items. For example, there is one individual who buys every house that the heirs want to sell in a particular city. The heirs win by avoiding the brokers' commission. I have two people that want the opportunity to buy cars (one is looking for 1960s corvettes and the other is looking for any cars). There are many opportunites out there.

    David
  • It can be fun, I did it quite a bit in college. There are plenty of arbitrage opportunities between thepit.com, naxcom, and ebay. Now that I have a real job I hardly do it at all, but it can be done. Making 10%-15% over a 4-5 month period between november and april is very achievable. To give you an example:

    On thepit you can often purchase high-grade baseball rookie cards in large quantity right after the world series as people get interested in football. A perfect example of this is Manny Ramirez's 1992 Bowman BGS 9.5 rookie card. I would guess that between 50-75 of those cards were sold between december and february on thepit for an average of $40-$42 a card. This is a card that generally sells for $50-$70 during the season (higher amounts are usually in april). I bought about 25 of them, and sold them on ebay in march and early april in lots of 2 for an average of $55-65 a card.

    The most important thing i think is having a good reputation on ebay. if you have a near-perfect feedback score and send your items right away, you can get often premiums for your cards over the average ebay selling price. Good customer service is always good business.

    I will say that buying and holding modern cards for more than a year is generally a losing proposition, just because supply increases every year. Buying hot young prospects is also pretty dangerous too. But if you stick to buying established stars in the off-season, then selling in march-april, you have a pretty good chance of making a bit of money.
  • for what it's worth, i hear you can also attend self storage auctions where they regularly auction off the contents of unpaid storage units, blindly.. well they open the door like 2 feet and you can crouch and look in beforehand, but that's all.. i've heard of people scoring major goodies that way and making a bundle... it's a gamble but you can definitely come up with some things to sell on ebay that way... you would have to get very lucky to get any cards that way, but stranger things have happened.
  • smallstockssmallstocks Posts: 1,644 ✭✭✭✭
    Montana - I saw that very same article in the paper the other day.

    Late 60's and early to mid 70's non-sports
  • 9 times out of 10 the stuff in storage container auctions are boxes of overproduced 1987-1995 junk. I used to be a buyers worst nightmare when someone came in with a bunch of cards in top loads to sell to dealers at shows. I would watch as the guy would thumb through them, go to his Beckett, add some numbers and than quote him a ridiculously low price. Without hesitation, I would top the guys offer by at least 100.00, getting a scowl from the dealer.......
  • larryallen73larryallen73 Posts: 6,067 ✭✭✭
    I am an estate planning and probate attorney in Sacramento. I have not seen any huge collections but was presented with one last year by the household sales company I sometimes hire to clean out and sell stuff after the person dies. She wanted price guide value. There is just so much information out there that people know cards have value. I tried to explain that Ebay is real world value, etc... but she wouldn't hear it so I didn't buy. Point is, these auction/estate sales people may be good sources of card collections. I know my lady has a short list of train collectors, plate collectors, etc... that she invites to each sale she conducts. Packman- I am really not sure of the "law" on the point but I have bought cars in probates before. I make sure I am paying fair market value and I disclose in the final petition. I have bought 4 cars in probates or trust administrations I believe. They tend to be cheap ones. I have also taken a car to reduce my fees. The family tends to want to sell stuff and as long as the price is fair (beit for cars or cards) everybody is happy. To be extra careful, if it was a high dollar item, the attorney could send notice of proposed action to all heirs and explain the conflict!?
  • I have made alot of money on storage units, but not on finding cards. My biggest haul was a bunch of old books and some old camera equipment .
  • I just read in the latest Stuff magazine about a guy who bought a storage locker and it turned out to belong to Paris Hilton. It was filled with her pictures, boxes of medical and legal papers, 18 diaries and a bunch of video tapes. He is now offering to sell it back to her.
Sign In or Register to comment.