If you feel like the seller was deceptive........I do, he put an uncirculated coin in a US Mint Proof box..........then I'd blast him with a negative or at least a neutral.
I bought some vacuum tubes once. One brand, Telefunken, has a diamond marking in the glass making it easily identifiable. The telefunkens command a premium price. I bought two "diamond bottom" tubes from a guy once and only one was diamond bottom. I left him a neutral and he claimed I was blind in his response to my neutral.
Surprisingly he left me a good feedback.
If I were buying from you and saw a negative that I could tell was just a retaliation I wouldn't think twice about it. Seeing someone with a gazillion feedbacks at 100% does bother me though. How in the world can you make everyone happy? There's no way.
Personally, I think the feedback system on eBay is broken. If I win an auction and pay, I deserve a good feedback right away. I've done my part. Having buyers hold their feedback so they can retaliate is a bunch o' crap.
I dont really see anything deceptive about the auction, I have had people send me morgans in the same proof box that is shown in that photo. The auction clearly states "uncirculated" and even the box says the same thing so I think he did his part with describing the auction. Before I would leave negative feedback i just wouldn't leave feedback at all as Russ said
<< <i>Almost word for word, Check his feedback on the link. >>
Gee, I'm honored. But Coindexter is right, it was bit harsh. I was just being sarcastic. You're not really an idiot, that kind of stuff has happened to the best of us.
<< <i>If I win an auction and pay, I deserve a good feedback right away. >>
I agree the feedback system has its flaws and it has the potential to be abused by both parties on either side of a transaction. But I disagree that payment constitutes an immediate positive feedback. Payments are not guaranteed, checks bounce, PayPal payments can be charged back based on invalid complaints and so forth.
A seller who gives an automatic positive can actually be setting himself up for problems in that there is little recourse to tell others that the buyers transaction or honesty was less than perfect.
Feedback should only be used when the transaction is actually completed. Expectations that feedback is deserved immediately after payment is no different from giving the seller a positive because he informed you the package is in the mail. You have no idea what the product actually is (as is mentioned in this thread), the seller has no idea if the payment is good or the transaction will actually be completed honestly. Sadly feedback extortion works both ways and therein lies one of the feedback faults.
What I usually find interesting is when a seller or buyer receives a negative for whatever reason, the retaliatory feedback they leave often shows true colors.
Comments
Russ, NCNE
I'd leave a positive saying
Your confusing auction allowed you to sell me a $10 SAE and a $30 box
My posts viewed
since 8/1/6
I bought some vacuum tubes once. One brand, Telefunken, has a diamond marking in the glass making it easily identifiable. The telefunkens command a premium price. I bought two "diamond bottom" tubes from a guy once and only one was diamond bottom. I left him a neutral and he claimed I was blind in his response to my neutral.
Surprisingly he left me a good feedback.
If I were buying from you and saw a negative that I could tell was just a retaliation I wouldn't think twice about it. Seeing someone with a gazillion feedbacks at 100% does bother me though. How in the world can you make everyone happy? There's no way.
Personally, I think the feedback system on eBay is broken. If I win an auction and pay, I deserve a good feedback right away. I've done my part. Having buyers hold their feedback so they can retaliate is a bunch o' crap.
John
Never view my other linked pages. They aren't coin related.
I'm an idiot and I need to pay more attention to what I'm buying
Ask me no questions, I'll tell you no lies.
Keeper of the VAM Catalog • Professional Coin Imaging • Prime Number Set • World Coins in Early America • British Trade Dollars • Variety Attribution
<< <i>Almost word for word, Check his feedback on the link. >>
Gee, I'm honored.
Ask me no questions, I'll tell you no lies.
More and more these days I find myself pondering how to reconcile my net income with my gross habits." - John Nelson.
<< <i>If I win an auction and pay, I deserve a good feedback right away. >>
I agree the feedback system has its flaws and it has the potential to be abused by both parties on either side of a transaction. But I disagree that payment constitutes an immediate positive feedback. Payments are not guaranteed, checks bounce, PayPal payments can be charged back based on invalid complaints and so forth.
A seller who gives an automatic positive can actually be setting himself up for problems in that there is little recourse to tell others that the buyers transaction or honesty was less than perfect.
Feedback should only be used when the transaction is actually completed. Expectations that feedback is deserved immediately after payment is no different from giving the seller a positive because he informed you the package is in the mail. You have no idea what the product actually is (as is mentioned in this thread), the seller has no idea if the payment is good or the transaction will actually be completed honestly. Sadly feedback extortion works both ways and therein lies one of the feedback faults.
What I usually find interesting is when a seller or buyer receives a negative for whatever reason, the retaliatory feedback they leave often shows true colors.