What would this 72 grade?

zef204

And more importantly, is it within the centering limt for an 8 if the grader thinks its an 8?

A761506

Technically, the centering is there for an 8, but even with the rough cut, I think you'd be looking at a 7 at best because of the bottom corners combined with the centering.

brianwintersfan

I would say 7

lostdart58

Centering would pass for an 8 barely...............I do not think I have ever seen a rough cut on three sides like that..............That card being one of the toughest in the set would be worth submitting..an 8 is a $60-$100 card.

Stone193

Hi Zef

I have been collecting the 63F set for 2 yrs and I've seen many, many 8s with centering like that.

But I do have concern about the lower right border - it looks like too much of the white is missing to have the cornering of an 8?

I think it's close tho - and heck - a slider 8? What does the corner look like under the loupe?

mike

zef204

The bottom right corner will be the trigger if it doesn't get an 8. Its dinged. But all 3 other corners are very square. The bottom left may look bad becaus the bottom edge is rough, but there the corner itself is not touched.

I picked up about 400 72's about 5 years ago that are all pretty solid. I just got about 20 of them graded and got all 8's and 9's. I have never been into this set and I see there is stiff competition out there so I don't think its one I am going to venture into. I'll stick with my fb cards

zef204

I hate issues I don't know the ins and outs. If the McRae is within an 8 for centering, I am guessing this one is too, right?

smallstocks

I have a Rose just like that McRae and it was graded a 6. Then again, thesame card could get an 8 the next time.

lostdart58

The Dietz IA is another low pop card worth submitting ...... ( This 72 set collector needs it in an 8 or better.....)