Complete Bechtler Dollar Set Grading Challenge

Regulated

Here is a complete set of Bechtler Gold Dollars by die variety. The second (28-Grain High - a real tough coin) and third (28-Grain Centered) pieces are the stoppers. What do you grade them?

K.1 - C Bechtler 30-Grain with Star



K.2 - C Bechtler 28-Grain High



K.3 - C Bechtler 28-Grain Centered



K.4 - C Bechtler N Reversed



K.24 - A Bechtler 27-Grain 21-Carat



Have fun!

tradedollarnut

Oh, my.

WAG's:

55,40,45,50,55

michael

58
50
45
55
53

mgoodm3

These are tough.

50
40
30
62
58

MacCrimmon

50
30
35
58
55

poorguy

58
45
55
63
60

PerryHall

Since they are two dimensional, you need to grade based on the remaining luster which is impossible without seeing the coins in hand.

Regulated

Good answer, Perry. BTW the lowest grade in the group is 58.