We all know I can't grade real coins, so HELP ME!!!

MadMarty

Any thoughts on the nickel? Also a couple of toners out of a 56 mint set.

Tootawl

I would grade the X as MS-70 RED.

MadMarty

<< <i>I would grade the X as MS-70 RED. >>



Something must be wrong with your computer than!

jonesy

The Liberty Nickel looks like a 65 to me. I can't tell on the 56 set coins.

Coindexter

The toning on those 56 coins is cool, but there's no way I could hazard a guess on their grade from an image.

I think 65 is probably right for the nickel.

ChangeInHistory

64 on the nickel
Can't tell on the toners, but I'll say 65/66's

fc

1st. AU to low MS.
2nd. UNC, low MS
3rd. AU that toned

hey marty, since you have the coins in hand, shouldn't you
help us out with your thoughts first?

i am beginning to feel like my guesses really suck.

kryptonitecomics

<< <i>The Liberty Nickel looks like a 65 to me. I can't tell on the 56 set coins. >>




I agree completely.....can't tell on the Mint set coins due to the nature of the crackled toning????

bhartman35

I'd agree with 65 on the nickel.

It's hard to tell with the mint set coins. I can see some nicks on the Frankie through all that haze, so I'd say probably 65 on that, as well. no clue on the quarter. Neither coin looks particularly well-struck, though. (All of this ignores the toning (i.e., eye appeal) completely. It might just be the image, but the coins look too encrusted to be marketable with "market grading".)

PhillyJoe

Nice nickel!

As far as the mint set, things from 1956 have a way of looking older than they really are.

Joe

rainbowroosie

AU 58
MS 66 FBL
MS 65

Stuart

Marty: I like the psychedelic looking purple colored felt that you are using as a background for the photos!

Tootawl

There they are! The first few times I tried to view this thread, I got red Xs.

jdimmick

Ms-62 on the 1910 nickel

jonesy

Where are the Liberty nic freaks??

LincolnCentMan

Low end 65 on the nickel. I bet you could send those bottom two in ten times and get at least three different grades on them. It's too hard to tell from images. I wouldnt be suprised anywhere from 64 to 66.

David