1964 Topps Giants..What would this grade?

Goodsport40

Found this and some others at my favorite shop. What do you guys think? More to come.


Robert

Goodsport40

Here is another. By the way, thanks to Hoofhearted and his great instructions on how to post photos.

I hope these scans are not too small for everyone. I'm new at picture posting. Thanks.

Robert

mikeschmidt

I would say 7 on Howard [based on t/b centering] and 8 on Kaline. These really don't seem to be worth grading at the time except at the 9 and above level. I can't tell the corner sharpness well enough from where I am - but you can eyeball that yourself.

~m

grilloj39

I would say PSA 8 grades are OK for likes of the Mantle card, Koufax, Mays, and a few other of the SPs...otherwise, a grade of 8 for the likes of killebrew, kaline, yaz, aaron, etc, really won't affect sell value.

larryallen73

Nice cards but probably not "worth" grading if you plan to re-sell. I don't think either will grade a 9.

Goodsport40

Thanks, guys. I agree that both are most likely solid 8's. Not really interested in selling even if I do get these and the others I bought graded. I just like them because they are very affordable for the most part. Thanks.

Robert

fiveniner

8s at best. but they are a nice set whem complete.

theo934

<< <i>Thanks, guys. I agree that both are most likely solid 8's. >>

did I miss it? who here said they were both 8s?

Goodsport40

Hi, Theo. I didn't mean to suggest that those who had posted an opinion thought they were 8's. This was meant to be a fun thread. Sorry for the confusion. Thanks.

Robert