Grades in here too... but I got shafted.

Coindexter

cert date
08500584 1921 S$1 Peace, High Relief USA AU55
08500585 1812 50C USA VF20
08500586 Oregon 50C 1928 USA MS64
08500587 1949 50C USA MS62FL


I'm looking for the picture to post it, but that Franklin was a lock 64 with a shot at a 65. I cannot even begin to comprehend how PCGS could justify a 62!

I am happy my Oregon made it into a holder, though.

LucyBop

the Oregon is great news....


I also called that Frankie a lock ms64fbl, with a shot 5 holder due to outstanding gem luster...

I am baffled at that grade....

heh...

I'll gladly give you ms62 money for it!

LucyBop

well..... my image does capture alot of hits on the Obverse... hmmm.... I remembered this one being cleaner in person.. the big hit in the left field probably really hurt the grade...

LucyBop

the bustie..

robertpr

Maybe a lotta hits but that frankie has gotta get some props for that fantasmic strike!

LucyBop

<< <i>Maybe a lotta hits but that frankie has gotta get some props for that fantasmic strike! >>




i think my image captures every single one... This coin looks much nicer in hand, it truely has strong luster as if it were minted just yesterday...
and the strike is strong but typical of a 49 Frankie...

Coxe

I agree, but think 63FBL would have been a better call. At least they did recognize the FBL, as the breaks were from the local hits not strike deficiency. I bet the coin looks really nice in hand.

Myqqy

The obverse die break on that 1812 half is awesome!!

Bruceswar

1928 Oregon is alot harder to find than people think. Nice looking ones that is. I have a 1928 PCGS MS66 (Rattler First Gen) And I would not part with that coin. I like the old holder. anyhow... loooks like some nice coins congrats

MadMarty

Consider yourself lucky! If I would have submitted it it would have come back AU58!!

MORGANHUNTER2

<<Consider yourself lucky! If I would have submitted it it would have come back AU58!!

-------------------------
It is not exactly cheating, I prefer to consider it creative problem solving!!!>>


I don't want to hear that!

mtnman

In today's climate, if you didn't get any BB's you've had a good day.

Coindexter

All things considered I guess you positive outlook folks are right. I though my Oregon was gonna get bagged for sure and it's coming back in a holder. I bought the Peace dollar as an XF and it's coming back as AU. The Franklin is surprising to me, but I guess I can't complain.