1959 Topps Sub Results
fiveniner
Posts: 4,111 ✭✭✭
Thanks to lostdart58 I am able to post my subs for the first time ever.Quite pleased with the results however The Buddin card is giving me heart burn. I have had the worst luck in trying to find a PSA 6 or better on this one.I am sure they are out there but I never see one.
I am really surprised by the Mc Clish as I thought it was one of the nicer cards I submitted.
1 31526379 1959 TOPPS 368 DON MUELLER N/A 7
2 31526380 1959 TOPPS 366 HUMBERTO ROBINSON N/A 8
3 31526381 1959 TOPPS 482 RUSS MEYER N/A 7
4 31526382 1959 TOPPS 495 JOHNNY PODRES N/A 6
5 31526383 1959 TOPPS 497 HAL R. SMITH N/A 7
6 31526384 1959 TOPPS 456 JERRY CASALE N/A 7
7 31526385 1959 TOPPS 374 ART DITMAR N/A 7
8 31526386 1959 TOPPS 332 RAY MONZANT N/A 8
9 31526387 1959 TOPPS 326 MARV THRONEBERRY N/A 8OC
10 31526388 1959 TOPPS 322 HARRY HANEBRINK WITH TRADE STATEMENT 8OC
11 31526389 1959 TOPPS 324 DON DEMETER N/A 7
12 31526390 1959 TOPPS 362 DOLAN NICHOLS WITH OPTION STATEMENT 7
13 31526391 1959 TOPPS 355 JIM PIERSALL N/A 7
14 31526392 1959 TOPPS 367 CAL NEEMAN N/A 8OC
15 31526393 1959 TOPPS 402 HECTOR LOPEZ N/A 7
16 31526394 1959 TOPPS 445 CAL McLISH N/A Not Holdered, Miscut
17 31526395 1959 TOPPS 459 BILL TUTTLE N/A 8
18 31526396 1959 TOPPS 458 GORDON JONES N/A 7
19 31526397 1959 TOPPS 476 INDIANS TEAM N/A 8
20 31526398 1959 TOPPS 483 CLINT COURTNEY N/A 8
21 31526399 1959 TOPPS 487 HAL BROWN N/A 7
22 31526400 1959 TOPPS 498 DICK HYDE N/A 7
23 31526401 1959 TOPPS 557 KEN BOYER ALL STAR 8
24 31526402 1959 TOPPS 542 JIM PERRY N/A 6
25 31526403 1959 TOPPS 371 DICK BRODOWSKI N/A 7
26 31526404 1959 TOPPS 4 ALBIE PEARSON N/A 7
27 31526405 1959 TOPPS 12 VERN LAW N/A 8OC
28 31526406 1959 TOPPS 17 DANNY'S ALL-STARS N/A 8OC
29 31526407 1959 TOPPS 32 DON BUDDIN N/A 5
30 31526408 1959 TOPPS 6 ALEX GRAMMAS N/A 8
31 31526409 1959 TOPPS 41 BOB MARTYN N/A 7
32 31526410 1959 TOPPS 37 GENE GREEN N/A 7
33 31526411 1959 TOPPS 21 CONNIE JOHNSON N/A 8
34 31526412 1959 TOPPS 73 RON JACKSON N/A 6
35 31526413 1959 TOPPS 84 RENO BERTOIA N/A 7
36 31526414 1959 TOPPS 86 BOB KEEGAN N/A 7
37 31526415 1959 TOPPS 98 ARNIE PORTOCARRERO N/A 7
38 31526416 1959 TOPPS 103 BILLY GOODMAN N/A 8
39 31526417 1959 TOPPS 112 BILLY CONSOLO N/A 8
40 31526418 1959 TOPPS 122 BENNIE DANIELS N/A 8
41 31526419 1959 TOPPS 167 DUKE MAAS N/A 7
42 31526420 1959 TOPPS 185 JIM BUSBY N/A 8
43 31526421 1959 TOPPS 187 BUBBA PHILLIPS N/A 7
44 31526422 1959 TOPPS 190 BILL VIRDON N/A 7
45 31526423 1959 TOPPS 198 JIM DAVENPORT N/A 7
46 31526424 1959 TOPPS 200 WARREN GILES N/A 6
47 31526425 1959 TOPPS 310 LUIS APARICIO N/A 7
48 31526426 1959 TOPPS 323 FRANK SULLIVAN N/A 7
49 31526427 1959 TOPPS 330 GUS TRIANDOS N/A 7
50 31526428 1959 TOPPS 513 TOM CARROLL N/A 7
I am really surprised by the Mc Clish as I thought it was one of the nicer cards I submitted.
1 31526379 1959 TOPPS 368 DON MUELLER N/A 7
2 31526380 1959 TOPPS 366 HUMBERTO ROBINSON N/A 8
3 31526381 1959 TOPPS 482 RUSS MEYER N/A 7
4 31526382 1959 TOPPS 495 JOHNNY PODRES N/A 6
5 31526383 1959 TOPPS 497 HAL R. SMITH N/A 7
6 31526384 1959 TOPPS 456 JERRY CASALE N/A 7
7 31526385 1959 TOPPS 374 ART DITMAR N/A 7
8 31526386 1959 TOPPS 332 RAY MONZANT N/A 8
9 31526387 1959 TOPPS 326 MARV THRONEBERRY N/A 8OC
10 31526388 1959 TOPPS 322 HARRY HANEBRINK WITH TRADE STATEMENT 8OC
11 31526389 1959 TOPPS 324 DON DEMETER N/A 7
12 31526390 1959 TOPPS 362 DOLAN NICHOLS WITH OPTION STATEMENT 7
13 31526391 1959 TOPPS 355 JIM PIERSALL N/A 7
14 31526392 1959 TOPPS 367 CAL NEEMAN N/A 8OC
15 31526393 1959 TOPPS 402 HECTOR LOPEZ N/A 7
16 31526394 1959 TOPPS 445 CAL McLISH N/A Not Holdered, Miscut
17 31526395 1959 TOPPS 459 BILL TUTTLE N/A 8
18 31526396 1959 TOPPS 458 GORDON JONES N/A 7
19 31526397 1959 TOPPS 476 INDIANS TEAM N/A 8
20 31526398 1959 TOPPS 483 CLINT COURTNEY N/A 8
21 31526399 1959 TOPPS 487 HAL BROWN N/A 7
22 31526400 1959 TOPPS 498 DICK HYDE N/A 7
23 31526401 1959 TOPPS 557 KEN BOYER ALL STAR 8
24 31526402 1959 TOPPS 542 JIM PERRY N/A 6
25 31526403 1959 TOPPS 371 DICK BRODOWSKI N/A 7
26 31526404 1959 TOPPS 4 ALBIE PEARSON N/A 7
27 31526405 1959 TOPPS 12 VERN LAW N/A 8OC
28 31526406 1959 TOPPS 17 DANNY'S ALL-STARS N/A 8OC
29 31526407 1959 TOPPS 32 DON BUDDIN N/A 5
30 31526408 1959 TOPPS 6 ALEX GRAMMAS N/A 8
31 31526409 1959 TOPPS 41 BOB MARTYN N/A 7
32 31526410 1959 TOPPS 37 GENE GREEN N/A 7
33 31526411 1959 TOPPS 21 CONNIE JOHNSON N/A 8
34 31526412 1959 TOPPS 73 RON JACKSON N/A 6
35 31526413 1959 TOPPS 84 RENO BERTOIA N/A 7
36 31526414 1959 TOPPS 86 BOB KEEGAN N/A 7
37 31526415 1959 TOPPS 98 ARNIE PORTOCARRERO N/A 7
38 31526416 1959 TOPPS 103 BILLY GOODMAN N/A 8
39 31526417 1959 TOPPS 112 BILLY CONSOLO N/A 8
40 31526418 1959 TOPPS 122 BENNIE DANIELS N/A 8
41 31526419 1959 TOPPS 167 DUKE MAAS N/A 7
42 31526420 1959 TOPPS 185 JIM BUSBY N/A 8
43 31526421 1959 TOPPS 187 BUBBA PHILLIPS N/A 7
44 31526422 1959 TOPPS 190 BILL VIRDON N/A 7
45 31526423 1959 TOPPS 198 JIM DAVENPORT N/A 7
46 31526424 1959 TOPPS 200 WARREN GILES N/A 6
47 31526425 1959 TOPPS 310 LUIS APARICIO N/A 7
48 31526426 1959 TOPPS 323 FRANK SULLIVAN N/A 7
49 31526427 1959 TOPPS 330 GUS TRIANDOS N/A 7
50 31526428 1959 TOPPS 513 TOM CARROLL N/A 7
Tony(AN ANGEL WATCHES OVER ME)
0
Comments
I have sent a few single 59's in and they were not holdered miscut also. Is this common for the year??? I remember one being a great looking Aaron I thought would be an 8. Odd it was cut just ever so slightly out of square, is that the problem with these getting labeled miscut??
1957 Topps 99% 7.40 GPA
Hank Aaron Basic PSA 7-8(75%)
Glad you figured out the copy and paste...
As it turns out I am also a collector of 59 Topps but in raw form....so i know the set well.
The Buddin card probably has an ever so slight hairline wrinkle which would give it an automatic PSA 5.....even if the rest of the card is perfect.
1955 Bowman Raw complete with 90% Ex-NR or better
Now seeking 1949 Eureka Sportstamps...NM condition
Working on '78 Autographed set now 99.9% complete -
Working on '89 Topps autoed set now complete
<< <i>Overall results look great.
I have sent a few single 59's in and they were not holdered miscut also. Is this common for the year??? I remember one being a great looking Aaron I thought would be an 8. Odd it was cut just ever so slightly out of square, is that the problem with these getting labeled miscut?? >>
Although I really looked the cards over real close I probably did not pay as much attention to the back as I should have but for sure I know that no other part of another card was showing.It may have well have been diamond cut beyond or below allowed regular demiensions which would have resulted in the miscut designation.However it really must have been just a bit.I really have to study it when I get it back.
I do not find this all that common with 59s in my experience with them however it does occur.
Great results from where I'm sitting!
Congratulations.
Can you provide a scan of the miscut card when you get them back?
I have purchased lots of cards from the late 50s many years ago and have everything from miscuts to scratches and minor corner wear that only can be seen with a loupe. It's amazing, what a dealer/seller called nmmt back around 1988, with a loupe, today, would at best be a 6.
Good luck on the set.
mike
<< <i>5-9er
Great results from where I'm sitting!
Congratulations.
Can you provide a scan of the miscut card when you get them back?
I have purchased lots of cards from the late 50s many years ago and have everything from miscuts to scratches and minor corner wear that only can be seen with a loupe. It's amazing, what a dealer/seller called nmmt back around 1988, with a loupe, today, would at best be a 6.
Good luck on the set.
mike >>
Will do Mike,thanks!
2005 Origins Old Judge Brown #/20 and Black 1/1s, 2000 Ultimate Victory Gold #/25
2004 UD Legends Bake McBride autos & parallels, and 1974 Topps #601 PSA 9
Rare Grady Sizemore parallels, printing plates, autographs
Nothing on ebay
Stay classy,
Ron
Buying Vintage, all sports.
Buying Woody Hayes, Les Horvath, Vic Janowicz, and Jesse Owens autographed items