Please give your opinion on this image. Old and new images for comparison.

Gator5220

A few days ago, I asked for opinions on my first toned image. I've been tweaking the settings, and I need your honest assessment. Which do you like better?

Here's the old image:

Here's the new image:

DickyBetz

The second is too dark. I like the first.

anablep

I like the second. The image is too sharp in the old picture.