Does anybody think this is worthy of a star designation?

Myqqy

I don't think this morgan is worthy.....

DickyBetz

No, I dont think it deserves it.

dlimb2

That looks like a sulfur job to me.

Russ

If the image is accurate, I'd have to go with no, it isn't worthy. Common date with common toning. If, however, it has mondo blazing retina searing luster that isn't showing in the image, then maybe it might be.

Russ, NCNE

Russ

<< <i>The star rating is not an exceptional toning indicator, but an indicator that the coin is high end for the grade. >>



This is incorrect. The rating is for eye appeal, not for high end for the grade.

Russ, NCNE

DickyBetz

I stand corrected.

JoshL

I would say no.

100proof1957

Bag toner 63 i ilke it !

relayer

ER

No

curly

I don't care what the holder says.....it's just an average grade of a very common morgan. That star doesn't do squat for that coin except drive up the price. Does anyone really think that coin would be a centerpiece of a group of Morgans?

raycyca

NO! The reverse looks pretty nice as far as luster, strike and lack of bagginess. As far as the front goes, the color is almost there, BUT, not quite. It needs to be more complete of a circle, OR, brighter in color. Star should mean WOW! The coloring on that coin leaves something to be desired. I think NGC missed the boat on that one. Ray

kryptonitecomics

Not a star to me....but certainly NT.

JoshL

<< <i> I think NGC missed the boat on that one. Ray >>



They didn't even hit the water

raycyca

If you want to see the sister of this coin, look at E-bay # 8387479698. It looks like lady Liberty is getting speared in the head! I DON'T care for it at all! How many boats can NGC miss? Maybe they need another silver dollar grader that knows what a real star coin should look like? When they first came out, there were MANY more deserving coins getting the designation. Now with coins like this, the star designation gets cheapened. Pretty soon any coin with color will get a star? Ray

OHC6

Star for eye appeal? Its got good luster, but its not very eye appealing to me.

Colorfulcoins

Its a S T R E T C H to say the least.

Myqqy

Star should mean WOW!

That's always been my interpretation. If I look at a morgan, and the first involuntary thought is "wow" or "HOLY S**T!"- then that should get a star.....

UncleWiggly

<< <i>

<< <i> I think NGC missed the boat on that one. Ray >>



They didn't even hit the water >>



Your avatar sure looks like it rates a NGC star.



Jerry

mozin

NGC blew it.

seateddime

I say...........................no

Trime

Not even a consideration