PSA Review Question
KyleBicking
Posts: 147
Quick question for all of you who have sent in a card to PSA for review.
I recently had a 1920s strip card graded as Authentic. No more than 2 weeks ago, a similar card, in nearly identical shape and size (in fact, mine is ever so slightly larger), but in in my opinion worse condition graded out as a PSA 5.
Has anyone ever had luck providing a scan of a previously graded card along with their disputed graded card to PSA and been successful?
Thanks in advance.
-Kyle-
I recently had a 1920s strip card graded as Authentic. No more than 2 weeks ago, a similar card, in nearly identical shape and size (in fact, mine is ever so slightly larger), but in in my opinion worse condition graded out as a PSA 5.
Has anyone ever had luck providing a scan of a previously graded card along with their disputed graded card to PSA and been successful?
Thanks in advance.
-Kyle-
0
Comments
didn't larry bring that card to PSA already?
not sure what to tell ya.
i have a card that i need to send in too.
Steve
Nope different card this time... cooler one in my opinion. 1925 W590 Robert T. Jones Jr. Rookie, or Pre-Rookie... its a sweet item.
The Larry situation is interesting because as it turns out, Joe Orlando stood behind the grade 100% and refused to offer money for it. I do have my card, and in the end, thats all that matters.
If I find anything out, I'll let you know. Email me at kylebicking@yahoo.com if you want me to contact you directly.
-Kyle-
the ruth card was graded 'authentic" if I am not mistaken and that is why PSA stood behind it. had they gave it a numerical grade then perhaps then they would have done something.
jmo
Steve
good luck
The Ruth was graded an 8. Larry thought it was too small, investigated, was proven wrong and then with everything that happened, I asked for it back rather than go through worrying about it anymore. Atleast its over and Larry was very apologetic over the whole situation.
-Kyle-