No one is more passionate than SCcoins about Franklins. Like he said, collectors of the same series help themselves by helping others, rather than feeling like they are competing.
I've sold off several 67 coins, and passed on buying many other 67s in favor of the 66 toners I have, and so they'd probably be lost in the Registry shuffle. I think what I am going to do is take some pics of my #1 toners and post them on Dog's analysis of the Franklins series, and we can all get the benefit of the Pug's insight.
LincolnMan's thread has been hijacked a bit. Unfortunately we may have scared some away with all the talk about AT Franklins. To respond to his question, the Franklin is not unlike any other series, both toned and white can be stunners, and both can have their problems, as other series do. The Martin collection of white Franklins in the FUN ANR auction was the best collection of whites I have ever seen. PQ white coins can be harder to find than toned, and right now are more expensive as a whole. If I were starting the series now, I would put together a toned set, irrespective of FBL. These are the best bargain coins and could bring the most enjoyment.
Some refer to overgraded slabs as Coffins. I like to think of them as Happy Coins.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------That 57 is such a MONSTER A+++ toner MS67 FBL, I'd guess we're talking a car trade, not money, to get that HEPcat Baby!!!
Since this thread is already hi-jacked, let me ask if any of you guys looked at the set of 8 coins in the heritage auction, and remember what they looked like in person.
<< <i>Since this thread is already hi-jacked, let me ask if any of you guys looked at the set of 8 coins in the heritage auction, and remember what they looked like in person.
I viewed Heritage. This lot is from the inventory of a dealer who has a good eye for Franklins. Sounds like you bought this lot? I think you'll find the coins very solid citizens for the grade but no real lookers.
Some refer to overgraded slabs as Coffins. I like to think of them as Happy Coins.
<< <i>I want a super nice set with higher grade coins rather than fbl coins. I can afford to stretch to a few thousand $ on some dates but can't afford the $5000 rare 66fbl dates. So here's the main thing... should I stick to untoned? All toned? Is a mix okay? Would a white 62-p look dumb next to a spectacular toned 62-d? I really like the overall look of a matched set. Is finding all dates nicely toned an impossibility? Is finding some dates in super high grade all white an impossibity?
Thanks Franklin Experts! And everyone else! >>
This may have already been stated but if you are going to put them in an album they will become toned eventually.
Yes I bought the lot, a few are upgrades for my set. I didn't think any were crack/out upgrade candidates, but thought the group went rather low. . I was high internet bidder and so it made me nervous that no one in person thought it was a good price.
But as long as they are solid for the grade I''ll be happy
A witty saying proves nothing- Voltaire (1694 - 1778)
An error does not become truth by reason of multiplied propagation, nor
does the truth become error because nobody will see it. -Mohandas K. Gandhi (1869-1948)
Ok all you Frankie fanantics out there, let me ask your opinion on some Franikes I have.
#1 - I have a 1959P MS (non FBL) white Frankie which appears to be proof like (reflective/mirrorlike fields) and which has a strongly defined, sharp eagle on the reverse (it looks like the eagles on a Type 2, 1956 Proof), is this coin special and what would it be worth in say MS63-64 condition;
#2 - I picked up an original 1951 proof set a few years ago in a five coin rectangular holder with two clear plastic sheets that cover the front and back of the coin holes (like a Dansco Album). The Frankie was completely toned on both sides with wild purple and yellow color. It is also a CAM proof. I agonized over the coin and finally decided to dip it to remove the toning so that I could place the blast white CAM proof into a Capital holder with 13 other CAM/DCAM proofs. Looking back on it, I wish that I had not dipped the coin because the toning was simply wild. Did I make a mistake (I think I did)?; and what would a 1951 CAM Proof (IMHO it would grade PF63 or 64 CAM) with this wild toning be worth?;
#3 - I have a 1956 Mint set, One of the 1956P Frankies is fully toned on both sides. IMHO the grade of the coin would be MS64-65. The obverse of the coin when first viewed is toned dark with a grey/brown look. However after looking more closely at the coin one sees that it is actually toned with a mixture of colors, including brown, grey, yellow, blue, green, violet and orange. Under good lighting the obverse shimmers with a mixture of rainbow colors and has nice luster. At first glance the reverse is more eye appealing that the obverse primarily since it is more lightly toned. The reverse toning is primarily auburn in color, with splashes of violet, blue and green present on some of the lettering and on parts of the bell. Looking through a loupe reveals that the auburn portion of the toning is not completely uniform across the coin. There is a mottled pattern with very, very small faint white interruptions in the auburn toning that. My guess is that the faint white areas are the remaining portions of the surface of the coin that has not yet toned over. The overall appearance of the reverse is very pleasing and when viewed under good lighting it also shimmers with the auburn color and has very nice luster. Though it has taken me a while to warm up to the dark obverse on this coin, it is one of my favorite Frankies. What do you think this coin would be worth?
The second 1956P Frankie in the set is toned. IMHO it would grade MS64 and possibly FBL by PCGS (though there are some small marks on the upper lines which would probalby preclude the FBL designation). The obverse toning is interesting. The bust of Franklinis primarily white and it appears to float above the surrounding fields and perimeter devices (which are toned to a great degree). The bust of Franklin, when viewed throgh a loupe does in not completely white. There is splotchy toning of blue, violet and dark orange on parts of the bust, but white areas predominate. The fields and perimeter devices are more heavily toned, though some white splotchy areas exist (primarily adjacent to the edge of the bust running from the 6:00 to 10:00 o'clock positions on the coin. The remaining non bust area of the obverse are toned a mixture of blue and purple (the 10:00 to 6:00 o'clock positions on the coin primarily along the perimeter of the coin) and violet and orange (not along the perimeter of the coin but instead to the right of Ben's bust from 2:00 to 4:30 o'clock extending outward to where it merges with the blue and purple perimeter toning; with the date being toned violet and orange). The reverse of this coin has lighter toning, with some darker areas along the lower half of the perimeter (grey and violet); with the lower part of the bell and the areas adjacent to the botton and sides of the bell being toned a very light and even orange and violet; and with the top of the bell, the wood beam to which the bell is attached and top perimeter of the bell (from the S in states to the A in america) being a shimmery silver muted by small areas of light orange. What do you think this coins value would be?
Unfortunately I can not post pics of these coins at this time, thus my verbal description of them.
SanctionII, I've seen a lot of 59s as you describe. Look real close and you will probably see die polishing. I have one in PCGS-65. The die polish does not really detract, and the coin is very clean. It does give the coin a somewhat uncommon look. I've never heard of a premium for them. Although some market makers have tried. Here is a lousy picture of mine:
Today's mighty oak is just yesterday's nut that held its ground.
Me like MadMonk's 1959! I bet its a ty 2. Cant wait to see the new pic coming soon!
SanctionII- I think if ours was high grade like the one MM shows us, it would carry a nice premium. But even a lower mint state grade should be worth a premium- how much depends on finding the right buyer.
Franklin Fanatics are really not all that common.
"Wars are really ugly! They're dirty and they're cold. I don't want nobody to shoot me in the foxhole." Mary
<< <i>Me like MadMonk's 1959! I bet its a ty 2. Cant wait to see the new pic coming soon!
SanctionII- I think if ours was high grade like the one MM shows us, it would carry a nice premium. But even a lower mint state grade should be worth a premium- how much depends on finding the right buyer.
Franklin Fanatics are really not all that common.
>>
O.k. Don't rub it in, I,m saving up for a decent camera
Today's mighty oak is just yesterday's nut that held its ground.
Comments
"Senorita HepKitty"
"I want a real cool Kitty from Hepcat City, to stay in step with me" - Bill Carter
Coin's for sale/trade.
Tom Pilitowski
US Rare Coin Investments
800-624-1870
because Franklin Half dollars are widely collected, they are extremly popular
Because many of the baby boomers held them in their hands as child-
ren and those same people now sometimes earn millions of dollars and
put tremendous demand on the spectaculer pieces; causing prices to rise
into the 10,000$ plus range. Bringing up the values of all Franklins
Because the registered sets preak curiousity and draw new collectors to the series
who's ego's and self esteem could rise along with their standings in the PCGS registry
Because someone who has collected Franklins with a passion unparalled for some twenty
odd years , spending a significent portion of his life and his resources and tens
upon tens of thousands of dollars in the process ; has amassed a collection
which is the zenith of his series .
Because once registered and photographed, he would gain world-wide recognition
for his efforts and his dreams.
Because hundreds if not thousands of seasoned and novice die hard Franklin buffs
alike could oggle over visions of many of the most fantasticly toned coins
known to humanity
And all of us could aspire to equal or better him in the brutaly competitive field
Of collecting the single most greatest coin ever minted on this earth
I've sold off several 67 coins, and passed on buying many other 67s in favor of the 66 toners I have, and so they'd probably be lost in the Registry shuffle. I think what I am going to do is take some pics of my #1 toners and post them on Dog's analysis of the Franklins series, and we can all get the benefit of the Pug's insight.
LincolnMan's thread has been hijacked a bit. Unfortunately we may have scared some away with all the talk about AT Franklins. To respond to his question, the Franklin is not unlike any other series, both toned and white can be stunners, and both can have their problems, as other series do. The Martin collection of white Franklins in the FUN ANR auction was the best collection of whites I have ever seen. PQ white coins can be harder to find than toned, and right now are more expensive as a whole. If I were starting the series now, I would put together a toned set, irrespective of FBL. These are the best bargain coins and could bring the most enjoyment.
<< <i>....I for one will be really looking forward to your visual treats Rony ! >>
Mee too!
<< <i> PQ white coins can be harder to find than toned...
... irrespective of FBL. These are the best bargain coins . >>
Damn straight!
(Ronyahaski, you do know Pug is no longer with us , right? He passed last year)
and they're cold.
I don't want nobody to shoot me in the foxhole."
Mary
Best Franklin Website
just because you got a top notch whitey set don't mean they are harder to find then
monster color pieces................
White is so bland, unexciting , and monotinus ................... any body can find white -
(albeit , pure white flawless is a rare bird too )
but you got to know somebody , be in the right spot at the right time, and outbid a
plethera of other's to get the wildly colored hi-grade Franklin ....dangit
<< <i>
<< <i> PQ white coins can be harder to find than toned...
... irrespective of FBL. These are the best bargain coins . >>
Damn straight!
(Ronyahaski, you do know Pug is no longer with us , right? He passed last year) >>
I know. Just want to keep the Pug and his thoughts TTT.
<< <i>
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------That 57 is such a MONSTER A+++ toner MS67 FBL, I'd guess we're talking a car trade, not money, to get that HEPcat Baby!!!
<< <i>...
but you got to know somebody , be in the right spot at the right time, and outbid a
plethera of other's to get the wildly colored hi-grade Franklin ....dangit >>
'xactly. That's one reason the whites are a bargain.
And for all but a handful of dates (1948P,D, 1953-S,1954-S, 59-63), there are dozens and dozens of
toned Gems for every one that is brilliant white. Although only a small percentage of those toners are
the wildly colored jobs so many desire. Don't misunderstand, I appreciate beautifully toned coins just
as much as you do. I have some ga-ga toner Franklins too! I only suggest that white Franklins are a
better value.
and they're cold.
I don't want nobody to shoot me in the foxhole."
Mary
Best Franklin Website
let me ask if any of you guys looked at the set of 8 coins in the heritage auction, and remember what they looked like in person.
Link to Heritage FUN lot
A witty saying proves nothing- Voltaire (1694 - 1778)
An error does not become truth by reason of multiplied propagation, nor
does the truth become error because nobody will see it. -Mohandas K. Gandhi (1869-1948)
<< <i>there are dozens and dozens of >>
<< <i>toned Gems for every one that is brilliant white. >>
Especially the 1953 and 1949. These were by far the toughest dates for me to find white, in gem, for my set.
John
My icon IS my coin. It is a gem 1949 FBL Franklin.
and yes , white - undipped
hi-grade , PCGS coins are undervalued on paper ;
but when one appears at auction , i believe they bring VERY strong prices.
so undervalued would be relitive to what the dingydong wop bobbah luhaaah
replying to see if it bumps it out.
I have seen this before- where someone replies, and you can't see it for hours.
edit- it worked!
So I should be pleased when those coins arrive?
A witty saying proves nothing- Voltaire (1694 - 1778)
An error does not become truth by reason of multiplied propagation, nor
does the truth become error because nobody will see it. -Mohandas K. Gandhi (1869-1948)
<< <i>Since this thread is already hi-jacked,
let me ask if any of you guys looked at the set of 8 coins in the heritage auction, and remember what they looked like in person.
Link to Heritage FUN lot >>
I viewed Heritage. This lot is from the inventory of a dealer who has a good eye for Franklins. Sounds like you bought this lot? I think you'll find the coins very solid citizens for the grade but no real lookers.
<< <i>I want a super nice set with higher grade coins rather than fbl coins. I can afford to stretch to a few thousand $ on some dates but can't afford the $5000 rare 66fbl dates. So here's the main thing... should I stick to untoned? All toned? Is a mix okay? Would a white 62-p look dumb next to a spectacular toned 62-d? I really like the overall look of a matched set. Is finding all dates nicely toned an impossibility? Is finding some dates in super high grade all white an impossibity?
Thanks Franklin Experts! And everyone else! >>
This may have already been stated but if you are going to put them in an album they will become toned eventually.
I didn't think any were crack/out upgrade candidates, but thought the group went rather low. .
I was high internet bidder and so it made me nervous that no one in person thought it was a good price.
But as long as they are solid for the grade I''ll be happy
A witty saying proves nothing- Voltaire (1694 - 1778)
An error does not become truth by reason of multiplied propagation, nor
does the truth become error because nobody will see it. -Mohandas K. Gandhi (1869-1948)
<< <i>
<< <i>there are dozens and dozens of >>
<< <i>toned Gems for every one that is brilliant white. >>
Especially the 1953 and 1949. These were by far the toughest dates for me to find white, in gem, for my set.
John >>
Here's a nice white 53:
and another one in technicolor:
$250- $850. Usually it is the bell lines that determine the price on this issue. There are, unfortunately, lots of PCGS FBL coins out there that
have very iffy bell lines. It is the few specimens with hammered bells that bring the bigbux.
I also like the look of the 53D in yer lot.
and they're cold.
I don't want nobody to shoot me in the foxhole."
Mary
Best Franklin Website
#1 - I have a 1959P MS (non FBL) white Frankie which appears to be proof like (reflective/mirrorlike fields) and which has a strongly defined, sharp eagle on the reverse (it looks like the eagles on a Type 2, 1956 Proof), is this coin special and what would it be worth in say MS63-64 condition;
#2 - I picked up an original 1951 proof set a few years ago in a five coin rectangular holder with two clear plastic sheets that cover the front and back of the coin holes (like a Dansco Album). The Frankie was completely toned on both sides with wild purple and yellow color. It is also a CAM proof. I agonized over the coin and finally decided to dip it to remove the toning so that I could place the blast white CAM proof into a Capital holder with 13 other CAM/DCAM proofs. Looking back on it, I wish that I had not dipped the coin because the toning was simply wild. Did I make a mistake (I think I did)?; and what would a 1951 CAM Proof (IMHO it would grade PF63 or 64 CAM) with this wild toning be worth?;
#3 - I have a 1956 Mint set, One of the 1956P Frankies is fully toned on both sides. IMHO the grade of the coin would be MS64-65. The obverse of the coin when first viewed is toned dark with a grey/brown look. However after looking more closely at the coin one sees that it is actually toned with a mixture of colors, including brown, grey, yellow, blue, green, violet and orange. Under good lighting the obverse shimmers with a mixture of rainbow colors and has nice luster. At first glance the reverse is more eye appealing that the obverse primarily since it is more lightly toned. The reverse toning is primarily auburn in color, with splashes of violet, blue and green present on some of the lettering and on parts of the bell. Looking through a loupe reveals that the auburn portion of the toning is not completely uniform across the coin. There is a mottled pattern with very, very small faint white interruptions in the auburn toning that. My guess is that the faint white areas are the remaining portions of the surface of the coin that has not yet toned over. The overall appearance of the reverse is very pleasing and when viewed under good lighting it also shimmers with the auburn color and has very nice luster. Though it has taken me a while to warm up to the dark obverse on this coin, it is one of my favorite Frankies. What do you think this coin would be worth?
The second 1956P Frankie in the set is toned. IMHO it would grade MS64 and possibly FBL by PCGS (though there are some small marks on the upper lines which would probalby preclude the FBL designation). The obverse toning is interesting. The bust of Franklinis primarily white and it appears to float above the surrounding fields and perimeter devices (which are toned to a great degree). The bust of Franklin, when viewed throgh a loupe does in not completely white. There is splotchy toning of blue, violet and dark orange on parts of the bust, but white areas predominate. The fields and perimeter devices are more heavily toned, though some white splotchy areas exist (primarily adjacent to the edge of the bust running from the 6:00 to 10:00 o'clock positions on the coin. The remaining non bust area of the obverse are toned a mixture of blue and purple (the 10:00 to 6:00 o'clock positions on the coin primarily along the perimeter of the coin) and violet and orange (not along the perimeter of the coin but instead to the right of Ben's bust from 2:00 to 4:30 o'clock extending outward to where it merges with the blue and purple perimeter toning; with the date being toned violet and orange). The reverse of this coin has lighter toning, with some darker areas along the lower half of the perimeter (grey and violet); with the lower part of the bell and the areas adjacent to the botton and sides of the bell being toned a very light and even orange and violet; and with the top of the bell, the wood beam to which the bell is attached and top perimeter of the bell (from the S in states to the A in america) being a shimmery silver muted by small areas of light orange. What do you think this coins value would be?
Unfortunately I can not post pics of these coins at this time, thus my verbal description of them.
What do you think of these coins, as described?
but youv'e basicly described some lower grade commen coins; the prooflike one sounds intresting though .
you get an A+ for effort and time spent describing them......that's for sure !!
I've seen a lot of 59s as you describe. Look real close and you will probably see die polishing. I have one in PCGS-65.
The die polish does not really detract, and the coin is very clean. It does give the coin a somewhat uncommon look.
I've never heard of a premium for them. Although some market makers have tried.
Here is a lousy picture of mine:
Capped Bust Half Series
Capped Bust Half Dime Series
SanctionII- I think if ours was high grade like the one MM shows us, it would carry a nice premium.
But even a lower mint state grade should be worth a premium- how much depends on finding the right buyer.
Franklin Fanatics are really not all that common.
and they're cold.
I don't want nobody to shoot me in the foxhole."
Mary
Best Franklin Website
And leading the way , blazing the trail , carring the torch
for the beacon of hope ...........
will ALWAYS will be a follower of Ben Franklin ; the Grandfather of America
Godfather to this U.S of A
you need to look in a mirror to see a Franklin Fanatic
<< <i>Me like MadMonk's 1959! I bet its a ty 2. Cant wait to see the new pic coming soon!
SanctionII- I think if ours was high grade like the one MM shows us, it would carry a nice premium.
But even a lower mint state grade should be worth a premium- how much depends on finding the right buyer.
Franklin Fanatics are really not all that common.
O.k. Don't rub it in, I,m saving up for a decent camera
In true Rick Tomasuk form, it is now offered in R&I's retail price list for a mere $2800. Any dealer is entitled
to make a fair profit, but a 121% markup seems excessive!
edit to correct %
and they're cold.
I don't want nobody to shoot me in the foxhole."
Mary
Best Franklin Website
Tomaska is a free spirit, - he's trying to make
300 to 500 % profit ! more power to him
A witty saying proves nothing- Voltaire (1694 - 1778)
An error does not become truth by reason of multiplied propagation, nor
does the truth become error because nobody will see it. -Mohandas K. Gandhi (1869-1948)
You might wonder why a dealer like Tomaska wouldn't be offered or given a chance to buy such
top notch stuff ??
( or offered 20% of retail)
A witty saying proves nothing- Voltaire (1694 - 1778)
An error does not become truth by reason of multiplied propagation, nor
does the truth become error because nobody will see it. -Mohandas K. Gandhi (1869-1948)
hint: ( they are beautiful arn't they!~ )
and they're cold.
I don't want nobody to shoot me in the foxhole."
Mary
Best Franklin Website
at that same time I saw one in hand at local show ..............
one coin can't be in two places at one time .
PCGS has never graded a white Franklin MS67.
Therefore, anyone playing the Registry game that limits themselves to white coins can never rise to the top.
and they're cold.
I don't want nobody to shoot me in the foxhole."
Mary
Best Franklin Website