Should this card have been O/C?

julen23

Does this fall w/in psa 8 criteria?

Seems pretty close to O/C to me.

psa 8 or psa 8 o/c?

Julen

Stingray

Were is the pixel counter?


Stingray

ROCKDJRW

Maybe it would have been a 10?

stevek

Yes, looks OC from the scan, but scans do tend to make small borders appear even smaller. But no question it's a low end 8 because of the centering.

BigRedMachine

<< <i>Maybe it would have been a 10?
>>



Is that how this works if you send in a card and request "no qualifier"????
It's knocked down two grades??

If that's the case, I don't care for that at all. The card pictured is not very appealing to the eye
if you're concerned about centering. I don't need a pixel counter to tell me if it's within the limits
or not. Buy the card, not the holder I guess.

Stingray

<< <i>

<< <i>Maybe it would have been a 10?
>>



Is that how this works if you send in a card and request "no qualifier"????
It's knocked down two grades??

If that's the case, I don't care for that at all. The card pictured is not very appealing to the eye
if you're concerned about centering. I don't need a pixel counter to tell me if it's within the limits
or not. Buy the card, not the holder I guess. >>



Good point, I was wondering too, if it has perfect corners, and just the centering is off, it becomes an 8. If everything is perfect on a card, except centering, and you did not ask to have no qualifiers listed, would it automatically be a PSA 9OC?? Never have seen a PSA 10OC??

Stingray

envoy98

There is no qualifiers on a 10 card.

Looks about 75/25 to me. Which is actually in line with NM 7 centering standards. So my guess is this was requested NQ and probably is in line with a PSA 10 otherwise. If it were a 9 otherwise I would have expected a 7 overall grade NQ.

For my money, there are plenty of high grade examples of 69 Topps baseball so I'd pass on it, but a great looking card other than that centering.

FYS

<< <i>Does this fall w/in psa 8 criteria?

Seems pretty close to O/C to me.

psa 8 or psa 8 o/c?

Julen >>



The holder has been compromised or the label has been swaped or the card has been swapped or the centering does in fact fall in line with PSA 8 standards. In any case, PSA did not make an error. Lets make that clear.

larryallen73

9oc?

As has been said before the knockdown of two grades for a qualifier is not automatic.

With all that said, I would not buy it.

Eddo33

I was going thru a old SMR and saw an ad for WIWAG. I believe I saw them selling a PSA 8 1969 Aaron.

Never know!!!

This mag was 4 years old in PSA defense.

Ed

Kurtman9

jruler pixel counter says it's 66/34 left/right and 65/35 top/bottom.

rbdjr1

Same seller! Look at the three sharp corners of this PSA 10! SELLER'S "HOLIDAY SCAN"

edit: (Well centered? LOL!)


rbd