Guess the grade of this Matty....

BigtimeBowmanfan

I need some thoughts on resubmitting this sporting life. Under a 16X loupe there are no crease's or wrinkles apparent.

MuckyMutt

I think it's a 1. You better just send it to me and I'll discard it for you.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Great looking card - really! Why would you not submit it?

yawie99

It looks great, so I'm assuming you got killed on the grade. I'll say a 2.

BigtimeBowmanfan

No , actually i bought it as a 3. But it doesn't make sense. Could they be that far off ?

tkd7

Any paper loss on the back? Even the smallest bit drops the grade tremendously.

BigtimeBowmanfan

Not a bit. This really puzzles me. Could it just be a mistake ? I mean even for the light dirt on the right edge of the back this still looks to be at least a 6.

WinPitcher

Scott

Look at the card close. does it have a wrinkle that was flattened out? if so PSA deducts 2 and some times 3 grades.........




Steve

BigtimeBowmanfan

Hey Steve,

No it just looks great. I for the life of me cannot figure this out. I guess i will have to crack and resubmit. Maybe something will show when it's out of it's coffin, But i doubt it.

Is the line in the top right on your Robbie the issue ?