WOW! Incredible luster on my new PEACE dollar. I need some expert grade opinions.

Crazy4Coins

Just received this. The pics do not show the true luster..... I have been drooling over it since it came. I think the coin is under graded.
It also appears to have the same die crack as the VAM 2, just an earlier die state. I think I can see just a bit of doubling on the "E" in ONE.

She is definitely going in for crossover... Just can't decide whether to crack her out or not..

Help me decide please.....

1927-D

dizzyfoxx

Quite reflective luster... I like it!
Edited to add: If you like the coin itself, the number on the slab is irrelevant.

Peaceman

If she's in a 3 holder.... CRACK!!!! Denver mint coins usually come VERY clean... this one does show a little chatter... My guess is that it's in a 4 holder..... yes?

USAROK

<< <i>... My guess is that it's in a 4 holder..... yes? >>

ER

63, not expert.

zkcoins

I would guess 63 for the marks and such....but with the luster...have to go 64

Rollerman

I'd say 64 on that one, though not a Peace $ expert. Seems to me that coin is nicely struck and with good luster as you noted, just a little too much chatter for a 65.
Pete

NumisOxide

Looks like a 64.

Baley

That is a very very nice coin for the date! MS63.5!

TUMUSS

That strike and luster may get it in a 65....Good luck!

BuffaloIronTail

I agree with the "Chatter", but there are no serious problems with this coin and it exhibits, to me, acceptable Cartwheel luster for a branch mint coin, and a full strike.

I'd give it a 65.

Pete

19Lyds

Great Luster but still a 64 tops. Looks like a lot of little hits here and there but definitely a nice looking Peace!

DickyBetz

Nice coin! Looks MS-64 to me!

Inditonka

I would have to say its in a 63 holder. If you want it in a 64, you've got to crack it and cross your fingers!

LastExitInNY

I don't know much about the Peace dollars as of yet, but to me, every one is a beauty. With some coins, there is just something about them that does it for me. The Peace is one of those and would love to own one someday. Pretty coin.

cape

looks like a nice 64

Mercury

I like the coin and will have to say 64, love the luster. But, please tell what is the actual grade and are you going to crack it out or not?

goldisgood

nice 64

TwoSides2aCoin

It is beautiful, really. The luster, eye appeal, and detail is all there. Very few bag marks, and they are only slight.
I normally would go along with the 64, but I have a feeling it is MS65. It really does look like it has great cartwheel effect, too.

I would NOT crack it out, and I would be tempted to pay for PRESIDENTIAL REVIEW to have THE EXPERT take a look, I really think Mr Hall ought to see it, especially NOW that PCGS is grading the VAM's

I like the coin and please do not drool on the slab


oops, you said CROSSOVER.... so it's not in a PCGS slab...nevermind the presidential review then