August Collectors Club Result

JimThorpe

1978 TOPPS 288 DAVE HAMILTON N/A 8
1978 TOPPS 6 NOLAN RYAN RECORD BREAKER 8
1986 JENO'S PIZZA 46 TERRY BRADSHAW N/A 9
1986 JENO'S PIZZA 12 WALTER PAYTON N/A 9
1986 JENO'S PIZZA 12 WALTER PAYTON N/A 9
1986 JENO'S PIZZA 45 FRAN TARKENTON JACK LAMBERT 9
1986 JENO'S PIZZA 28 ROGER CRAIG N/A Not Holdered, Evidence of Trimming
1986 JENO'S PIZZA 28 ROGER CRAIG N/A Not Holdered, Evidence of Trimming
1986 JENO'S PIZZA 34 DAN MARINO N/A 9
1986 JENO'S PIZZA 53 DAN FOUTS N/A 9
1982 HALL OF FAME BOB LILLY METALLIC 10
1989 SCORE 78 ROD WOODSON N/A 9
1987 TOPPS STICKERS RANDY WHITE #36 OZZIE NEWSOME #186 9
1987 TOPPS STICKERS DOUG FLUTIE #10 MAX MONTOYA #159 9
1987 TOPPS STICKERS DOUG FLUTIE #10 MAX MONTOYA #159 10
1987 TOPPS STICKERS DANNY WHITE #34 KEVIN MACK #184 8
1987 TOPPS STICKERS DAN MARINO #138 ROHN STARK #152 9
1987 TOPPS STICKERS 174 JOHN ELWAY N/A 10
1987 TOPPS STICKERS 174 JOHN ELWAY N/A 9
1987 TOPPS STICKERS 14 WALTER PAYTON N/A 10
1987 TOPPS STICKERS 220 DAN MARINO N/A 9
1995 SPORTS ILLUSTRATED 349 MICHAEL JORDAN FOR KIDS-SERIES 2 9
1995 SPORTS ILLUSTRATED 351 DAN MARINO FOR KIDS-SERIES 2 9
1992 TOPPS 733 JIM KELLY GOLD 10
1982 HALL OF FAME ERNIE BANKS METALLIC PLAQUE CARDS 10

Date Received: 09/01/2005
Date of Grades Posted: 10/13/2005
Date Shipped: No Date Specified

ArnyVee

I'd be interested in the Marino cards if you have them for sale.

jayhawke

I am not familiar with jeno's pizza, but who would trim one?

JimThorpe

That is exactly how the Roger Craig card came from Jeno's. I have had about 20 of them and they are all just a tad shorter than the other cards. It must have had to do with where they were positioned on the sheet or how the cards were trimmed at the factory. It appears as if by PSA guidelines, this card can't be graded, unless it slips by a grader that day. By the way, this set is very hard to get 10s on because it was a redemption set from Jeno's and the sets were shipped in a manila envelope with a rubber band around the cards. The cards on the top and bottom of the stack are always ruined (at least not worthy of a 9 or 10).

studentT206

I know Jeno at Jeno's pizza. He told me the pizza cutter always slipped on the sheet when cutting the Roger Craigs and regrets that PSA won't grade them to this day. Really this is just ridiculous. If just a few folks are putting together a Jeno's registered set, the Craig in any holder will command bucks. I think you should be at least compensated for fees in the form of vouchers. The card may not meet size requirements but trimmed? Geez, put Jeno's mind at ease.

Damian

phreakydancin

Maybe resubmit the Craigs without other Jeno's cards to compare them to?