My 5 Day Submission Results (More GAI XOvers)
envoy98
Posts: 4,000 ✭✭
Hmm. Just got my grades from my last submission. There were a few GAI crossovers here. About 50/50 on these.
1 1955 TOPPS 210 DUKE SNIDER N/A 4 (GAI 4.5)
2 1956 TOPPS 30 JACKIE ROBINSON N/A 2 (GAI 3.5)
7 1967 TOPPS 581 METS ROOKIES B.DENEHY/T.SEAVER 4 (GAI 3)
8 1968 TOPPS 247 REDS ROOKIES J.BENCH/R.TOMPKINS 6 (GAI 6.5)
I'm not too surprised. I didn't scan these first as I had already cracked them out before the "experiment".
The 55 Snider has a water stain on the top corner so I expected it not to go up. The Robinson is kind of a piece of crap, but I like the card anyway, I am surprised by the 1.5 grade drop however. The Seaver is nice that it got bumped and the Bench is a high-end 6, but not a 7. I was hoping for a nice grader and maybe have that one move into a 7 holder, but that's alright.
Here's the rest of what I had graded. (Cert #'s removed to protect the innocent...er my registry
(Lots of junk vintage I had)
1 1955 TOPPS 210 DUKE SNIDER N/A 4 (if not for the water stain, this might have been a 5 or a 6, still a great card IMO)
2 1956 TOPPS 30 JACKIE ROBINSON N/A 2 (lots of problems with this one, but the color and centering are decent enough, it's seen some humidity tho)
3 1957 TOPPS 302 SANDY KOUFAX N/A 7 (This is so close to an 8, I'll probably crack and resubmit)
4 1959 TOPPS 350 ERNIE BANKS N/A 5 (Nicely centered, soft corners, I just liked the card and I got it for $4)
5 1964 TOPPS 125 PETE ROSE ALL-STAR ROOKIE 3 (This baffles me, I had another that looked just as good that was a 6)
6 1966 TOPPS 100 SANDY KOUFAX N/A 4 (Was hoping for a 5 or 6...there aren't any creases, just soft corners)
7 1967 TOPPS 581 METS ROOKIES B.DENEHY/T.SEAVER 4 (Very soft, a 4 is a good grade)
8 1968 TOPPS 247 REDS ROOKIES J.BENCH/R.TOMPKINS 6 (Was hoping for the 7 bump, but that's alright)
9 1969 TOPPS 100 JOE NAMATH N/A 5 (This one baffles me too, thought it was a 7 or an 8, guess I really missed something)
10 2004 PLAYOFF CONTENDER 106 BEN ROETHLISBERGER AUTOGRAPH 9 (This is good, thought it might be an 8 or 9 so I'm happy)
11 1969 TOPPS 120 LARRY CSONKA N/A 6 (Thought both of these would make 7's)
11 120 LARRY CSONKA N/A 5
I should've saved my money on some of these but I have a guy that will pay very close to SMR in any condition so some of these will get moved asap.
Date Received: 08/24/2005
Date of Grades Posted: 08/30/2005
Date Shipped: No Date Specified
1 1955 TOPPS 210 DUKE SNIDER N/A 4 (GAI 4.5)
2 1956 TOPPS 30 JACKIE ROBINSON N/A 2 (GAI 3.5)
7 1967 TOPPS 581 METS ROOKIES B.DENEHY/T.SEAVER 4 (GAI 3)
8 1968 TOPPS 247 REDS ROOKIES J.BENCH/R.TOMPKINS 6 (GAI 6.5)
I'm not too surprised. I didn't scan these first as I had already cracked them out before the "experiment".
The 55 Snider has a water stain on the top corner so I expected it not to go up. The Robinson is kind of a piece of crap, but I like the card anyway, I am surprised by the 1.5 grade drop however. The Seaver is nice that it got bumped and the Bench is a high-end 6, but not a 7. I was hoping for a nice grader and maybe have that one move into a 7 holder, but that's alright.
Here's the rest of what I had graded. (Cert #'s removed to protect the innocent...er my registry
(Lots of junk vintage I had)1 1955 TOPPS 210 DUKE SNIDER N/A 4 (if not for the water stain, this might have been a 5 or a 6, still a great card IMO)
2 1956 TOPPS 30 JACKIE ROBINSON N/A 2 (lots of problems with this one, but the color and centering are decent enough, it's seen some humidity tho)
3 1957 TOPPS 302 SANDY KOUFAX N/A 7 (This is so close to an 8, I'll probably crack and resubmit)
4 1959 TOPPS 350 ERNIE BANKS N/A 5 (Nicely centered, soft corners, I just liked the card and I got it for $4)
5 1964 TOPPS 125 PETE ROSE ALL-STAR ROOKIE 3 (This baffles me, I had another that looked just as good that was a 6)
6 1966 TOPPS 100 SANDY KOUFAX N/A 4 (Was hoping for a 5 or 6...there aren't any creases, just soft corners)
7 1967 TOPPS 581 METS ROOKIES B.DENEHY/T.SEAVER 4 (Very soft, a 4 is a good grade)
8 1968 TOPPS 247 REDS ROOKIES J.BENCH/R.TOMPKINS 6 (Was hoping for the 7 bump, but that's alright)
9 1969 TOPPS 100 JOE NAMATH N/A 5 (This one baffles me too, thought it was a 7 or an 8, guess I really missed something)
10 2004 PLAYOFF CONTENDER 106 BEN ROETHLISBERGER AUTOGRAPH 9 (This is good, thought it might be an 8 or 9 so I'm happy)
11 1969 TOPPS 120 LARRY CSONKA N/A 6 (Thought both of these would make 7's)
11 120 LARRY CSONKA N/A 5
I should've saved my money on some of these but I have a guy that will pay very close to SMR in any condition so some of these will get moved asap.
Date Received: 08/24/2005
Date of Grades Posted: 08/30/2005
Date Shipped: No Date Specified
0