SF (Ebay) closing prices! UPDATED 12-20! Check out the differences...

p8nt

I was wondering where the pricing on these will go (I already have an idea but needed some evidence to support it) so last night I searched and averaged out all of the prices for every 2005 SF coin in MS68 and MS69. You can use this as a guide for buying or selling or whatever. Maybe check it out to see if the grading prices would be worth it for a borderline coin or something. I dont really care. I just thought it might be useful to someone.


First regular text = 7/18/2005
First bold text = 7/24/2005
Second regular text = 8/2/2005
Second bold text = 8/10/2005
Third regular text = 12/20/2005

SAC-D MS68
$204.89 (6 Auctions)
Pop 160
$125. (5 Auctions)
Pop 160
$91.36 (9 Auctions)
Pop 229
$63.29 (16 Auctions)
Pop 333
$38.35 (4 Auctions)
Pop 465

SAC-P MS68
$56.34 (11 Auctions)
Pop 257
$46.64 (4 Auctions)
Pop 257
$34.08 (17 Auctions)
Pop 427
$19.69 (20 Auctions)
Pop 564
$20.60 (17 Auctions)
Pop 1169

SAC-D MS69
$725. (1 Auction)
Pop 7
$849.99 (1 Auction)
Pop 7
$499.95 (1 Auction)
Pop 24
$499.95 (1 Auction)
Pop 24
No Auctions Found
Pop 26

SAC-P MS69
$152.42 (13 Auctions)
Pop 72
$115.49 (2 Auctions)
Pop 72
$105.44 (6 Auctions)
Pop 138
$116.87 (6 Auctions)
Pop 141
$100.50 (2 Auctions)
Pop 198

50c-D MS68
$157.5 (1 Auctions)
Pop 19
No Auctions Found
Pop 19
$88.22 (1 Auctions)
Pop 116
$111.13 (3 Auctions)
Pop 33
$35.33 (3 Auctions)
Pop 148

50c-P MS68
$23.14 (13 Auctions)
Pop 287
$15.68 (3 Auctions)
Pop 287
$17.63 (9 Auctions)
Pop 499
$17.11 (12 Auctions)
Pop 591
$13.66 (5 Auctions)
Pop 223

50c-D MS69
No Auctions Found
Pop 0
No Auctions Found
Pop 0
No Auctions Found
Pop 0
No Auctions Found
Pop 0
No Auctions Found
Pop 0

50c-P MS69
$85.45 (8 Auctions)
Pop 97
$56.62 (3 Auctions)
Pop 97
$46.63 (7 Auctions)
Pop 187
$50.16 (17 Auctions)
Pop 190
$51.25 (2 Auctions)
Pop 218

CA-D MS68
$21.98 (3 Auctions)
Pop 286
$19.59 (4 Auctions)
Pop 286
$15.65 (11 Auctions)
Pop 325
$12.65 (11 Auctions)
Pop 533
$20.05
Pop 693

CA-P MS68
$21.96 (7 Auctions)
Pop 436
$16.28 (4 Auctions)
Pop 436
$13.92 (16 Auctions) (1st coin to not be worth minimum slabbing fees)
Pop 502
$16.37 (17 Auctions)
Pop 548
$13.67 (4 Auctions)
Pop 974

CA-D MS69
$306. (1 Auctions)
Pop 23
$255.02 (1 Auction)
Pop 23
$232.49 (2 Auctions)
Pop 25
$222.62 (2 Auctions)
Pop 25
No Auctions Found
Pop 35

CA-P MS69
$97.93 (8 Auctions)
Pop 80
$73.48 (2 Auctions)
Pop 80
$62.49 (6 Auctions)
Pop 107
$45.84 (12 Auctions)
Pop 107
$59.99 (1 Auction)
Pop 151

MN-D MS68
$25.64 (6 Auctions)
Pop 120
$19.30 (4 Auctions)
Pop 120
$12.79 (11 Auctions)
Pop 168
$12.94 (12 Auctions)
Pop 386
$12.99 (1 Auction)
Pop 610

MN-P MS68
$19.75 (2 Auctions)
Pop 223
$16.18 (4 Auctions)
Pop 223
$12.26 (11 Auctions)
Pop 301
$10.46 (11 Auctions)
Pop 302
$9.76 (1 Auction)
Pop 812

MN-D MS69
$258.75 (2 Auctions)
Pop 16
$242.50 (1 Auction)
Pop 16
$203.77 (3 Auctions)
Pop 28
$190.25 (3 Auctions)
Pop 30
$150.59 (1 Auction)
Pop 45

MN-P MS69
$103.32 (6 Auctions)
Pop 60
$89.52 (2 Auctions)
Pop 60
$51.88 (7 Auctions)
Pop 94
$48.14 (12 Auctions)
Pop 99
$25.49 (1 Auction)
Pop 146

OR-D MS68
$20.21 (8 Auctions)
Pop 381
$19.15 (3 Auctions)
Pop 381
$13.40 (10 Auctions)
Pop 460
$13.02 (14 Auctions)
Pop 679
$10.92 (2 Auctions)
Pop 881

OR-P MS68
$24.47 (6 Auctions)
Pop 314
$18 (1 Auction)
Pop 314
$11.86 (18 Auctions)
Pop 645
$9.68 (4 Auctions)
Pop 932

OR-D MS69
$126.09 (5 Auctions)
Pop 36
No Auctions Found
Pop 36
$81.95 (6 Auctions)
Pop 48
$72.21 (4 Auctions)
Pop 48
$99.99 (1 Auction)
Pop 71

OR-P MS69
$99.16 (12 Auctions)
Pop 125
$50.50 (2 Auctions)
Pop 125
$45.77 (6 Auctions)
Pop 166
$38.43 (12 Auctions)
Pop 169
$32.49 (1 Auction)
Pop 231

KS-D MS68
$29.86 (4 Auctions)
Pop 192
$24.28 (2 Auctions)
Pop 192
$21.77 (10 Auctions)
Pop 224
$18.59 (10 Auctions)
Pop 224
$14.88 (3 Auctions)
Pop 559

KS-P MS68
$32.6 (1 Auctions)
Pop 129
$No Auctions Found
Pop 129
$24.82 (3 Auctions)
Pop 154
$34.16 (4 Auctions)
Pop 156
$19.75 (3 Auctions)
Pop 426

KS-D MS69
$223.38 (4 Auctions)
Pop 31
$228.76 (2 Auctions)
Pop 31
$167.09 (6 Auctions)
Pop 38
$170.45 (3 Auctions)
Pop 38
No Auctions Found
Pop 45

KS-P MS69
No Auctions Found
Pop 14
No Auctions Found
Pop 14
$486.52 (2 Auctions)
Pop 19
$305. (1 Auction)
Pop 20
No Auctions Found
Pop 29

WV-D MS68
$89. (1 Auctions)
Pop 163
No Auctions Found
Pop 163
$38.90 (2 Auctions)
Pop 177
$46.62 (1 Auction)
Pop 354
$47.92 (3 Auctions)
Pop 484

WV-P MS68
$43.35 (5 Auctions)
Pop 259
$26.05 (3 Auctions)
Pop 259
$15.04 (4 Auctions)
Pop 308
$13.80 (7 Auctions)
Pop 422
$12.99 (1 Auction)
Pop 814

WV-D MS69
No Auctions Found
Pop 2
No Auctions Found
Pop 2
No Auctions Found
Pop 2
No Auctions Found
Pop 2
No Auctions Found
Pop 2

WV-P MS69
$122. (3 Auctions)
Pop 50
$108.01 (2 Auctions)
Pop 50
$80.85 (4 Auctions)
Pop 71
$68.61 (7 Auctions)
Pop 73
$61.49 (2 Auctions)
Pop 99

10c-D MS68
No Auctions Found
Pop 7 : FB Pop 1
No Auctions Found
Pop 7 : FB Pop 1
$12.03 (2 Auctions; both NO FB)
Pop 225 : FB Pop 16
No Auctions Found
Pop 306 : FB Pop 23
$9.27 (2 Auctions; both NO FB)
Pop 363 : FB Pop 50

10c-P MS68
No Auctions Found
Pop 70 : FB Pop 7
No Auctions Found
Pop 70 : FB Pop 7
No Auctions Found
Pop 226 : FB Pop 29
$19.22 (3 Auctions; all NO FB)
Pop 321 : FB Pop 29
No Auctions Found
Pop 391 : FB Pop 96

10c-D MS69
No Auctions Found
Pop 5 : FB Pop 1
No Auctions Found
Pop 5 : FB Pop 1
$44.48 (2 Auctions; both NO FB)
Pop 60 : FB Pop 2
$39.01 (NO FB)
Pop 74 : FB Pop 2
No Auctions Found
Pop 74 : FB Pop 2

10c-P MS69
No Auctions Found
Pop 22 : FB Pop 7
No Auctions Found
Pop 22 : FB Pop 7
$23.50 (1 Auction; NO FB)
Pop 61 : FB Pop 15
$122.73 (2 Auctions; Both FB)
Pop 61 : FB Pop 15
No Auctions Found
Pop 63 : FB Pop 20

Bison-D MS68
No Auctions Found
Pop 35
$182.5 (1 Auction)
Pop 35
$94.85 (2 Auction)
Pop 49
$76.97 (4 Auctions)
Pop 138
$82.12 (1 Auction)
Pop 151

Bison-P MS68
$40.27 (16 Auctions)
Pop 281
$25.16 (11 Auctions)
Pop 281
$20.96 (19 Auctions)
Pop 432
$20.13 (17 Auctions)
Pop 533
$23.42 (10 Auctions) ("Detached Leg" errors brought more and WERE calculated)
Pop 821

Bison-D MS69
No Auctions Found
Pop 0
$1505.99 (1 Auction)
Pop 0
No Auctions Found
Pop 3
No Auctions Found
Pop 3
No Auctions Found
Pop 3

Bison-P MS69
$120.58 (12 Auctions)
Pop 75
$108.55 (4 Auctions)
Pop 75
$74.91 (4 Auctions)
Pop 117
$66.70 (6 Auctions)
Pop 118
$139.88 (1 Auction)
Pop 165

WW-D MS68
$89. (1 Auctions)
Pop 60
$110.25 (2 Auctions)
Pop 60
$77.63 (4 Auctions)
Pop 92
$41.17 (6 Auctions)
Pop 221
No Auctions Found
Pop 253

WW-P MS68
$43.35 (6 Auctions)
Pop 57
$31.10 (5 Auctions)
Pop 57
$25.23 (6 Auctions)
Pop 177
$21.05 (6 Auctions)
Pop 261
$29.79 (5 Auctions)
Pop 379

WW-D MS69
No Auctions Found
Pop 2
No Auctions Found
Pop 2
No Auctions Found
Pop 2
No Auctions Found
Pop 2
No Auctions Found
Pop 2

WW-P MS69
$122. (1 Auctions) I cant seem to find the auctions, but I have info saying these are $250+ coins
Pop 20
No Auctions Found
Pop 20
$206.50 (1 Auctions)
Pop 36
$234.06 (1 Auction)
Pop 38
$245.00 (2 Auctions)
Pop 47

1c-D MS68
$24.95 (9 Auctions)
Pop 123
$20.98 (4 Auctions)
Pop 123
$15.80 (3 Auctions)
Pop 319
$13.80 (4 Auctions)
Pop 414
$11.99 (5 Auctions)
Pop 501

1c-P MS68
$25.22 (7 Auctions)
Pop 123
$22.86 (4 Auctions)
Pop 123
$18.01 (2 Auctions)
Pop 314
$14.39 (4 Auctions)
Pop 393
$11.33 (3 Auctions)
Pop 553

1c-D MS69
$94.59 (9 Auctions)
Pop 75
$65.36 (4 Auctions)
Pop 75
$55.80 (5 Auctions)
Pop 144
$55.33 (2 Auctions)
Pop 154
No Auctions Found
Pop 162

1c-P MS69
$80.52 (13 Auctions)
Pop 128
$66.10 (4 Auctions)
Pop 128
$50.12 (3 Auctions)
Pop 241
$52.63 (9 Auctions)
Pop 243
No Auctions Found
Pop 295

MikeInFL

Very useful info. Do you have the sample size for each that was used to derive the average? That too would be helpful.

As for where these prices will go, I have no idea whatsoever.

Thanks for sharing...Mike

p8nt

Sample size... as in how many auctions the average was made from?

jcping

Putting the last two auction hammered prices will make the topic more interesting since price is coming down every week and pop is going up every week

p8nt

<< <i>Putting the last two auction hammered prices will make the topic more interesting since price is coming down every week and pop is going up every week >>



Feel free to chime in with more info

itsnotjustme

Interesting. Be neat to see a trend (I know, chime in)

Gandyjai

Great info! THANKS!

Brian

p8nt

I think I will update this every couple of weeks and Ill be sure to leave the old prices on so as to make a comparison.

Stooge

Isn't that amazing fellow Roosie collectors...Not a single auction for a 2005-P/D Roosie to be found!

Later, Paul.

Dan50

There are a lot of auctions for 2005 Roosie's, trouble is they are all in NGC holders. Now the question comes to mind, WHY??

GRANDAM

VERY useful info!!!! PLEASE keep it updates.

THANKS GrandAm

Bochiman

<< <i>Isn't that amazing fellow Roosie collectors...Not a single auction for a 2005-P/D Roosie to be found!

Later, Paul. >>



Does anybody really collect Roosies?


It is cool info to see.....and, trending and last couple of prices are good info to see, as mentioned.

TAP444

maybe you can also post the pops as they increase
to compare with the prices

Wekar

cool info & nice work. I and many others I'm sure are hoping you'll keep this updated for a little while, it'll be interesting to watch the trend, so definitely keep all the old pricing when you post an update for comparison.

p8nt may not be a collectors club member? maybe someone who is could post or pm him the pops, which would also be interesting to see along with the pricing.

p8nt

I am a member and have access to the pops. Im working on it. Im going to update the prices every 2 weeks (So the old ones have a chance to cycle through and not be counted again). I just need some more free time

mademan

GREAT WORK- KEEP IT UP-by the way I think p8nt is a YN if I am not mistaken. I feel the future of numismatics is safe.-Don/MM

p8nt

Mademan, you would be correct in that Id love to have a job in numismatics as long as it could support myself. Oh wow that would be fun to be a grader or professional photographer or maybe even a dealer..

p8nt

TTT so a friend can find it.

p8nt

jcping

Thank you for the update. It seems that price dropped about 25% across the board in a week with only a few exceptions

Wekar

<< <i>Thank you for the update. It seems that price dropped about 25% across the board in a week with only a few exceptions >>


This can't be right, dealers keep saying the prices will keep increasing. Maybe we need to get the word out to more eBay bidders that they need to keep paying more for these.


Thanks for the update P8nt!

LindeDad

Some of the initial surge of I have to have it first seems to be wearing off. And it looks like 68's might be a common as 66's were a couple of years ago. At least that is what I notice about the quarters and half's.

TAP444

Looks like the pops have updated
showing the
SAC-D 68 -217 05 half -p 68-415
SAC-D 69 -18 05 half-p 69-155
SAC-P 68 -396 05 half-d 68-29
SAC-P 69-108 05 half-d 69-ZERO
looks like a decent jump
05cent -P 68-231
05cent-P 69-226
05cent-P 70-10
05cent-D 68-231
05cent-D 69-136
05cent-D 70 -2

ellewood

TAP444,

Can you post pops for the P & D lincolns in 68, 69 & 70?

TAP444

done

rb7557

Great post. I don't know how many of you check out teletrade these days, I 've seen stronger money bid
on the sf coins than what is bid at ebay. Makes some of the ebay final prices look like a steal. There was an 05d WW in ms69 that went on Wed for $1650. May be a while before these hit ebay. But whats funny there, you don't see where coins you bid on actually sold. Some of bids are crazy money!

TAP444

if you don't see where it sold, then it was a buyback by the owner
and did not sell

ellewood

MORE INPUT FOLKS...

I just had a 2005-P Lincoln MS69RDSF on eBay for one week...reserve starting at $59.99....IT DID NOT SELL.

I just had two 2005-D Lincolns MS68RDSF on eBay for one week...reserve starting at $29.99 THEY DID NOT SELL.

Two or three weeks ago, people were paying $90+ for MS69's.....and $30+ for MS68's.....

Now...you can barely unload the 68's for more than $20 and the 69's are going for barely $40!!!

Seems to me the only people that are making real bucks here are the lucky ones holding the 70RD's!!!!!

I just got a nice pair of 69RD's back from PCGS on my 4 free gradings and I'm stuck holding the bag on three 68RD's....oh well.

coinrookie

I think the nickels in SF69 will perform quite well for a fair amount of time.

Steve

p8nt

THIS WEEKS UPDATE!

Wekar

I see the beginnings of a career in research, thanks for another update

There was a post on the US Coin Forums about where are the Roosies, and it still applies... where are all the Roosie auctions? where are those coins going? Are they really all being submitted by collectors who intend to keep them? that just seems too weird.

Dabigkahuna

Very nice work!

Great thread, thanks!



Larry
Dabigkahuna

jcping

Thanks for the update. Another down week ......

p8nt

Im hoping these stabalize soon or go up some. I have a submission of 20 in right now...

rb7557

There was a ms70 Ca-p on teletrade tonight. Realized $1050. Check it out Ca-p ms70 sf. I really have to wonder what that spot is above the eyebrow.

jcping

The last two statehood quarters MS70SF on ebay was $850 (MN-P and OR-P)

CoinFame

<< <i>The last two statehood quarters MS70SF on ebay was $850 (MN-P and OR-P) >>



I would say the new owner of those two coins did very well based on the rarity.

ellewood

My 2005-P MS69RD SF Lincoln Cent just went for $46 on eBay. Down from $80???? Talk about prices spiraling downward FAST! My two 2005-D's Lincolns in MS68 are on the BIN board because they didn't even sell at $19!!! The only people that really made out like champs are the guys that had their coins into PCGS first. No one knew what kind of pops we would see.

I am a perfect example. I paid a dealer $34 for a 2005-D in MS68....and am having trouble selling it at $15 because I got back a handful of 69RD's from my free gradings at PCGS. Guess I should have waited, huh? When I start feeling blue about a $23 loss...I just remind myself of those people out there paying thousands for the MS70 specimens!!!!

p8nt

Quite a few of us have some in right now. I almost thought about telling PCGS not to grade them and Ill pay the return shipping... I think Im going to break about even.. despite all the work.. and cut up mint sets.. and shipping.. and effort to sell them... Ugh.

ellewood

Luckily, I didn't pay a red cent for either of my 4 lincolns to be graded. All 4 were sent in on "freebies" and I was 3/4 on 69RD's with only 1 68RD. I did spend the $34 on the 68RD before I knew what I was getting back from PCGS

Good luck with it...maybe you'll get a break and get the 13th 70RD!!!!

p8nt

I did modern so its only $14 per coin. Ive had great sucess with modern times.. I had a submission in.. entered and shipped in 14 calendar days!

mademan

Hey p8nt- I have found this coin collecting hobby to be a "learn as you go experience" -- if you break even in dollars and cents you are still way ahead in the learning and experience department. I know you are on a limited budget and every dollar counts but you are quickly becoming one of the "good guys". By that I mean you are honest, hardworking and people come to take what you say as the unabridged truth(at least I do)- nobody wins them all but the ones that remain are the ones that keep on plugging away. My theory is the next submission will be "KILLER" and I don't dwell on the past ones. Keep up the good work and live for the next submission. PS I remember your first post 6 months ago- Look at what you have accomplished in that short period of time. I am somewhat new at this myself and have come to realize there are certain people on the boards who are real experts at their chosen specialty. I come to depend on these people for help. I now concider you one of these people because of the "massive " effort you have put into the tracking on these Satin Finish coins. My rules for success at any given endevour are Don't Lie, Don't Cheat and Tell the truth. So far it appears you you are a success. Keep up the good work-I am depending on you---Don/the mademan-

p8nt

Prices are stabilizing and some are going up.

babboonbobo2

Thank You for this info, keep up the good work.
Bob

quarterguy

Great work!!!

I honestly believe that a lot of the 68s and 69s sold were true bargains.

I know it is still early but pops in low 100s range for less than the grading fees is a steal.

Ebay is flooded with 05 SF coins from people trying to get their money back.

I have had over 300 2005 coins graded already and I am a buyer on Ebay!

Dan50

Nice work p8nt nice work.

p8nt

Updated! More than 4 months since the last one!

zkcoins

Great info.... One of my favorite posts.

BECOKA

Wow, this is some nice data. Good job.

FullStepJeffs

My friend Mr Paint...

After a year tracking Jeffersons for the price guide I did last year, you might find the quest you've started to be overwhelming at times, but I for one, can't wait to see how this one turns out.

Keep up the good work!

Steve