Reggie rookie...what would it grade?

zef204

I got this a while back in an obscure auction a while back from (ebay tag) room_to_spare_auctioneering. They titled it real poorly and actaully the Sosa Leaf rookie PSA 9 that I asked about came from this lot. It also came with 89 score Sheffieldand Johnson, 82 D Rip, 88 d Grace, 86 Donruss Rookies Bonds(which also fetched a PSA 9), 90 D Griff??, 83 F Boggs(which is a strong 8/ borderline 9), 83 F Sandburg, and 84 t Mattingly. The ones mentioned above were pictured and the Reggie was a bonus when the package came. The lot was titled something like "rookie cards," no year, make or names were in the title.

Anywhoo, I was wondering any opinions on what this would grade, what it could sell for at the grade you assign, and what you think it could sell for raw.

Gemmy10

I would say PSA 4 or 5. It has soft corners and edge. It's Off Center also but the centering falls within the PSA 5 grade I believe.

SDSportsFan

Considering the condition of the corners and the lower right edge, I'd expect no higher than a 4.

SMR on a 5 is $85, so I'd think it would get around $40, maybe $50.


Steve

A761506

I would say 4... looks a bit too worn for a 5.

Selling it... probably would come out about the same either way after factoring in grading/shipping costs. It would cost you $12 plus a portion of the total shipping charges to get that card PSA graded, I think it would be difficult to justify with that card.

mudflap02

My 1969 PSA 4 for comparison. I think I got lucky with this one. The Reggie I would put at 4 or a slider 5.

stevek

4

goudeygold

I agree. It should be a 4. sell it raw.

GG